Supreme Court Flashcards
Who are the current supreme court justices?
John Roberts, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, Amy Coney Barrett, Ketanji Brown Jackson.
What is the current split of the court?
6-3 Conservative.
What are the characteristics of the Roberts Court?
Most conservative court since 1946-53. Major rulings on gun control, LGBT rights, campaign finance.
What were the characteristics of the Rehnquist Court?
More conservative than the previous court, less conservative than the court after. Promoted policies of new federalism, more power given to states, at the expense of federal government. Moved to the right at the end.
What were the characteristics of the Burger court?
Seen as the last liberal court. Transitional from liberal rulings of warren to Rehnquist court. Less generous interpretation of fourth and fifth amendment.
What are the steps of ascendency to the Supreme court?
Vacancy, Presidential nomination, white house review, paperwork and financial disclosure, FBI investigation, senate confirmation hearings, senate vote.
What type of majority is needed for confirmation to pass the senate?
A simple majority.
Why was Robert Bork rejected by the senate?
His controversial views on civil rights, abortion, and executive power.
Why was G Harold
Carswell rejected by the senate?
Concerns about his qualifications, previous offensive comments on women, commitment to equality.
Why was Clement Haynsworth rejected by the Senate?
Concerns over his judicial record, too Conservative, out of step with evolving social landscape.
Why did Ruth Bader Ginsburg receive over 90% of votes in the senate?
Extensive legal background, judicial philosophy, public support, more bipartisan tradition.
Why did Antonin Scalia receive over 90% of votes in the senate?
Long legal reputation, strict interpretation of constitution, bipartisan support, lack of controversy.
Why did Sandra Day O’ Connor receive over 90% of votes in the senate?
Moderate judicial philosophy, strong, legal background, historical significance.
Why was Harriet Miers’ nomination withdrawn?
Lack of judicial experience, concern about lack of conservative decision making, public pressure.
Why was John Roberts’ nomination withdrawn?
His original application was withdrawn, for him to become chief justice.
Why was Clarence Thomas’ nomination passed with a tight vote in the senate?
Controversial record, sexual harassment allegations, partisan divisions, too conservative.
Why was Brett Kavanaugh’s nomination tight in the senate?
Appointment was controversial because of alleged sexual assault, and his legal record was attacked.
Why was Merrick Garland’s nomination never voted on?
It was announced, but the GOP controlled senate refused to hold a vote in an election year.
What are the arguments for the appointment and confirmation process?
Ensures candidates are qualified, involved multiple branches of government, ensures judicial independence, ensures scrutiny of nominees, encourages debate, respects constitution. Stability.
What are the arguments against the appointment and confirmation process?
Could become political, based on who controls the senate. Imbalance due to lifetime appointments. Unequal opportunities. Lack of consistency in standards, influence of interest groups.
What are the different philosophies of justices?
Strict constitutionalists, loose constitutionalists.
What are strict constitutionalists?
Requires a judge to apply the text only as it’s spoken. Once the court has a clear meaning, no further investigation is needed.
What are loose constitutionalists?
Requires a judge to make inferences. Read between the lines, in order to form a statute.
What is an example of a strict constitutional decision?
Dobbs v. Jackson.
What is an example of a loose constitutional decision?
Roe v. Wade.
Which party usually appoints Strict Constitutionalists?
Republicans.
Which party usually appoints Loose Constitutionalists?
Democrats.
What is Judicial Activism?
Judges believe they have a duty to interpret the constitution, so their decision will change the way society operates.
What is an Activist court?
Judges see this as interpreting the constitution positively, in order to put things right.
What are the arguments for judicial activism?
Can bring about necessary social change, protection of rights, checks on legislature and executive power. Judicial responsibility, state laws are likely to promote values which aren’t acceptable.