Summary & Indictable Offences Flashcards
What are the 3 categories of offences?
- Summary offence
- Indictable offence
- Hybrid/elective offence
What is a summary offence?
- Usually less serious offences such as traffic offences and petty crime
- Tried by a judge alone
- If you are charged with a summary offence you do not have the right to have a trial by jury
- Usually proceed through the justice system much faster than indictment
- Max penalty of two years imprisonment
- the statute that creates the offence must clearly say that it can be dealt with summarily. If it does not, then the offence is indictable
What is an indictable offence?
- More serious offences e.g. murder
- Require a trial by judge and jury
- If you are charged with an indictable offence and choose to plead ‘not guilty’, you are guaranteed the right to a trial by jury
What is a hybrid/elective offence?
- indictable offences that allow the accused to choose whether to have the matter dealt with summarily i.e. the accused can choose not to have a trial by jury and have the matter dealt with by a judge alone
Where are indictable offences heard?
Supreme Court (murder and treason) or District Court (manslaughter)
What is the benefit of having a matter dealt with summarily?
The matter may be resolved much faster than if you have a jury trial
Where can the classification of ‘indictable’ offences to ‘hybrid’ offences be found?
Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW) Schedule 1: Tables 1 & 2
What are the two tiers of justice?
- Summary hearings
2. Trial upon indictment
What are Table 1 offences?
- More serious elective offences
- both Prosecutor and Defendant have the power to elect to proceed on indictment
- s 260(1) CPA
What are Table 2 offences?
- less serious elective offences
- only Prosector has power of election
- s 260(2) CPA
Why would a Defendant not elect to proceed to trial on indictment?
- It disadvantages them
- Exposes an individual to a higher maximum penalty
Why would a Defendant elect to proceed to trial on indictment?
Really want to be tried by a jury which isnt available in DC
What factors might influence the Prosecutor in deciding whether or not to elect for a trial on indictment?
- The seriousness of the offence
2. The penalty available to the court
Features of summary hearings
- expedient for efficient enforcement of statutory regulations
- maintenance of quiet and good order of society
- presided over by magistrate
Who presides over summary hearings?
Magistrate