Sudbery Flashcards
How many live births have some kind of genetic disorder?
- approx 8% (but estimates vary) have some sort recognisable before adulthood
Are genetic diseases rare?
- individually rare but collectively common
What are most genetic disorders caused by?
- single gene mutation (= single gene disorders = SGD)
What major birth defects are there?
- chromosomal
- mitochondrial
- complex (multifactorial)
How common are complex diseases?
- before we die 2/3 will suffer from one
What are complex diseases?
- genetic component in etiology
- susceptibility caused by alleles at 100s-1000s lico and v heavily mod by env (interaction between genes and env)
Do freqs of SGDs vary, whats an eg.?
- yes, vary in diff pops
- eg. CF v common (1 in 500) in N. Europe, but rare everywhere else
What are some eg.s of common complex disorders?
- rheumatoid arthritis, epilepsy, MS, type I/II diabetes
- psychiatric disorders –> alzheimer’s, schizophrenia, autism
- congenital defects –> cleft lip and palate, pyloric stenosis
What is the missing heritability problem?
- amount of genetic variability identified through GWAS etc. doesn’t account for variation of heritability disorders
Where are SGDs catalogued?
- OMIM (online mendelian inheritance in man)
How many SGDs are there?
- ≈5000 disorders affection ≈3400 genes (so mutations in some genes responsible for more than 1 disorder)
- total no. documented = ≈7400
- ≈20,000 human genes
How common are chromosomal disorders prenatally?
- ≈8% clinically recognisable conceptions terminate due to chromosomal abnormalities
- but may be 50% of all conceptions (but most terminate before know pregnant)
How common are chromosomal disorders in live births, and what types are there?
- 0.1%
- aneuploidies –> Down’s syndrome (trisomy 21), Edwards syndrome (trisomy 18)
- translations
How significant is the mito genome?
- 16kb, so much smaller than nuclear DNA, but sig amount by weight
What do mito disorders cause?
- multi system failures –> basal ganglia (causing ataxia), heart, endocrine system, sight and hearing, skeletal muscle
When does maternal inheritance and what does this cause?
- if mother heteroplasmic
- variable phenotype in siblings
- progressive onset
- diff degrees of severity in diff organs
What might accum of mtDNA (and therefore O free radicals) be involved in?
- ageing
Why bother identifying variants responsible for SGD?
- stopping repeated medical tests which may be invasive and distressing –> not needed as know diagnosis
- introd approp treatment and stop inapprop treatment (eg. for epilepsy usually have to try series of medication till find what works, but if know mutation, know treatment)
- psychological benefits to affected and family
- scientific knowledge
What are the difficulties w/ diagnosing rare diseases?
- genetic heterogeneity in medically well characterised disorders (sometimes over 50 genes) –> so diseases can be caused by mutations in many genes
- atypical disease presentation
- novel variant in known gene
What are some eg.s of diseases that genetically heterogenous?
- polydactyly
- retinitis pigmentosa
- lipid metabolism
What other problems is there w/ identifying alleles responsible or rare diseases (apart from w/ diagnosis)?
- if novel disorder but suspected SGD
- or documented disorder w/ unknown genetic basis
How has identifying genes assoc w/ disorders progressed?
- originally mapping
- now WES/WGS
- downward trend of genes identified in recent years
What are WES and WGS?
- WES = whole exome sequencing
- WGS = whole genome sequencing
Why is WES used and not WGS?
- SGD so far all in coding seq
- cheaper
- fewer variants to analyse (coding seq under selective pressure so less variation, unlike intergenic seq)
Where are complex disease variants usually found in genome?
- nearly all outside coding seq, in intergenic seq
- prob affect expression of coding seq
If each individual shows approx 20,000 variants after WES, then how can we identify causative variant of a SGD?
- predicted effect on protein function –> exclude any that don’t affect coding seq (ie. silent/replacement), look at whether AA changes are conservative (if not, bigger effect, eg. hydrophobic for hydrophilic)
- disease allele will be rare, look at pop databases –> if recessive have to look for homozygous variant, doesn’t have to be same mutation as long as affects same gene
- same allele in unrelated indivs w/ same disorder –> if unaffecteds too can rule out
- expert appraisal of biological relevance to disorder phenotype –> recapitulation in model system/organism and look at seq conservation
- databases of pathogenic variants (think genes not alleles)
What types of mutation can lead to loss of function, and how can loss of function be predicted/assessed?
- likely to lead to loss of function –> by frameshift, protein terminating variant (PTV), splice sites, exon deletions
- function prediction, eg. polar substitution in TM domain
- seq conservation
assessed by computer programmes, eg. SIFT, Polyphenz
When can usually loss of function mutations not be harmful and why?
- frameshift and PTV if near end of ORF don’t have much effect
What was ExAC?
- exome aggregation consortium
- 60,000 exomes and identifies v rare alleles
- looks at pop freq to identify which alleles are v rare and which pot harmful alleles occur freq in apparently healthy indivs
- the size of the database is key
What has ExAC now been succeeded by?
- gnomAD –> 123,000 WES an 15,000 WGS
- multiple other databases now exist
What is the problem with pop databases, such as ExAC?
- most exome info from European originating pops, so not representative of other pops
- ie. something could be rare in Europeans, but common in other pops and not diseases causing
Is it common to carry pot harmful mutations?
- yes, we all carry 100s of them
- mostly heterozygous missense mutations
- 1 in 5 homozygous for a rare PTV
How can you match affected indivs who are geographically separate?
- need precise phenotype description
- controlled vocab –> human phenotype ontogeny (HGO)
- allows computer matching, eg. GENEMATCHER
Why is it important to allow matching of affected indivs?
- estimated 1000 genes w/ good candidate causal variant but not rep in unrelated cases
What is the major ethical problem with databases, eg. for phenotypic descriptions of diseases?
- data sharing (need all data for gene matching)
- fundamental right to indiv privacy of genetic info
- but sharing of genetic data and phenotypic description vital
What is an eg. of how ExAC database has been used for a specific condition?
- to identify relevant genes in cardiomyopathy
- can see if more mutations in healthy than affected indivs, then not relevant gene
How can you characterise a recessive pedigree?
- may be compound heterozygote –> may not be exactly same bp change, but affecting same gene
- will be heterozygous in each parent (assuming no non-paternity)
- heterozygous siblings not affected
How can you characterise a consanguineous pedigree?
- same allele in each gene
- only affected members of pedigree are homozygous
How can you characterise a de novo dominant pedigree?
- new allele not present in either parent
- heterozygous mutation not present in parents, but shared w/ other indep affecteds
- an affected parent is less likely to have children, therefore de novo more likely
Why is standardisation needed?
- to ensure compatibility between diff countries w/ diff medical organisations and diff labs
What is the simplest eg. of a consanguineous pedigree?
- cousin marriage
What are the consequences of a consanguineous autosomal recessive pedigree?
- allele in shared relative could be v rare, but sporadic occurrence could be freq in children and could be only cases of disease
- homozygous variant in each affected
How does the distance of the relationship between affecteds affect the amount of rare homozygous variants, in a consanguineous autosomal recessive pedigree?
- the more distant the relationship, the fewer homozygous regions to analyse
- children of cousins have 15-20 homozygous rare variants
- children of 3rd cousins have only 5-10 homozygous rare variants
What is the proband?
- indiv in pedigree who 1st comes to medical attention
What is a case study of a consanguineous autosomal recessive condition?
- proband was 16 y/o Saudi Arabian girl w/ complex symptoms shared w/ 8 consanguineous relatives
- suggestive of complex neurotransmitter disorders
- -> dopamine: parkinsonism, non-ambulation, global developmental delay, hypotonia
- -> serotonin: sleep and mood disturbances
- -> adrenaline: diaphoresis, temp instability
- neurotransmitter levels normal, but dopamine breakdown products elevated in urine
What treatment was initially tried in this consanguineous case study, and what was the effect?
- treatment to increase dopamine levels
- caused immediate worsening of condition
How was this case study of a consanguineous pedigree investigated further by mapping?
- needed to map and look for regions of homozygosity
- by looking at SNPs distrib over 3.2 mb region
- calc LOD score as 4.1 –> means matching of alleles would occur by chance 1 in 10,000 (so v unlikely)
What is a LOD score?
- stat test whether likely to occur by chance (threshold score)
What did mapping reveal about the consanguineous case study?
- found 8 genes w/ neuronal function
- identified p.pro387leu mutation in SLC18A2, encoding VMAT2 dopamine transporter
- highly conserved residue –> transporter in ec loop that holds TM domain together
- homozygous in all affected, but not in unaffected
- not in >1000 patients in Parkinson’s study (affecting dopamine but not classic mutation involved in Parkinson’s, hence other symptoms
What does the nomenclature p.pro387leu mean?
- p = protein
- leu sub for pro at position 387
What is the role of the VMAT2 dopamine transporter, and what is its importance in assoc w/ this case study?
- transports serotonin and dopamine into presynaptic vesicles
- w/in presynaptic vesicles dopamine converted to adrenaline
- therefore providing a link between all 3 neurotransmitters assoc w/ disease)
What happened when they expressed WT and mutant VMAT2 in tissue culture?
- reduction, but not complete loss of activity (makes sense as proband alive at 16)
- so less dopamine going across synapse
After discovering the role of VMAT2 how was this targeted in the consanguineous case study?
- need to target monamine receptor
- treatment w/ dopamine receptor agonist resulted in dramatic improvement w/in 7 days and maintained for 32 months
What does the SLC18A2/VMAT2 study show?
- homozygosity mapping
- choosing candidate genes by hypothetical function
- mutation affecting functional part of protein
- mutation in highly conserved seq
- mutation present in affected but not unaffected
- recapitulation of phenotype in in vitro model
- diagnosis and treatment in rare and novel disorder (new gene, new disorder)
What are the characteristics of an autosomal dominant pedigree?
- heterozygous variant in affected family members
- not present in unaffected
- generally difficult, as need mapping info (unlikely to have children so harder to look at pedigree)
What are the symptoms of Floating Harbor Syndrome?
- dysmorphic syndrome –> triangular face, long narrow nose, short filtram
- short stature
- intellectual disability
- language defects
- 13 indep indivs
How was SRCAP identified as the mutation involved in Floating Harbor Syndrome?
- by comparing indivs can narrow down mutations occurring in all 5 studied
- SRCAP was gene affected in all 5 studied
- SRCAP is a Snf2-related chromatin remodelling ATPase and cofactor for CREB BP
What is the role of chromatin remodelling complexes (CRMs), and how do they carry this out?
- DNA assoc w/ nucleosomes can be inaccessible to DNA BPs
- have DNA helicase activity that can push DNA into nucleosomes
- causing them to “slide” along DNA
- CRMs can bind to activation or repression domains of TFs
What are the majority of Diamond-Blackfan Anaemia caused by?
- 50-70% cases due to autosomal dominant mutations in 10 genes encoding ribosomal proteins (ribosomopathy)
What kind of mutations are involved in Diamond-Blackfan Anaemia?
- heterogenous –> caused by mutations in diff genes
What was discovered by studying 2 brothers w/o ribosomal gene mutation?
- 31 mutations in both but only 1 on X-chromosome
- affecting splicing of exon GATA1 TF, which controls dev of RBCs –> variable splicing, so affected inherit C and unaffected inherit G
- prod less GATA1 protein
What is a summary of the pathway to finding a causative mutation?
- disease causing mutations should be rare
- v large databases of variants in healthy indivs
- we all have multiple rare, apparently gene-inactivating mutations (not necessarily disease causing)
- pedigree info
- disease mutation database
- some mutation in affected but not in unaffected
- recapitulation in model system
What are the problems with identifying v rare diseases, where there is an unknown disease and unknown gene?
- matching multiple indivs w/ same rare disease
- data sharing vital for assigning mutations to genes –> but privacy issues when genetic info made widely available on web-based databases
- accuracy of phenotypic descriptions –> need controlled vocab to standardise
Is CF found in non-caucasians?
- yes, but if in non-Europeans can usually trace heritage back to Europeans at some point
How is the carrier frequency for CF calc w/ H-W?
- q^2 = 1:2000 affected
- q = √1/2000 = 1/44
- carrier freq = 2pq = 2 x 43/44 ≈ 1/22
What are the pulmonary symptoms of CF?
- thick dehydrated mucous (so cilia cant move it out of lungs
- repeated bacterial infections (S. aureus, P. aeruginosa) –> get lodged in lungs and not removed (and fungal infections)
- chronic inflam, overprod of elastase, irreversible lung damage
What are the non-pulmonary symptoms of CF?
- pancreatic exocrine deficiency
- diabetes congenital
- bilateral absence of vas deferens (BAVD)
- congenital bowel obstruction
- salty sweat (diagnostic test)
What does autozygous mean?
- genotype of homozygote where genes are copies of identical ancestral gene as result of consanguineous mating
What is the most common CF causing mutation, and how common is it?
- 70% alleles = phe508del
- 90% cases have at least 1 phe508del allele (so useful for diagnosis)
How many other CF causing mutations are there?
- approx 15 other mutations responsible for 1/2 remaining cases among Europeans
- over 2000 private mutations catalogued (only identified in single families)
What is a similar protein to CFTR in bacteria, and what is its role?
- ABC cassette transporter protein (membrane protein)
- pump antibodies out of cell
What is the phe508del mutation?
- 3 base deletion so lose 1 AA (Phe) but maintain ORF
Why has the phe508del mutation remained in the gene poss when it is so deleterious?
- poss heterozygote advantage –> protects from infantile cholera as less water lost in diarrhoea and point of entry of Salmonella
What is the result of the CF mutation?
- CFTR (CF transmembrane regulatory protein) forms pore in membrane and pumps CL- out
- have ASL (airway surface liquid) surrounding cell –> made up PCL (periciliary layer) which lubricates mucus (mainly water), then mucus and cilia beat in PCL to move mucus
- on other side of cell is transporter to move Na+ out and Na+ diffuses round
- get NaCl secreted on cell surface –> makes ASL more osmotically hypertonic, so suck water out of cell by osmosis, keeping ASL hydrated
- CFTR also inhibits ENaC channel –> ENaC channel absorbs Na+ from surface, so inhibits inward flow if Na+
- so in patients lacking CFTR no Cl- out, no inhibition of ENaC channel and PCL collapses, cilia can’t cope, so no mucus movement
What therapies are there for CF to treat the symptoms, and therefore prolong life expetancy?
- physiotherapy = percussion therapy
- DNAse to decrease mucus viscosity
- antibiotics (decrease bacterial infections)
- anti inflammatories, eg. steroids (as chronic inflam responsible for a lot of damage)
- mannitol spray to increase osmolarity of mucus (increase hydration)
How could gene therapy be used to treat CF, and what are the problems?
- viral vectors w/ tropism for airways –> but immune responses prevent repeated therapy
- liposomes –> but poor delivery, research ongoing
How did Vertex pharmaceuticals use precision medicine according to the CF mutation?
POTENTIATORS = Ivacaftor, helps keep channel open
- class III, reduced gating Gly551Asp, Phe508del
- class IV, reduced conductance
- class VI, high surface turnover, Phe508del
CORRECTORS = Lumacaftor, helps protein fold correctly so can get to surface, but still not as open as much as should be - class II, misfolded and degraded Phe508del
PRODUCTION CORRECTORS = Alaluren
- class I, no CFTR Gly542X
- class V, v low CFTR levels 3849 and 10kb C–>T
Who decides if a drug works and if cost effective for NHS?
- NICE (National Institute for Health and Excellence
What diff indicators do NICE look at?
- Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) = generic measure of disease burden inc quality and quantity of life, 1 QALY = 1 year in perfect health
- Standard of Care (SoC) = how much longer would have good standard of life comp to no drug
- incremental cost-effectiveness ratio = diff in cost between 2 intercalations (new and current)
Is Lumacaftor and Ivacaftor a cost effective treatment for CF cases w/ phe508del allele?
- both drugs v expensive due to cost of dev
- plausible ICER of £30,000 per QALY gained, but was approx £220,000
Does Ivacaftor work and for how many CF cases is it effective?
- Gly551Asp in ≈5% CF patients
- yes, trials show 10% increase in forced expiratory vol (gets progressively lower w/ disease), decrease to half rate of exacerbations, normal sweat salt conc, reduced Pseudomonas infections and increased QoL
Was Ivacaftor justified as a drug on the NHS and why?
- costs = £182,000
- discounted ICER £285
- NHS commissioning group agreed treatment for under 5s
- justified as “ultra-orphan” drug (only drug for disease, no other option)
Why is a disorder affecting muscles v serious?
- most abundant body tissue
How much of the body weight does muscle make up?
- 23% in females
- 40% in males