Subs and general Flashcards
What are the 5 methods of valuation?
- Comparative
- Investment
- Residual
- Profits
- DRC
When is the comparative method used?
For vacant and owner occupied properties with good comparable evidence available. E.g. owner-occupied house.
When is the investment method used?
For investments with an income stream to be valued. E.g. commercial property held as an investment.
When is the residual method used?
For properties where the value lies in development value and to find the value of a site at a particular point in time. E.g. development site.
When is the profits method used?
For properties where value is based on trading potential and business profitability, often where there is a monopoly position. E.g. pubs and hotels.
When is the Depreciated Replacement Cost method used?
Unusual and specialised assets where direct evidence is unavailable or limited. E.g. lighthouses, state schools, docks.
How can the 5 valuation methods be categorised in 3 approaches?
- Income approach - converts cash flow into capital - investment, residual, profits
- Cost-based approach - DRC
- Market approach - comparable
For what purposes might a valuation be undertaken?
- Loan security
- Internal purposes
- Litigation
- Statutory functions such as statutory return
- Negotiation
- Sale or purchase
What is the latest Red Book and when is it effective from?
Valuation - Global Standards 2021, effective from January 2022
What were the key changes from the last Red Book to the current?
- VPGA 1 - Valuation for financial reporting purposes with reference to IFRS 16 - fair value
- VPGA 4 - Examples of use of the profits method for trade-related valuations including purpose built student housing
ESG focus: - VPS 2 & 3 - (Inspection and reporting) valuers should have consideration to ESG when collecting data and in their valuation approach and reasoning
- VPGA 2 (valuation for secured lending) - ESG should be integral to the approach and comments should be provided on relevant upcoming costs
Under VPGA 8, what are examples of direct and indirect valuation factors, physical and transition risks with regard to ESG?
Direct - e.g. storms or flood risk
Indirect - e.g. resilience and carbon emissions
Physical risks - e.g. heat and wildfires
Transition risks - e.g. regulatory change
What is the difference between IVS and the RICS Red Book?
International Valuation Standards are published by the IVS council, an independent body, these standards are fully adopted by the Red Book, which provides further standards and guidance for RICS valuers.
What are the 5 requirements for a Red Book TOE which are not required by IVS?
- Statement of compliance with IVS
- Statement that the RICS may monitor
- CHP
- Fee
- Limit on liability
What are the different Red Book standards and who do they apply to?
Professional Standards (PS) - mandatory for all members providing written valuations
Valuation Technical and Performance Standards (VPS) - Mandatory for provision of IVS-compliant valuations
Valuation Practice Guidance Applications (VPGA) - Practical guidance on ‘best practice’
How does the Red Book define ESG?
Environmental, social and governance - Criteria that establishes the framework for assessing the impact of sustainability and ethical practices of a company on its financial performance and operations. Comprises environmental, social and governance - which collectively contribute to effective performance, with positive benefits for the wider markets, society and world as a whole.
What does VPS 1 cover?
TOE for a Red Book Valuation (IVS 101 Scope of Work)
Under VPS 1 (IVS 101), what must a Red Book TOE cover?
- Identify Client
- Identify valuer and their status (internal/ external)
- Identify asset being valued
- Identify other reliance parties
- Valuation date
- Valuation basis
- Valuation purpose
- Extent of investigations
- Information relied on and sources
- Assumptions and Special Assumptions
- Report format
- Valuation currency
- Restrictions on use, publication and distribution
- Fee basis
- Red Book and IVS compliance
- Statement of RICS compliance
- Limitation on liability
- CHP
What’s the difference between an assumption and a special assumption?
Assumption - reasonable for the valuer to assume this is reality without making specific investigations
Special assumption = knows this isn’t reality, must be agreed in writing at the start of the instruction
What is VPS 2 and what does it cover?
Inspections, Investigations and Planning
Inspections, desktop valuations and revaluations, records
What does VPS 2 say about inspections?
Valuers must take steps to verify information relied on for a valuation and ensure it is adequate for its purpose.
What does VPS 2 say about desktop valuations?
- Desktops are still red book
- Restriction and its valuation implications must be agreed in writing before the value is reported (TOE)
- Consider whether reasonable for valuation purpose
- Refer to restriction in report
What does VPS 2 say about revaluation without inspection?
Valuer must be satisfied there is no material changes to the property or location since the last inspection.
Must confirm in TOE and report.
What does VPS 2 say about records?
Proper records must be kept on inspections, investigations and other inputs, and in an appropriate business format. This includes sufficient ESG data.
What does VPS 2 say about ESG?
Valuers should collect and record appropriate and sufficient sustainability and ESG data for the valuation.
What is VPS 3 and what does it cover?
Valuation Reports (IVS 103 Reporting) - covers minimum report requirements and preliminary reports
What are minimum Red Book report requirements under VPS 3?
- Identify - valuer and their status, the client and other intended users, the asset
- Valuation - The valuation purpose, basis, date
- Information - The extent of investigation, the nature and source of info
-Report - restrictions on use, publication and distribution, report date
Figures - Assumptions and SAs, approach and reasoning, figures
Compliance - Statement that valuation is undertaken in accordance with IVS
Comment on market uncertainty and agreed liability limitations
What is VPS 4 and what does it cover?
Bases of value, Assumptions and Special Assumptions.
Under VPS 4, what are the six bases of value?
Market Value, Market Rent, Fair Value, Investment Value, Equitable Value, Liquidation Value
How does VPS 4 define MV?
Estimated amount for which an asset/ liability should exchange:
- on the valuation date
- between a willing buyer and seller
- arms length transaction
- after proper marketing
- parties acted knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion
How does VPS 4 define MR?
Estimated amount for which an interest in real property should be leased
- on the valuation date
- between a willing lesser and lessee
- on appropriate lease terms
- arms length transaction
- after proper marketing
- parties acted knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion
How does VPS 4 define Fair Value?
“Based on IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards 13)
‘The price that would be received to sell and asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date’”
How does VPS 4 define Investment Value?
Value for a particular owner/ prospective owner for individual investment or objectives, this may differ from MV
Sometimes used to reflect against clients own investment criteria.
Which basis of value is sometimes referred to as worth?
Investment value
Under VPS 4, what is an assumption?
Made where it is reasonable for the valuer to accept that something is
true without the need for specific investigation or verification. Must be reasonable and relevant to the purpose of the valuation.
Under VPS 4, what is a Special Assumption?
Assumption which the valuer knows is not true, or would not typically be made by a market participant, at the valuation date.
If necessary to provide a client with the valuation, must be confirmed in writing prior to report.
Must only be made if they are reasonably considered realistic, relevant and valid for the valuation circumstances.
What is VPS 5 and what does it say?
Valuation approaches and methods (IVS 105)
Valuers are responsible for adopting and justifying approach - must consider the asset, valuation purpose and intended use, statutory requirements, best practice.
Good practice to use multiple methods when appropriate.
What is VPGA 2 and what does it cover?
Valuations for secured lending
Gives guidance on dealing with conflicts and reporting procedures
Under VPGA 2 , what is previous involvement?
Usually involvement with the borrower or property in the last 2 years, but can be longer in some cases.
What are examples of conflicts under VPGA 2?
- Longstanding relationship with the borrower
- Valuer will receive a fee for introduction to the lender
- Valuer has a financial interest in the property
- Valuer retained to act in the disposal or letting of the property
Under VPGA 2 , if a conflict is managed, what must be done?
The conflict and the management arrangements must be recorded in writing in the TOE and report
Under VPGA 2, what additional information needs to be reported in a loan security valuation?
- COI and arrangements in place to manage
- Valuation methodology, supported by calculations if appropriate
- Recent transaction price OR statement that there is no recent price, and the extent to which this has been adopted as market value
- Environmental considerations
- Comment on suitability for secured lending purposes
- Any other factors or circumstances which could affect price or conflict with the definition of MV or underlying assumptions
Under VPGA 2, when a loan security valuation uses a SA, what needs to be included in the report?
Comment on any material differences between MV and the value reported using the SA
What does VPGA 2 say about sustainability?
Sustainability and ESG factors can have significant market influence and loan security valuations should have appropriate regard to their relevant to the particular assignment.
What is VPGA 4 and what does it cover?
Trade related valuations
What is VPGA 8 and what does it cover?
Valuation of real property interests - covers inspection and investigations, with a particular focus on ESG and sustainability
Identifies need to consider direct and indirect valuation factors and physical and transition risks.
Under VPGA 8, what sustainability factors might a valuer consider?
- ESG matters - including climate change and resilience
- configuration and design - including ‘wellness’
- accessibility and adaptability - including disabled use
- Carbon emissions, energy efficiency, building intelligence, other costs in use
- Fiscal considerations
What is VPGA 10 and what does it cover?
Matters that give rise to material uncertainty.
Key is that reports should not be misleading, must detail risk surrounding valuation of the asset, standard caveat shouldn’t be used.
What is PS1?
Compliance with the Red Book
Under PS1, what are the 5 situations where a valuation doesn’t need to be Red Book compliant?
- Negotiation or litigation
- Statutory function (other than statutory tax return)
- Internal purposes (without liability or third party)
- Agency or brokerage work
- Expert witness work