STUDY Flashcards
Please compare aluminium vs composite window?
Aluminium
More durable Holds more weight Greater acoustics Material more expensive Better aesthetics £275/m2 more expensive
Composite Meets performance requirements Cheaper Maintain aesthetics Greater themal properties
Both had life expectancy of 50 years
Aluminium more expense to repair
Glass replacement every 15 yrs
What life cycle costs were considered when you carried out the window?
The supply chain was able to confirm that Composite will have a longer lifespan (if engineered timber)
Replacement of glass is every 15 yrs
Both window types are similar cost for damages
Why Intermediate over minor works?
No L&E
No EOT
No Sec Comp
Can you tell me how you believe Covid / Brexit has effected procurement / tendering?
Unknown impact of covid may lead to contractors being more inclined to seek the more management routes and avoid fixed price routes due to:
- unknown impact on inflation & construction costs generally so difficult to price in their costs
- similar for tendering strategies above
What are the deliverables under the PCSA?
Open book Competitive tender to 3 SCs Carry out design & contribute to buildability & risk Method of construction Work collaboratively w/project team Reconcile target cost plan
What was the further VE you achieved with the Contractor?
£200k 50% tiling
£300k acoustic layer to cheaper alternative
How would your two stage tendering option work? How would you carry out EW alongside PCSA?
Outputs in 1st and 2nd Stages?
1st stage under PCSA Prelims OHP Programme Designed packages PCSA Fee Target Cost Plan to assess against
2nd Stage to develop S2 to S3/4 to arrive at a Contract Sum
Finalise design
Agree outstanding packages
Rules placed into 2nd stage (min 3 tenderers, open book, evaluation)
Contractor in charge of tender
What was the market appetite to work on single stage as opposed to two stage?
Letters of enquiries were sent out to a number of contractors to establish market appetitie and generally the response was positive
However a number of tenderers within the PQQ who pulled out during the PQQ process due to the tender not being two stage.
The reason being:
Design risk on SS
Missed scope
Resource, time and cost
What was specified for the lighting as the saving?
Omission of 6 LED Lights with the addition of 1 ceiling light to the kitchen and living room areas gave saving of £2k/unit
Why was intermediate used?
Intermediate is :
£250k
Adds more robust procedures with regards to EOT and L&E that minor works does not have
How did you back up the elements that could produce savings?
Through benchmarking and market testing.
I would expect to see:
External Walls @ £260/m2 not £300/m2
Glazing @ £110/m2 not £170/m2
In your documents you have highlighted the advantages/ disadvantages of Steel v Concrete. Could you talk me through some of these?
Steel
Advantages:- Quicker to construct- Recyclable- Strong tensile strength Lighter than concrete
Disadvantages- More volatile pricing - Low compression strength - Low sound/fire resistance - Requires soundproofing
Concrete
Advantages
- High compression strength
- Good noise resistance
- Good fire protection
- Low maitenance
Disadvantages
- Slower to construct
- Need for reinforcement
- High embodied carbon-
- Not as square and flat as steel
Are you aware of any renewable technology techniques?
London 0% Carbon Local labour Photo voltaic panels Blue / Green Roof Presence detectors ASHP GSHP
What is embedded carbon?
Embodied carbon is the carbon footprint of a material.
It considers how many GREENHOUSE GASSES are released throughout the supply chain and is often measured from cradle to (factory) gate, or cradle to site (of use)
You mention that you have an understanding on the different choices of facades that can be used for high rise and low buildings. Please explain which facades are commonly used in both cases and why.
Low rise :- Traditional as lower cost and less need for construction to be lighter
High Rise : - greater cost on foundation, SFS system will reduce load bearing capacity moving down the structure
How did grenfell change the way facades are built?
No combustible materials to buildings over 18m
RICS have an EWS Process
- appointed fire professional carries out risk assessment
- Looks at new / existing properties
- Valid for 5 years
Why would you recommend using an SFS over traditionally constructed wall?
3 month Programme / Prelim benefits with concurrent fit out and external wall
Structural implications
No wet trades
What is the cost difference between traditional and SFS?
Around £200/m2 and fairly cost neutral when considering prelims
How did you calculate the cost difference in the prelims with regards to SFS vs blockwork?
Mace logistics were able to advise that using SFS would make a saving to the overall prelims of 2 months
Can you tell me about what forms of modern methods of construction you are aware of?
Modular construction Bathroom Pods 3D Printing Modular grids (internal walls) Minimise unit types Precast stairs Utility cupboards
What are green / brown / blue roof?
A green extensive roof is planted for ecological and aesthetic purposes.
A brown roof is to mirror as best as possible local ecological conditions
A blue roof is onethatstoreswater.
What was the cost difference between steel partition and blockwork?
£50/m2 blockwork (just blockwork)
£100/m2 SFS w/steel mesh
What is an air source heat pump?
- Air drawn in from outside
- Air passes through heat exchanger
- Heat transferred to refrigerant from liquid to gas
- Passes through compressor heating temperature
- LTHW runs through ASHP which is heated by refrigerant
What is an ground source heat pump?
- Buried pipes beneath ground with anti freeze
- Absorbed heat transferred to refrigerant
- Heat transferred to refrigerant from liquid to gas
- Gas passes through compressor heater temperature
- LTHW runs through ASHP which is heated by refrigerant
Talk me through the costs you were able to advise on the SFS vs Blockwork on the facade? And what other considerations aside from cost?
SFS £750/m2 = £5.6m
Blockwork £550/m2 = £4.4m + 3 months of prelims = £1m = £5.4m
3 month quicker construction led to the client accepting this option.
Impacts on structural were positive with SFS
Concurrent process of fit out / facade
Talk me through the savings you were able to make on the blockwork vs SFS w/steel mesh to the internal walls? And what other considerations aside from cost?
3000m2 of area
SFS
£100/m2 +
£40/m2 for steel mesh = £420k
Blockwork
£50/m2
+ 3wk prelims = £240k (£80k / wk) = £390k
Overall £30k difference but client opted for 3 wk quicker construction
Shortage of bricklayers left unknown on costs
How is a steel frame constructed?
Steel columns will be cast into the slab
Installation of universal beams
Beams run across the upper floor area for floor finishes
Purlins to run across the roof
Accessories to fix and tie the frame together
What is the process for RBP?
Form Pile Mat Mobilisation Excavation / disposal Secure excavation w/steel casing / bentonite Insitu conc Rebar Cut piles Test piles
What are the pros and cons of SFS?
Pros Lighter frame Programme benefits Concurrent fit out / facade Prelims savings
Cons
More expensive
Limited suppliers
Fire resistant barrier installed to façade
What are the members of a steel frame?
Beams, Columns, Purlins, Cladding rails, erection, anchors
How did you advise on design efficiencies?
£13m but circa 20% across 8 buildings increase on Net Areas on the projects which would have lead to greater returns on investment for my client
Smaller communal areas
Reduction of overall footprint but keeping the same NIA
Rationalisation of core areas
Thinner internal wall build ups
How did your advise on design economics influence the design?
The design team would have tried as best as possible to reach the targetted NIA:GIA that I set out in the early stage estimates, therefore design reflective of this.
It may mean costs increase, but there will be a greater area of net sellable area for the client to drive returns
Name some assumptions and exclusions in your cost plan?
ASSUMPTIONS 1Q 2020 Base Date Assumed fit out specification Assumes external works specification Assumed for removal of contaminated material
EXCLUSIONS Professional Fees Inflation Land Costs VAT Impacts of Covid-19 & Brexit
How did you present your façade / internal walls options to your client?
This was done in a workshop to run through each option, summarising:
Cost Impact Prelims / Programme Logistics Quality Recommendation