STATUS OF TERMS Flashcards
WHAT IS A CONDITION ??
A condition is a major term of a contract and goes to the heart of the contract if breached the contract will be rendered meaningless and claimant will be allowed the fullest range of remedies the ability to repudiate the contract and claim for damages
(POUSSSARD V SPIERS AND POND)
WHAT IS A WARRANTY??
Minor terms of the contract and not as important as a condition if they are broken they will not end the contract. they are secondary to the purpose of the contract. the only remedy for breach of warranty is damages
(BETTINI V GYE)
INNOMINATE TERMS
comes from Latin word innominatus meaning anonymous.
it does not have any specific classification.Rather than classifying the terms themselves as conditions or warranties, the innominate term approach looks to the effect of the breach and questions whether the innocent party to the breach was deprived of substantially the whole benefit of the contract.
Established in
(THE HONG KONG FIR CASE)
PROBLEMS WITH INNOMINATE TERMS
- sacrificing certainty
(in commercial contracts like shipping contracts where readiness to load clause is treated as a condition (BUNGE V TRADAX)) - innocent party would be liable for wrongful repudiation if they treat the contract as at an end
- uncertainty of the innominate approach, lengthy, costly and futile litigation for those who don’t know their rights(THE CHIKUMA)
-
ADVANTAGES OF INNOMINATE APPROACH
- creating flexibility in the law allowing for courts to make the right and just decision (THE HONG KONG FIR CASE)
- prevents breach of contracts for trivial reasons (THE HANSA NORD)
- prevents escaping unwanted contracts
(REARDON-SMITH LINE V HANSEN-TANGEN) - even though parties may have expressly stated what is a condition and warrant in their contract the courts still have discretion with the innominate term approach to decide if it is a warrant on condition
(SCHULER V WICKMAN TOOLS)
