States Flashcards
Do we live in a world in which states are still the key actors in international relations?
Yes
Why are states still important?
As there is no world government and no system of world law enforcement
In which ancient empires do we find some the key characteristics of the state emerging?
Egypt, Persia, China and Rome
What were the key characteristics of the state to emerge from the ancient empires of Egypt, Persia, China and Rome?
- Rulers employ officials to enforce their decrees
- Armies of full-time soldiers to repel enemies
- Complex legal codes developed
What have the legal systems of contemporary Europe been greatly influenced by?
Roman law
What is it important to note from the Italian city-states of the Renaissance period?
One of the most important precursors of the modern state:
Increasing secularism
What came about with the Reformation in Europe + the clear separation of church and state?
The conditions emerged for the development of a truly modern state system in Europe in which
- no single state is recognised as the hegemony
- all member states agree to recognise each other’s rights to sovereignty
When was the true beginning of the modern state system in Europe?
The Peace of Westphalia in 1648 which marked the end of the Thirty Years War
What was the Thirty Years War?
International conflict between Holy Roman Empire and the powerful sovereign states (eg. France), which sought to ensure they obtained strategic + defensive frontiers
What was the impact of the Peace of Westphalia (1648) on the Holy Roman Empire?
- Power + authority drastically curtailed
- No longer permitted to raise troops, declare wars or make peace, or raise taxes without the consent of members of the state system
According to international law, what do states have to possess?
- A defined territory
- A permanent population
- A government which is capable of maintaining effective control over its territory + conducting relations with other states
Do states always meet the criteria as set out by international law?
No
In what ways do states struggle to meet the criteria set out by international law?
- Many states struggle to maintain control over their territory
- Do not have control of armed forces, resulting in civil wars + insurgents
- This leaves whole areas of country under control of rebel leaders (e.g. Afghanistan, Burma, Somalia)
Why are states that struggle to meet the criteria set out by international law still regarded as states?
- Still receive international recognition
- Sign agreements with other states
- Send delegates to the UN
Why is even external recognition not an absolute criterion of statehood?
- For decades US withheld diplomatic recognition from communist China
- External recognition does not have to be universally accorded before statehood can be achieved
- Enough to have external recognition from considerable no. of powers + especially UN
What is the name of states that have been recognised by the UN as achieving full statehood?
Nation-state
Why is the term ‘nation-state’ useful?
- Almost all sovereign states seek to foster a sense of national identity and loyalty
- eg. an Indian nationalism which transcends local loyalties
- in the UK still strong British nationalism
What is a strong sense of British nationalism rooted in?
- Shared monarchy
- Common central government
- Long experience of close political, economic + social interaction in times of peace and war
Whilst ‘nation-state’ is in common usage and almost every state in the global states system engages in some form of ‘nation building’ activity, why is there a huge amount of tension, hostility and conflict between ‘state’ and ‘nation’?
- Many ethnic minorities are rule by states they never chose to join
- Some (eg. Kurds) found their populations divided by political frontiers created during European colonisation, only to be reaffirmed by new elites in the decolonisation process
Since the implosion of the Former Soviet Union in 1989-90, which country has been the world’s only superpower?
US
Why is the US the global superpower?
- US has the biggest economy
- Greatest purchasing power of any state
- Unique capability for rapid deployment of its forces, as shown in conflicts in Balkans and Middle East
What does the US’ superpower status depend upon?
Huge economic strength + high levels of military expenditure, only made possible by US’ unique wealth
Why is it important for the UK to maintain its ‘special relationship’ with the US?
- Enormous assets US brings to the North Atlantic Alliance
- Damage that would be inflicted on British interests around the world if the relationship with the US were to be put at risk
- Through British failure to act in accord with US foreign policy
Name an example of when Britain failed to act in accord with US foreign policy
The Suez Crisis of 1956
- Prime Minister Anthony Eden conspired to invade Egypt
- With the aim of stopping Nasser from nationalising the Suez Canal
- US President threatened to pull plug on Pound Sterling as a result
- Anthony Eden was forced to resign
Why should the UK not automatically fall in with the wishes of the US?
- Difference between mere subservience + genuine alliance
- UK is an independent sovereign state + its national interests do not always coincide with those of the US
- eg. UK made wise decision to abstain from Vietnam war, which cost US, Vietnam + Cambodia huge loss of life and wealth
How could the US change its image of a superpower reacting to challenges with an over reliance on military power and intervention?
A change towards civilian foreign policy by the US, using ‘soft power’ of trade, aid, and cultural, scientific and technological cooperation