Stalin's Rise To Power Flashcards
What were Kamenev’s 7 strengths as a candidate to replace Lenin?
Helped form party policy and was close to Lenin so had great influence, Lenin entrusted many of his personal papers to Kamenev after his stroke in 1922, strong power base in Moscow where he ran the local party, thoughtful and intelligent, good at smoothing out difficulties amongst colleagues, reconciled with Lenin following the revolution and remained close, working class background made him popular with the party
What were Kamenev’s 8 weaknesses as a candidate to replace Lenin?
Underestimated his rivals like Stalin, too closely linked to zinoviev who was more popular than him, gained a reputation for compromise and giving up easily in the face of opposition, uninspiring public speaker, many believed he lacked the drive to be a sole leader, inconsistent and opportunist (switched alliances between Stalin and Trotsky), disagreed with Lenin on April Theses/October Revolution/creation of an all communist government, Lenin pointed out Kamenev and Zinovievs disloyalty during the 1917 revolution in his last will and testament
What were Zinoviev’s 4 strengths as a candidate to replace Lenin?
Before 1924 he was Lenin’s ‘closest and most trusted assistant’ (Lenin words), party boss in Leningrad (Petrograd) which was second in importance only to Moscow so he had a strong political power base, one of the party’s best speech makers with a commanding presence in the Comintern Congresses, reconciled with Lenin following the revolution
What were Zinoviev’s 10 weaknesses as a candidate to replace Lenin?
Compromised, tended to buckle under pressure, vain and prone to mood swings, inconsistent, least educated of all potential party leaders, left it to late when siding with trotsky, opposed planned Bolshevik coup in October 1917 and stayed far away from the fighting during the civil war, many in the party expressed their open contempt to him, zinoviev suggested communists share power with other socialist parties which Lenin disagree with, Lenin in his last will and testament said ‘I will remind you that the October episode of Zinoviev and Kamenev was of course not accidental’
What were Bukharin’s 8 strengths as a candidate to replace Lenin?
Lenin called him the ‘darling of the party’, regarded as the best theoretician in the party, friendly relations with people on the left and right eg Stalin and Trotsky, expert on economics and agriculture, highly popular with politburo colleagues, embraced Lenin’s NEP, Lenin recognised him as the favourite of the party’, open and cooperative, in 1921 a foreign visitor to Moscow claimed that Bukharin was named in Russia as the eventual successor to Lenin
What were Bukharin’s 7 weaknesses as a candidate to replace Lenin?
No power base because had friendly relations with everybody, underestimated Stalin who was less popular than him so bukharin became a target for his enmity, Lenin said ‘his theoretical views can only with the greatest doubt be regarded as fully marxist’ in his last will, headed the first Communist opposition group the Left Communists after the revolution who criticised Lenin’s peace policy
What were Rykov’s 3 strengths as a candidate to replace Lenin?
Widely respected in the party for his old Bolshevism, administrative ability shown in the implementation of war communism and switching to NEP, extensive support from Sovnarkom who chose him as deputy chairman in 1923 and chairman in 1924
What were Rykov’s 6 weaknesses as a candidate to replace Lenin?
Conciliator more than a plotter who was overshadowed by Bukharin, largely ceremonial position in collective leadership and lacked a power base, policy of putting heavy taxes on vodka was socially correct but politically unwise and aroused intense opposition from the party, underrated Stalin, disagrees with Lenin frequently as he was more aligned to the views of Bukharin and Tomsky in terms of policy, as chairman he wanted to play a unifying role
What were Tomsky’s 3 strengths as a candidate to replace Lenin?
Respected for his old Bolshevism, working class origins made him popular in the party, role as chief spokesman for trade unions gave him a strong position within the party (General Secretary of Red International of the Trade Unions from 1920 and elected to central committee and the Politburo in 1922)
What were Tomsky’s 3 weaknesses as a candidate to replace Lenin?
Intense hostility to Trotsky blinded him to the danger of Stalin (his alliance with Stalin and rykov and bukharin in purging left wingers in 1926 from the party handed massive potential power to stalin), power base in trade unions made him target for Stalin jealousy, support for NEP used against him after crisis of 1927 hit the economy
How did Zinoviev react when the contents of Lenin’s last will were read out to a closed session?
Rose to tell the delegates that Lenin’s fears regarding Stalin were unfounded. Lenin’s wife had sent it to the politburo but they were never read publicly
What mistake did Trotsky make prior to the Twelfth Party Congress 1923?
He made a bitter attack on the way the affairs of the Party were being managed and he was asked to attend the congress to explain his views but failed to turn up. The triumvirate turned on him and accused him of factionalism, the term Trotskyist was used for the first time. Few months later he didn’t attend Lenin’s funeral
What did Zinoviev do at the Thirteenth Party Congress and how did Trotsky react?
In May 1924 he renewed the attack on Trotsky and called on him to refute his earlier claims. Six months later Trotsky published ‘Lessons of October’ attacking Kamenev and Zinoviev who responded with a torrent of abuse of so Trotsky gave up his position as Commissar for Military and Naval Affairs (surrendering his only power base) but Stalin took a back seat during this
How did the bureaucracy and the proletariat play a role in dividing the party?
Trotsky was opposed to the extension of bureaucratic government (centralised government by officials and departments at the top) and he wanted a return to the ideals of the revolution with a broad based government guided by the wishes of the proletariat. Stalin favoured a centralised bureaucracy that as secretary of the party gave him the greatest influence
How were Trotsky and Stalin divided on the concept of permanent revolution?
Trotsky and left believed the USSR couldn’t survive without support from other socialist countries so revolutions must be constantly encouraged in Europe (Lenin had made this argument many times). 1924 Stalin developed his theory of ‘Socialism in one country’ so socialism should first be firmly established in the Soviet Union and that once its success was obvious others would wish to follow their example, USSR could build socialism without support of socialist states, referenced an old article by Lenin that said one country could show the rest of the world the benefits of socialism and workers would rush to rise up in revolutions in their country, Stalin used his argument to criticise Trotsky for disagreeing with Lenin and underestimating the potential of the USSR
How did the NEP and rapid industrialisation divide the party?
Left (led by Trotsky, Zinoviev, Kamenev) wanted to abandon NEP in favour of a state controlled rapid industrialisation funded by ‘squeezing’ the peasants
Right (led by Bukharin, Tomsky, Rykov) believed NEP should continue with peasants becoming richer and the state using taxes on the peasants to fund gradual industrialisation.
Stalin opposed left and supported NEP during his struggle against Trotsky but once Trotsky was no longer a threat 1928-9 and the regime faced a grain procurement crisis early 1928 and NEP criticism increased in party he split from bukharin and shifted to a policy of replacing NEP with rapid industrialisation and collectivisation of agriculture
When did Kamenev and Zinoviev form an alliance with Trotsky and what was this?
July 1926, the United Opposition was an anti Stalinist bloc aimed at opposing the policies of the right which was backed by Lenin’s widow, formed after Kamenev had Zinoviev had criticised Stalin’s move to the right and support of NEP December 1925 at fourteenth party congress where they lost all votes due to Stalin’s control of the party machine, Stalins socialism in one country theory became popular and he formed duumvirate
What happened to Kamenev and Zinoviev and Trotsky after the United Opposition was formed? 6 points
Kamenev and Zinoviev removed from the Politburo, United opposition took their case to people by addressing public meetings and groups of factory workers, at Party Congress of October 1926 Trotskys last speech was heard in silence but Kamenev and Zinoviev were booed, Stalin reminded Kamenev of his mistake in 1917 (he sent a letter of congratulation to the Grand Duke of Nichalos in his accession to the throne after Tsar Nicholas abdication and later that year he opposed the Bolshevik coup), it was recalled that Trotsky had once been a Menshevik but after his conversion to Bolshevism he disagreed frequently with Lenin, Zinoviev lost his position as head of Comintern and replaced by Bukharin
When did Trotsky produce the ‘Declaration of the 83’ and what was this?
After the party congress of October 1926, attacked the policies of leadership and criticised their failures in foreign policy, Stalin accused Trotsky of being a resistor, summer 1926 was difficult for the United Opposition (they had no press to put forward their case so organised public meetings but everywhere they were abused)
What happened at the Fifteenth Party Congress?
December 1527, Stalin convinced the congress party congress of the need to expel Trotsky and Zinoviev from the party, Kamenev lost his seat on the central committee at the same time, Trotsky sent to Alma Ata in Kazakhstan close to the Chinese border and in 1929 was deported to Turkey, kamenev and zinoviev able tor join party in 1928 but lost high positions and places in Politburo (Trotsky refused this)
How did Stalin demote and remove the members of the Right who had helped him overthrow the New Opposition in 1925? 4 points
1928 Tomsky replaced as leader of trade unions and not re elected to the politburo, April 1928 bukharin criticised the ‘excesses’ of officials following Stalins methods and complained Stalin ‘is an unprincipled schemer who subordinates everything to his lust for power’ but received no support and was forced to resign as the editor of Pravda, bukharin and rykov expelled from the central committee, group of pro Stalinists replaced them eg Mikhail Kalinin, Vyacheslav Molotov and Kliment Voroshilov. initially able to stay in party after admitting their ‘mistakes’
What are two main reasons Stalin was able to win the power struggle?
His broad power base (as general secretary of the communist party he wielded immense power and was able to place supporters in strategic positions, within the party bureaucracy all the important positions were held by placements of Lenin). The left wanted rapid industrialisation and peasantry pressurised into producing more grain and paying higher taxes whilst the right wanted to move forward at a more moderate pace and peasants to continue to flourish under NEP but Stalin was happy to play one side off against the other and manipulate the changing alliances within the politburo
What 8 positions did Stalin have by the time he became leader in 1928?
General secretary from 1922 so could use control of the party machine to gain majority support in key divisions, this position allowed Hun go promote or demote the top 5500 officials in the Soviet Union commissar of the Workers and peasants inspectorate (the Rabkrin), could investigate and expel those working for the government, member of the Orgburo (organising body of central committee) he was a middle man between this and the politburo, member of the secretariat (control of appointments to positions of responsibility in the party), supervised ‘Lenin enrolment’ of 1924 and 1925 in which party membership doubled to 1 million, commissar for nationalities in the sovnarkom (oversaw affairs of all non Russians in the USSR which was some 50% of the populstion
How did a Lenin’s impact on party politics help Stalin get into power? 5 points
Highly centralised government government which banned all other political parties, banned party members from opposing party leadership by ban on factionalism in 1921, Stalin removed rivals by accusing them of factionalism, Stalin used Lenin’s writings which were often vague and contradictory to gain power, Stalin able to claim his ideology was the same as Lenin’s