stages in the development of attachment Flashcards
“The Glasgow babies”
-Schaffer and Emerson (1963)
-60 babies, working class families
-studied until 1 year old
-investigators visited every 4 weeks
-mother reports baby’s response to separation in everyday situations
-describe intensity of any protest, rated on 4 point scale
-who was the protest directed at
-stranger anxiety assessed by infants reaction to interviewer
Schaffer and Emerson findings
- between 25 and 32 weeks 50% of infants showed signs of separation anxiety towards a particular adult (usually mother)
- attachment tended to be with caregiver who was most interactive and sensitive to infants signals
- by 40 weeks 80% of infants has a specific attachment
- 30% displayed multiple attachments
stage theory: birth - 2 months
- indiscriminate attachments (asocial)
- similar response to all objects
- greater preference towards people towards end of 2 months
- reciprocity and interactional synchrony play key role
stage theory: 2-4 months
- beginnings of attachment
- seek attention from a number of people
- content when they receive it
- may not show signs of stranger anxiety yet
stage theory: 4-7 months
- discriminate attachment (specific attachment)
- develop strong attachment to one person
- showing separation protest and stranger anxiety
stage theory: 7-9 months onwards
- multiple attachments
- strong emotional ties with other caters develop
- also with non-carers e.g. siblings = secondary attachments
evaluation of stage theory:
internal validity
- some mothers may have been more sensitive to the infants reactions and therefore reported them more
- subjective opinions to what counts as a protest
- challenges the internal validity and therefore the theory
evaluation of state theory:
social desirability bias
- mothers may change their answers to what they believe is the “right” answer
- due to not wanting to be portrayed in a negative light
evaluation of stage theory:
biased sample
- working class community in 1960’s
- fewer women worked and fathers rarely stayed at home
- if study conducted today, may be more mothers at work and fathers at home
- temporal validity, population validity
- may be different for different social classes
stage theory evaluation:
supportive of Bowlby
- monotropy theory
- infant has one main attachment figure
- however did find that infants can form multiple attachments within a few months
- also argued by Rutter, they each of these is equally important to give overall attachment type
stage theory evaluation:
cross-cultural validity
- based in the UK (individualist culture)
- collectivist cultures, children cared for in communities e.g. Kibbutz Israel
- children less likely to show such a close attachment to parent
- lacks cultural validity
stage theory evaluation:
individual differences
- inflexible and doesn’t allow for individual differences
- may be seen as abnormal if infants don’t follow pattern of forming single attachments first
- judgements may be made inappropriately
- infants are individuals so will develop differently
what 4 factors affect the relationship between fathers and children?
1) degree of sensitivity
2) type of attachment with own parents
3) marital intimacy
4) supportive co-parenting
what is degree of sensitivity?
- more secure attachments found in fathers who show more sensitivity to child’s needs
what is type of attachment with own parents?
- single-parent fathers tend to form similar attachments with their own children that they had with their own parents