SQE2 Orals Day 2 (Crim Adv & Probate Int) Flashcards
Prepare for day 2 of the SQE2 orals, with Criminal Advocacy and Wills & Probate Interview
Criminal: Visual evidence - applying to exclude - the following three are required: Identify the court’s discretion to exclude evidence under s78 PACE, __________________________, and argue for / against the strength of ID evidence within ADVOKATE.
Other evidence there is to support prosecution
Identify the court’s discretion to exclude evidence under s78 PACE, other evidence there is to support prosecution, and argue for / against the strength of ID evidence within ADVOKATE.
Which application are these for?
Visual evidence - applying to exclude.
Criminal: Visual evidence - applying to exclude - the following three are required: Identify the court’s discretion to exclude evidence under s78 PACE, Identify other evidence there is to support prosecution, and argue for / against the strength of _________________________.
ID evidence within ADVOKATE
Criminal: Visual evidence: ADVOKATE - What does the A stand for?
Amount of time observed
Criminal: Visual evidence: ADVOKATE - What does the D stand for?
Distance
Criminal: Visual evidence: ADVOKATE - What does the V stand for?
Visibility
Criminal: Visual evidence: ADVOKATE - What does the O stand for?
Obstruction
Criminal: Visual evidence: ADVOKATE - What does the K stand for?
Known to the witness
Criminal: Visual evidence: ADVOKATE - What does the A stand for?
Any other reason
Criminal: Visual evidence: ADVOKATE - What does the T stand for?
Time
Criminal: Visual evidence: ADVOKATE - What does the E stand for?
Errors
Criminal: Visual evidence - improperly obtained. There are 2 points needed to be made to court. They are
1. Identify the court’s [mandatory power or discretion?] to exclude evidence under s78 PACE
2. Identify breaches of ID procedure.
Discretion
Criminal: Visual evidence - improperly obtained. There are 2 points needed to be made to court. They are
1. Identify the court’s [mandatory power or discretion?] to exclude evidence under s78 PACE
2. ???????????????
- Identify breaches of ID procedure.
Criminal: Visual evidence - improperly obtained. There are 2 points needed to be made to court.
What are they?
- Identify the court’s discertionary power to exclude evidence under s78 PACE
- Identify breaches of ID procedure.
- Identify the court’s discretionary power to exclude evidence under s78 PACE
- Identify breaches of ID procedure.
Which application are these two points for?
Visual evidence - improperly obtained.
Criminal: Visual evidence - improperly obtained - what are the 4 factors considered breaches?
Taking into account reasonable objections to the appearance of others in the IC procedure, keeping witnesses away from the suspect before and during the procedure, keeping witnesses apart during the procedure, warning that the suspect might not be shown at all.
Criminal: Visual evidence - improperly obtained - what are the 4 factors considered breaches? Taking into account reasonable objections to _______________________, keeping witnesses away from the suspect before and during the procedure, keeping witnesses apart during the procedure, warning that the suspect might not be shown at all.
Appearance of others in the ID procedure
Criminal: Visual evidence - improperly obtained - what are the 4 factors considered breaches? Taking into account reasonable objections to appearance of others in the ID procedure, keeping witnesses away from ________________________, keeping witnesses apart during the procedure, warning that the suspect might not be shown at all.
the suspect before and during the procedure
Criminal: Visual evidence - improperly obtained - what are the 4 factors considered breaches? Taking into account reasonable objections to appearance of others in the ID procedure, keeping witnesses away from the suspect before and during the procedure, keeping witnesses apart ________________, warning that the suspect might not be shown at all.
During the procedure
Criminal: Visual evidence - improperly obtained - what are the 4 factors considered breaches? Taking into account reasonable objections to appearance of others in the ID procedure, keeping witnesses away from the suspect before and during the procedure, keeping witnesses apart during the procedure, warning that the suspect ______________.
Might not be shown at all
Criminal: Exclusion of confession application. If challenged, does it fall to the prosecution to prove the confession is not unreliable beyond reasonable doubt, or the defence to prove that it is unreliable on the balance of probabilities?
The prosecution to prove beyond reasonable doubt that that the confession is not unreliable.
The prosecution to prove beyond reasonable doubt that that the confession is not unreliable.
What is this the test for?
Exclusion of confession application.
Criminal: Exclusion of confession application. If the prosecution cannot prove beyond reasonable doubt that the confession is not unreliable, then the court MUST or MAY exclude it under s76 PACE?
MUST
Criminal: Exclusion of confession application. Under which grounds should the confession sought to be excluded? That it is unreliable owing to _____________ to render it unreliable, that it is due to oppression, and demonstrate causation from these to the confession.
Things said or done