Specific Crimes and Defenses Flashcards
What is common-law murder?
Unlawful killing of another human being with malice aforethought.
How can you prove malice aforethought?
Malice aforethought may be proven by showing (1) intent to kill, (2) intent to cause serious bodily harm, (3) a reckless disregard for the value of human life, or (4) felony murder
What is first degree murder?
Unlawful killing of another with premeditation/delibration. Also felony murder.
Is felony murder first degree murder?
Yes
What is second degree murder?
Unlawful, non-premeditated killing of another human being with a depraved and malignant heart where the death of the victims was a distinct possibility.
Is first degree murder a specific intent crime?
Yes
What is the common law rule re death?
At common law, the victim must die within a year and a day to meet the causation element – for the death to be attributed to the D.
When is someone dead?
When doctor declares. Definition might vary by jurisdiction, but could include brain death – cessation of all brain functioning. According to the Uniform Determination of Death Act (§ 1, U.L.A. [1980]), from which most states have developed their brain death statutes, “An individual who has sustained either (1) irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory function, or (2) irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain, including the brain stem, is dead.” (Unborn fetus not human for purpose of murder.)
What are the elements of felony murder?
Intentional killing of a living human being caused during the attempted, actual or escape after commission of another INDEPENDENT AND INHERENTLY DANGEROUS FELONY, where death was foreseeable and felony prox cause of death.
What felonies qualify as predicate offenses for felony murder?
Burglary, arson, robbery, escape (from jail), kidnapping, rape, sex crimes other than rape
What is the acronym for felony murder predicate offenses?
BREAKRS
What does BREAKRS stand for
Burglary, robbery, escape (from prison), arson, kidnapping, rape, sexual offesnes
What are the important attributes of a felony murder predicate offense?
Must be inherently dangerous. Must be INDEPENDENT. Even if a dangerous felony, a predicate felony that merges into the murder does not support indictment for felony murder. Hence, assault and battery, even if felonies by statute, merge into murder. D would be charged with murder, not felony murder.
What is element of causation in felony murder?
Same as general causation – but for and proximate. The murder must be the natural and direct cause of the felony.
Is it felony murder, if during the commission of a felony, the police kill a bystander?
Yes, but if other felon is killed, not felony murder.
Can D be liable for felony murder of co-fellon?
Under the Redline rule, no. D not liable for death of co-felon from resistance of the victim or the police.
What is voluntary manslaughter?
Unlawful killing of a human being WITH LEGALLY SUFFICIENT PROVOCATION, and D’s act was actual and legal cause of death. D a) was provoked; b) a reasonable and sober person in D’s position would have been provoked; c) D did not have a cooling off period; and d) a reasonable person in D’s position wd not have cooled off.
What is sufficient provocation to support voluntary manslaughter?
Objective standard. 1) words alone, no matter how offensive or heinous, not sufficient provocation; 2) minor battery not sufficient; 3) serious assault may be sufficient; 4) adultery sufficient. Even tho std objective, is a trend towards taking into act some individual characteristics in determining provocation.
Can homicide be reduced to V manslaughter if D was not actually provoked, even if a reasonable person wd have been?
No. D must have been actually provoked, which is a subjective standard.
What standard applies to cooling off period?
Most Js, objective std. Bt if D cooled off more quickly than a real p wd have, then no mitigation.
What party has burden to show V manslaughter?
If gov’t is trying to prove murder, it is D’s burden to present facts sufficient to reduce to VMS, warrant jury charge.
What are the elements of involuntary manslaughter?
Unlawful killing of a human being with criminal negligence (criminally negligent homicide.) Conduct of D. is reckless or willfully bond to the risk No malice aforethought. Can also be a death that results during the commission of or flight from a misdemeanor or felony that is not encompassed by the felony-murder rule.
What kind of intent supports involuntary manslaughter?
It is a general intent crime.
What is misdemeanor manslaughter?
At common-law form of involuntary manslaughter. A death caused while commuting a misdemeanor. Can be an alternative to a felony murder.
What is vehicular manslaughter?
A death caused while operating a vehicle in a ceremonially negligent manner or while violating traffic rules.