Sovereign Immunity Flashcards
The Virginia Tort Claims Act, which waives sovereign immunity of the Commonwealth for tort claims within certain dollar and other limits, does not apply to…
counties. (no waiver is applicable as to counties)
Counties, being regarded as instrumentalities of the Commonwealth, may be sued for contract liability only…
in the manner and under the circumstances authorized by the sovereign.
Under the Virginia Code, no contract action may be maintained against a county upon any claim or demand, until…
the claim is presented to the governing body for allowance. If the governing body refuses or neglects to act when given this opportunity to resolve the matter, then a lawsuit may be brought.
If the governing body disallows the claim, the claimant may appeal to the…
circuit court.
Within __ ____ after notice of disallowance, a notice of appeal must be filed with the clerk of the county.
30 days
A complaint must be filed in circuit court within ___ ______ after the contract claim was disallowed by the county
6 months
Failure to allege, in the action in the circuit court that the contract claim has been presented to the governing body makes the complaint…
demurrable.
The above appeal procedure does not apply to…
tax refund claims, suits for non-monetary relief, or mandamus petitions.
_________ actions are immune, __________ actions are not.
governmental; proprietary
When acting within its public or governmental capacity, a city or town enjoys sovereign immunity for claims arising from…
the acts or omissions of employees and agents.
Governmental functions where immunity is enjoyed by cities and towns include:
police forces fire departments public educational facilities garbage removal service emergency response to hurricane damage hospitals and nursing facilities operation of jails design and layout of roads, and maintenance of traffic lights
___________ functions are those that promote the comfort, safety, and happiness of residents, much like a business corporation, such as operation of a waterworks
Proprietary
What are examples of proprietary functions?
Road Maintenance Provision of public water, sewage, storm drainage, gas, and municipal electric power are proprietary functions (but res ipsa doesn’t apply and proof of malfunction does not itself establish liability) Housing Authorities
The Supreme Court has said that a function is governmental if it is the exercise of an entity’s ____________ authority.
discretionary
If the function is a ministerial act and involves no discretion, it is…
proprietary.
Generally speaking, when the allegedly negligent act is one involving the ___________ or _________ of the service being provided, the function is deemed to be proprietary.
maintenance or operation
The test for establishing a proprietary function cannot simply be whether…
the same thing is done by private entities or whether a fee is charged.
The issue is whether, in providing such services, the governmental entity is exercising the ______ and ______ of government conferred by law for the general benefit and well-being of its citizens.
powers and duties
If a particular function has both governmental and proprietary aspects, the ____________ aspect prevails.
Government; As long as there is any meaningful government function involved, the activity is immune from negligence liability.
Even if the locality is immune, plaintiffs often attempt to sue the _________ of the governmental unit.
employees