SocPop Flashcards
In what 3 ways can ‘normality’ be decided?
Statistical basis
Optimal health
Social (normative) basis
Outline the statistical basis of normality
Normal is the usual or average
Normal (Gaussian) distribution - 95% of population should be within 2 standard deviations of the mean
Outline the optimal health basis of normality
Normal value is determined by what is required for optimal health
e.g. BMI
It is a change from the person’s normal values that is most reliable
Outline the social normality basis of normality
Normality is what society finds acceptable or desirable
Influenced by culture and time - wide variety across cultures etc.
Define disease
A pathological process confirmed by signs and investigations
Deviation from the biological norm
Define illness
A subjective experience or ‘feelings’
Personal
May be experienced in the absence of pathology
Define sickness
A social role adopted or assigned to people perceived to be ill
What is health?
WHO
A state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity
Discuss the medical model of health
Health is the absence of disease
Causes of ill health can be identified by signs and symptoms and diagnosis
List some limitations to the medical model of health
Doesn’t take into account multi-causal factors that influence biological functioning
Doesn’t explain chronic/long term condition - not as simple as ‘curing’
Places the power in the medical profession rather than individuals
Discuss the social model of health
Ill health and disease are caused by social and psychological factors
Income Place in society Gender Employment Education
List some benefits of adopting a social model of health
Takes into account lay beliefs
Places people at the center and recognises autonomy
Recognises that a person can have a disease and still consider themselves healthy
What charge can be brought against Drs if they undertake a procedure without informed, valid consent?
Battery
Is a written consent form proof of valid consent?
No - it is only supporting evidence.
A signed consent form is not valid consent if the patient lacked capacity, lacked information, or didn’t give information voluntarily
What are the 2 types of consent?
Implicit
Explicit - written, verbal
What documents are available to guide Drs on consent?
GMC guidance on consent
DoH reference guide to consent
What 3 things does valid consent require?
Competence/capacity
Information
Voluntariness
How is a person’s capacity assessed when it comes to decision making?
It must be based on their ability to make a specific decision at the time it needs to be made
A person is unable to make a decision if they cannot do one or more of the following:
(Capacity)
Understand the information given to them
Retain the information long enough to make the decision
Weigh up the information
Communicate their decision (by any means)
Why is information an important part of consent?
What should be considered when giving information?
Because it is a legal requirement of consent
Patients needs, wishes, existing knowledge, complexity of treatment and associated risks
Describe the voluntary aspect of consent
Consent should be given without coercion
Patients should be free of any outside influence when making their decisions
Explicit/implicit coercion
Patient/Dr relationship
Family pressure
Who should take consent?
Should be yourself or delegate to someone who:
- is trained and qualified
- has knowledge of investigation, treatment, and risks
- acts in accordance with GMC guidance
List some potential obstacles to informed consent
Poor information/time pressure during information provision
Being rushed into making a decision
Being pressured into making a decision by 3rd parties
What does the GMC say about consent in emergency situations?
You can treat a patient without consent (if they are unable to consent) provided treatment is immediately necessary to save life or prevent serious deterioration
What are the 4 principles of person-centred care?
Care is personalised
Care is coordinated
Care in enabling
Person is treated with dignity, compassion and respect
Personalised care involves…..
A whole person approach
Putting the patient’s needs and preferences, as they define them, first
Tailoring therapeutic plans and services to a patient’s needs and desires
Seeing the patient as a person
Enabling care involves…..
Shared decision making
Recognising the patient’s strengths in self-management
Supporting self-management
Patient and public involvement in the design and delivery of services
Coordinated care involves…..
Coordination across episodes over time
Integration between health and social services
Across primary, secondary and tertiary care
Through transitions e.g. child to adult
Which legal outline tells doctors to work in a person-centred way?
What does it outline?
GMC Duties of a Doctor 2013
Make the care of your patient your first concern
Treat patients as individuals and respect their dignity
Work in partnership with patients
What does the GMC guidance outline in terms of professional values and person centred care?
Listen to patients, respect their views
Discuss diagnosis, prognosis, treatment, care
Share information with patients so they can make a decision
Maximise patient’s opportunities and ability to make decisions
Respect patient’s decisions
List 5 ethical principles and values to consider when providing person centred care, and through all practice
Respect
Autonomy
Dignity
Care
Consequences
Define respect
Due regard for the feelings, wishes, or rights of others
Recognising the moral value of a person as an autonomous being
Define autonomy
Individual autonomy is an idea that is generally understood to refer to the capacity to be one’s own person, to live one’s life according to reasons and motives that are taken as one’s own and not the product of manipulative or distorting external forces
Define dignity
A state, quality or manner worthy of esteem or respect; and (by extension) self-respect. Dignity in care, therefore, means the kind of care, in any setting, which supports and promotes, and does not undermine, a person’s self-respect regardless of any difference. Or, as one person receiving care put it more briefly, ‘Being treated like I was somebody
Define care
Beneficence
Best interests
An ethic of care
Treat the condition, care for the person
Define consequences
-in terms of patient centred care
Best overall outcome (totalitarianism)
Likely to lead to better outcomes, fewer complaints, less risk of litigation, increased trust in the medical profession
Outline the Calgary Cambridge guide to consultations
Five tasks
- commencing the consultation
- gathering information
- physical examination
- explanation and planning
- closing the consultation
Two functions
- building the relationship
- providing structure
What is ethics?
How one ought to act
What are facts?
Claims about the world that have been, or can be in principle, verified by empirical methods
What are values?
Claims about, or expressions of, things like preferences, attitudes, emotions, aesthetic appreciation
What are thick concepts?
Claims that have both factual and evaluative content
What are the 3 most popular moral theories in healthcare?
Consequentialism/utilitarianism
Deontology
Virtue ethics
What is consequentialism?
What is a drawback to it?
Theories that assess the moral values of anything in terms of that thing’s outcomes or impact upon the world
The theory only bases its worth on outcomes, not the process
What is utilitarianism?
Aims for the best balance between benefit and harm
This makes for the most effective use of resources
Consequentialist theories need provide/defend:
An account of the relevant good
An account and method of quantification (who counts?)
An explanation of how rightness is to be determined
What is deontology?
Rules govern actions and we have a duty to abide by them regardless of cost
“The right is prior to the good”
Has less emphasis on outcomes (consequentialism)
Which moral theory seeks to respect autonomy?
Deontology
What are virtue ethics?
Focuses on the character of the person, not their actions
A right act is the action a virtuous person would do in the same circumstances
Not ‘what should I do’ but ‘what kind of person should I be?’
What are the 3 P’s of ethical reasoning in clinical practice?
Why is this important
Principles
Particulars - contents, facts
Perspectives
USE THIS WHEN ANALYSING ETHICAL QUESTIONS
What is the Refern Report?
Investigation following the retention of organs from deceased children in Alder Hey Hospital, kept without knowledge or consent of parents
Outline the Human Tissue Act 2004
Is this the same for the whole of the UK?
HTAct regulates the removal, storage and use of human tissue in England, Wales and Northern Ireland
Human Tissue (Scotland) Act (2006) applies in Scotland
What are the 3 principle functions of the HTAct (2004)?
To issues Codes of Practice
To issue licences and inspect establishment
To approve living organ and bone marrow donations