Sociologists Flashcards
Douglas (1964)
Cultural deprivation- parents education
WC parents placed less value on education. As a result they were:
- less ambitious for they children
- took less interest
- less likely to discuss child’s progress with teachers
- less encouragement
Feinstein (2008)
Cultural Deprivation - Parents education
MC parents have a better education so socialise their children to be positive towards education.
- Parenting style - discipline
- Parents educational behaviours - reading, museums
- use of income - educational toys, tuition
Parents education most important
Keddie
Cultural Deprivation theory is a myth and it victim blames. They are culturally different not deprived.
The schools responsibility to cater to the needs of different children with different cultures
Blackstone and mortimore
Criticise the idea that working class parents don’t care about their Childs education.
- Attend less parents evenings as they are working
- put off by MC atmosphere of the school
- lack of knowledge to help
- wc schools have less efficient ways of contacting home
Tanner
Cost of education
cost of books, transport, equipment etc places a burden on wc families. Wc children often have to use hand-me-downs which can result in them being stigmatised and bullied
Flaherty
Cost of education
only 20% of kids entitled to school meals take them - Fear of stigmatisation. Children from low income families often have to get jobs, babysit etc which acts as a barrier to educational success
Calendar and Jackson
Fear of debt
WC students more debt averse - see it as something negative and to avoid
- 5x less likely to apply to uni
Increasing uni fees- number of applicants dropped by 8.6%
Bourdieu
Cultural capital
1- economic capital
2 -educational capital
3 - cultural capital
If a pupil doesn’t have the same habits as the teachers then they will face symbolic violence
Sullivan
Survey using questionnaires - 465 pupils, assess capital
those who watched:
- serious TV documentaries are read complex fiction had more developed vocab - greater cultural capital
RIST
Labelling in primary schools
Tigers- MC, clean appearance, seated near the teacher
Clowns and Cardinals - WC, given lower level books, fewer opportunity to show their ability, sat furthest away from the teacher
Rosenthal and Jacobsen (1968)
Self-fulfilling prophecy
IQ test, randomly picked 20% of them and told the teachers that they were spurters. On returning a year later they found that 47% of them had made significant progress
Fuller
AO3 - Labelling
year 11 black girls rejected their labels and gained high grades
Gillborn and Youdell (2001)
Streaming and the A-C economy
- Schools focus their time and effort on those capable of getting a c to boost their league table position
Educational Triage -
- Those who will pass anyway
- Borderline c/d pupils
- Hopeless cases
Lacey
Pupil subcultures
- Polarisation - pupils respond to streaming by moving towards one of the 2 opposite poles
Pro-school - MC, high streams, committed to values of the school , gain status through academic success
Anti- school - WC, lower streams, symbolic capital off peers
Ball
AO3 - abolishing streaming
when streaming was removed, polarisation decreased however teachers still labelled mc as the ideal pupil
Class inequalities remain even when streaming is abolished
Woods
AO3- Lacy
pupils responded to streaming in 4 ways
1 - Ingratiation - Teachers pet
2 - Ritualism - going through motions, staying out of trouble
3 - Retreatism - Daydreaming & mucking about
4 - Rebellion - Reject everything the school stands for
Archer et al
Pupils’ class identities and the school
Those with the same habits to the teacher receives symbolic capital and if they don’t they will experience symbolic violence (Bourdieu)
Working class pupils felt that they had to change themselves and how they talked
Symbolic violence led to them creating their own status known as nike identities where they got symbolic capital from dressing in brands like nike
Ingram
Studied 2 groups of Catholic boys from a deprived area in Belfast
WC boys felt tension between the habits of their wc neighbourhood and middle class culture at school
Evans
WC girls wanted to go to university to support their families but they feared they wouldn’t fit in. They self excluded themselves from elite or distant universities
Lawson and Garrod
Define an ethnic group as “people who share common history, customs, identity as well as, in most cases, language and religion. They see themselves as a distinct unit”
Berieter and Engleman
The language spoken by low income, Black American families is inadequate for educational success
Gillborn and Mirza
Indians do well despite English not being their first language
Moynihan
Many black families are headed by lone mothers who struggle financially due to the absence of a male breadwinner. This also means that boys are left without a role model in the house
Pryce
Black Caribbean culture is less resistant to racism leading to low self-esteem and underachievement
Sewell
Boys don’t lack a father figure they lack ‘tough love’ and the will turn to a media-inspired role model of anti-school black masculinity
Gillborn
Black boys fail because of institutional racism not peer pressure
Sewell
Asian and Chinese students do better because their parents have an asian work ethic
Lupton
ethnic minorities see education as a way up in society
McCulloch
Ethnic minorities are more likely to aspire to go to university than white working class
Driver
Cultural Deprivation theories ignore the positives. For example- Moynihan ignores that the lone mothers act as a strong, positive role model for their daughters
Lawrence
Black pupils underachieve due to racism not because of a low self esteem
Palmer
Almost half ethnic minority children come from low income families compared to a quarter of white children
Almost half of Pakistani and Bangladeshi workers earn £7 an hour
EM’s are 3x more likely to be homeless
EMs are 2x more likely to be unemployed
Madood
White children from low income families did worse than ethnic minority students from low income families
Wood et al
Sent out job applications to 1000 job vacancies with similar cv’s but different ethnically sounding names. Those with British sounding names got an interview 1/9 of the time. Those with ethnic sounding names only got an interview 1/16 of the time
Gillborn and Youdell
Teachers are quicker to discipline black pupils and label them as hopeless cases. They have racialised expectations which often leads them to misinterpret their behaviour negatively
Wright
Teachers held ethnocentric views as they assumed asian pupils would have a poor grasp of English so they left them out of class discussions