Social Influence Flashcards
What is the definition of conformity
It is a form of social influence, occurs when someone’s behaviour or thinking changes because of group pressure
What was the aim of Asch’s study?
Asch’s aim was to see how people reacted under group pressure
What was the method of Asch’s study?
- There were 123 American men
- In a group of 6-9 men there was one naive participant (who didn’t know what the experiment was about) and the rest were confederates (who were hired by the researcher to purpously give incorrect answers)
- There was 1 standard line and 3 comparison lines and the group were asked to say out loud which comparison line was the same length as the standard line
What were the results of Asch’s study?
- Asch found that 24% resisted the urge to conform, 36.8% conformed in line with the confederates and 76% conformed at least once
What are the conclusions of Asch’s study?
Asch found that people will conform under group pressure and will agree with another person, even when they know the answer is a clearly incorrect in order to fit in.
What are 2 evaluations of Asch’s study
- One weakness is Asch only used males. This is a weakness because the results can’t say women would give the same results as well. Therefore the results can’t be generalised to women
- Another weakness is the study only uses Americans. This is a weakness because the results won’t apply to all nationalities. Therefore we can’t generalise the results to the wider population just because Americans act a certain way
Social Factors of Conformity
Group Size
The more people that there are in a group, the more likely we are to experience group pressure; conform more
Social Factors of Conformity
Anonimity
When we are anonymous, we are less likely to conform because our indentiities are hidden and we feel less pressure to conform to the opinions of others
Social Factors of Conformity
Task Difficulty
When the task is difficult, we are more likely to conform because we have less confidence in our answer, therefore we turn to others for guidance and the right answer
Dispositional Factors of Conformity
Expertise
When you have more intelligence, you have more confidence in your answers therefore conforming less under group pressure
Dispositional Factors of Conformity
Personality
- People with ELC believes that whatever happens to them is not their responsibility and they don’t infleunce the things that happen to them. People with ILC believe that they are responsible for the things that happen to them and they do influence the things that happen to them
- ELC —> More likely to conform and agree under group pressure
- ILC —> Less likely to conform, resisting the group pressure and sticking to their answers
What is the aim of Milgrims study?
His aim was to see if a normal person would deliver a potentially lethal shock to someone else if ordered to do so by an authoritive figure
What was the method of Milgrims study?
- 40 male volunteers (20-50yrs) were told they were taking part in memory research.
- They were paid for their time.
- The teacher (the participant) was told by the experimenter (actor) to give the learner (actor) shocks every time the learner got the answer wrong.
- The fake electric shocks started at 15v and went up to 450v (lethal).
- At 300V the learner would pound of the wall and after that they would stop responding
What were the results found from Milgrims study?
- 100% of people went to 300v
- 65% of people went to 450v
- Three participants had seizures (fits) caused by stress.
What were the conclusions from Milgrims study?
People will listen to an authority figure if they believe they aren’t responsible for the consequences. People obeyed because of the location, the pressure and the situation was new to them.
What are 2 evaluations of Milgrims study?
- A weakness of Milgram’s research is that some participants appeared to have realised it was fake. This is a weakness because if the participants realised the study was fake, they would show demand characteristics (impressing the researcher by changing behaviour)
- A weakness of Milgram’s research is that it only used male participants. This is a weakness because we cannot generalise the findings to females. We cannot say that females would have reacted in the same way. The study is androcentric.
What is the autonomous state?
Autonomous state is when people behave according to their own principles and feels responsible for their actions.
What is the agentic state?
Agentic state is where people act on behalf of someone else and therefore follow their orders. They don’t feel responsible for their actions.
What is the agentic shift?
- We are more likely to obey orders when we are in an agentic state/when we believe we are acting on behalf of an authority figure.
- When someone we believe to be a figure of authority gives us an order, we go from an autonomous state to an agentic state (an agentic shift).
2 evaluation points for Milgrims Agency Theory
- One weakness of this study is that it gives an excuse for people who blindly follow destructive orders. This is a weakness because it allows people to believe they aren’t responsible for their actions
- Another weakness is that is does not explain why there isn’t 100% obedience. In Milgrims study 35% did not obey fully. Milgrim did an interview with those 35% of participants and found that there were multiple factors as to why there was a lack of obedience in those participants, therefore social factors can’t fully explain obedience
What’s a dispositional factor
A dispositional factor are factors that affect behaviour because of your personalities and own characterisitics