Soci 314 Flashcards
Examples from class about gendered pattern?
Bespoke post
- Masculine product website
- The grizzly cabin slipper
- Rancher jackets
- Knives
- Manly Bands
Mainly rings
- The cowboy
- The gentleman
- The lord of the rings rings
Men prefer function, each product must have a function
Associated with outdoors, outdoors are a masculine symbol
Is masculinity just something men do?
No, some men are feminine
Women and non binary people may also enact masculinity
Among men, there are many forms of masculinity that differ based on social context, culture, and intersections of social identities.
Sex vs gender
There is a difference between sex and gender
There are biological difference between sexes but more social differences
How we study biology it is affected by out social and cultural understanding of gender
Are men and women more similar biologically or socially?
on average there aren’t actually that many differences between men and women in brain structure, many more social differences compared to biological
How does masculinity relate to politics?
masculinity is tied to nationalism and politics
what is the term masculinity applied to?
- a wide variety of situations, objects, and behaviours
- dynamics at most levels of society (micro, meso, and macro)
What is masculinity?
- Masculinity refers to the “practices, behaviours, attitudes, sexualities, emotions positions bodies organizations, institutions and all manners of expectations culturally associated with (thought not limited to) people understood to be male
- the term mass refers to real social phenomena but it’s an umbrella term that all concepts is abstracted from specific incidents and situation
- Masculinity varies across intersections of social identities/statues (race, class, disability, relation) cultures, social contexts and time periods
“Masculinity is a configuration of practices within a system of gender relations”
- cultural and social contexts shape masculinity
- there are not fixed types of masculinity
-masculinities exist in relation to other masculinities and femininities - masculinities change over historical periods
What are 4 key components to gender systems
- Power Relations = men have institutional power over women and non binary people and advantage relative to them
- Production relations = gendered division of labour in and out of the home
- Emotional relations = gendered emotions and sexual desire
- Symbolic relations = gender is embedded within cultural symbols
What is patriarchal dividend?
men as a group are advantaged relative to women and non binary people as groups
Men however do not benefit from gender inequality in the same way
What is hegemonic masculinity?
Hegemonic masculinity is the masculinity that is in a given social context the top of the gender hierarchy it “guarantees (or is taken to guarantee) the dominant position of men and the subordination of women”
- changes with historical condition
- differs across social contexts
- Establishes hegemony over other masculinity through a combination of force and consent
- Global, region, and local variants
Explain the three variants of hegemonic masculinity.
Global = constructed within transnational, political, social and economic contexts
Regional = hegemonic masculinity constructed at the level at the nation
Local = constructed within particular communities, organizations, institutions, or other smaller social contexts.
(UBC, Vancouver, must specify the context and the scale)
To say someone is hegemonic you must _______
identify how they create/reinforce gender inequality and it must involve force and consent
What are relational arrangements/configurations that differ across social contexts in relation to masculinity?
- Subordinated Masculinity = Configuration of masculinity with the least power and influence such as many gay masculinities
- Complicit Masculinity = configuration of masculinity that benefit from the subordination of women do not necessarily actively support it or resits it
- Marginalized masculinity = involves intersections of gender and marginalized race and class status; they share overlap with hegemonic masculinity but also are marginalized relative to it.
Big takeaways of hegemonic, subordinated, complicit and marginalized masculinity
- Masculinity exist in relation to one another and to femininities
- they exist in hierarchy
- Gender is a social structure that affects all aspects of social life
- Gendered social processes reflect, and reinforce, broader social inequalites
what are dominant masculinities?
Dominant masculinities are not always associated with and linked to gender hegemony but refer to (locally, regionally, and globally) the most celebrated, common, widespread, or current form of masculinity in a particular social setting
unlike hegemonic masculinities, they do not legitimate gender inequality
________ is about the mechanism of domination - how different masculinities are socially organized into a hierarchy - rather than qualities internal to a single masculinity.
Hegemonic
within-person masculinity?
- Individuals can enact different configuration of masc depending on the context
- People often behave differently in different contexts, so the masc they enact may differ as well (Student who behave different at school than at home with family)
What is Masculine Overcompensation?
When men feel that their masculinity is threatened many “overcompensate” through extreme behaviours and attitudes
Because masculinity is narrowly defined, esteemed, and unattainable, a strain always exists, and the result of that strain is __________ and the continual striving for greater masculinity
overcompensation
Why is masculinity easily threatened?
Because it is “relative and hierarchical”
Masculinity takes continual effort to “prove” resulting in continual efforts to bolster it
Men or Women: When felt their gender identity or status was threatened reported higher support for war, homophobia, dominance attitudes, and purchasing SUV’s
Men
What are the two forms of threats to a man’s masculinity?
- Individual (Men being told the they were feminine)
- Structural (Feeling that social changes threatened men’s status)
Can the failure of being masculine/feminine be considered a reversal process?
No, if someone fails at masculinity they can be feminized and demasculinized, while women are not considered masculine.