Shareholders Flashcards
Can SHs manage the corp?
No, that’s the BOD’s job.
When can SHs manage corp?
when closely held corp. BUT NOT MANDATORY - CAN HAVE BOD
** what defines a close corp? 2 things
- few SHs
2. private stock
** To have SH MGMT in close corp you need A PROVISION IN CERT giving board power to SHs and you need (4 things)
- all incorporators or SHs approve it
- conspicuously noted on front and back of all shares
- subsequent SH have notice, and
- shares not listed on exchange or regularly quoted OTC
in close corp run by SHs, who owes duties of care and loyalty
MANAGING sharholders
in close corp, trend toward imposing fid duties on SHs when dealing w/ each other. Controlling shareholders owe minority shareholders ______. Why?
Controlling shareholders owe minority shareholders the UTMOST DUTY OF GOOD FAITH. So controlling Sh can’t use their power for gain at expense of corp. We give minority SHs remedy b/c controlling shareholder’s behavior DEFEATS REASONABLE EXPECTATIONS for investing.
Can members of licensed profession operate through general corporation?
No, must form “P.C.” a PROFESSIONAL SERVICE CORPORATION.
In P.C., are professionals liable for their malpractice?
Yes, but not malpractice of others in the corporation, nor are you personally liable for rent or Ks of the P.C.
What’s required in P.C. certificate that’s abnormal? (2 things)
- profession being practiced
2. certification that each SH, Dir, and Officer is licensed to practice the profession
*Generally, are SH’s liable for what corp does?
No
Exception to rule that generally SH’s are not liable for what corp does?
Piercing the corporate veil in close corporation
*** To prove piercing corporate veil in NY reqs 3 things
- complete domination over corporation by SH
- abuse of privilege of incorporating, and
- fairness required holding SH liable (e.g., FRAUD or INJUSTICE)
what’s hardest part to prove to pierce corp veil?
Complete domination over corp.
What if only SH of corp is another corp – can you pierce corp veil?
Yes
Is undercapitalization grounds to pierce corporate veil?
No, not by itself.
Do we expect more piercing corp veil cases from K or tort?
Tort
in close corp, who is liable for wages and benefits of employees?
10 largest SHs.
- to determine if you’ve got a derivative suit, ask what?
Could corp have brought this suit (e.g., usurping corp opp suit against D&Os)? Derivative suits are brought by SHs but are based on CORP’S LEGAL CLAIM..
Who gets the $ from successful derivative suit?
Corp gets the $, but SH who brought suit gets costs and attorney’s fees covered out of the judgment.
When can SH recover the $ in derivative suit?
When $ otherwise goes to the bad guys, e.g., close corp where returning $ to corp gives it to bad D&O who is also SH. In this case, court might give $ directly to innocent SHs.
- can losing SH in deriv suit recover costs?
2. can other SHs thereafter sue defendant for same transaction?
- No
2, No
**Reqs for bringing SH derivative suit
- stock owner when COA arose and through action and judgment,
- adequately rep SHs or corp,
- bond for D’s costs (SH below 5% or 50K)
- SH makes prior demand on BOD to sue corp (unless futile)
- plead w/ PARTICULARITY efforts to get BOD to sue or why futile
- Join corp. AS DEFENDANT
what are 3 situations where derivative suit doesn’t req prior demand to BOD for suit (because such demand would be futule - #1 most important)
Futile to request BOD sue where:
- Maj of BOD is interested or under ctrl of interested directors;
- BOD didn’t inform itself of teh transaction to the extent reasonable; or
- transaction so egregious on face that it couldn’t reflect sound business judgment.
- Maj of BOD is interested or under ctrl of interested directors;
If SH requests that BOD sue on behalf of corp and BOD refuses, can SH bring derivative suit? Reqs (1 of 2)?
Only can bring deriv suit post-BOD rejection if EITHER: (1) show maj of BOD is interested OR (2) BOD procedure was incomplete or inadequate
SH brings deriv suit. Corp must be joined as defendant. Corp moves to dismiss based on?
finding of independent directors (or committee of ind directors, “special litigation committee”)
SH brings deriv suit. Corp must be joined as defendant. Corp moves to dismiss based on independent directors’ findings. What does court look at to decide (2 things)?
- independence of those investigating claims internally; and
- sufficiency of the investigation
parties to derivative suit can’t dismiss or settle it without ____
court approval
- In NY, when can a D&O bring a derivative suit?
- in whose name is suit brought?
- who gets damages?
- In NY, a D or O can sue another D or O to compel her to account for violation of duties or misappropriation of assets.
- brought in plaintiff’s own name
- corp gets damages
which SHs have right to vote?
record holder as of record date. record date = eligibility cut-off = 0-60 days before meeting.
You get to vote even if you sell your stock b/t record date and meeting.