Session Nineteen (PTSD) Flashcards
Outline the DSM-5 criteria for the diagnosis of PTSD?
A: Must count as traumatic
B,C,D,E: Must meet all 4 symptom criteria
F: Must last for 1 month or more
G: Must cause significant distress or interference
…and can’t be explained by the effects of a substance or medication
What qualifies as ‘trauma’ under the DSM-5 PTSD criteria?
Quite strictly defined, event that involves actual or threatened death, injury or sexual violence. Can be:
- Experiencing or witnessing a single event
- Learning about an event
- Repeated exposure to a traumatic stimulus
What are the 4 key symptoms of PTSD which must be met for a diagnosis to be reached (criteria B-E)?
B = Re-experiencing symptoms.
C = Avoidance symptoms
D = Negative alterations in cognition and mood
E = Alterations in arousal and reactivity
What are the re-experiencing symptoms of PTSD, and how many are required for a diagnosis? (Criteria B)
At least one of:
- Distressing memories
- Nightmares
- Dissociative reactions
- Distress when exposed to reminders
What are the avoidance symptoms of PTSD, and how many are required for a diagnosis? (Criteria C)
Only one; avoiding reminders of trauma (required for diagnosis)
What are the negative alterations in cognition and mood symptoms of PTSD, and how many are required for a diagnosis? (Criteria D)
At least two of:
- Forgetting aspects of event
- Negative beliefs
- Loss of interest
- Detachment
What are the alterations in arousal and reactivity symptoms of PTSD, and how many are required for a diagnosis? (Criteria E)
At least two of:
- Irritability
- Anger
- Destructive behaviour
- Hyper-vigilance
- Difficulty in concentrating
- Poor sleep
How common is trauma generally, and how do most people respond to it?
Incredibly common:
- Kilpatrick et al, 2013: 90% of US adults experience some form of traumatic event in their lifetime
- Most experience more than one in fact (3 being the mean)
- Common causes = violent death of a friend or family member, witnessing severe injury or death, being involved in an RTA
Normal response for most people is to develop some mild PTSD symptoms that recover over about a month.
How prevalent is PTSD generally?
Prevalence of PTSD after trauma =
- 11% for women
- 5% for men
- 8.3% overall
What factors affect likelihood of traumatic reaction developing into PTSD?
Stressor factors:
- Type of trauma (interpersonal violence, combat)
- Prolonged or repeated trauma
- Grotesque events, events involving children tend to be more strongly associated with PTSD
Personal characteristics:
- Women more at risk than men
- Black or hispanic at greater risk than white
- Personal or family history of psych disorders (D or A)
- Previous trauma
- Low intelligence
Subjective response:
- How the person perceives their life to be threatened, loss of control etc
- Mental defeat
- Dissociation
- Anger, guilt or shame
Aside from PTSD, what conditions are associated with the experience of trauma?
- Major depression
- Anxiety disorders
- Substance abuse
What 3 forms of trauma are classically associated with PTSD, and what % of individuals go on to develop the condition?
Rape:
- 65% men
- 46% women
Combat:
- 39%
Physical abuse:
- 22% men
- 49% women
What did Brewin et al’s 2000 meta-analysis into risk factors for PTSD show?
Factors with a strong effect on development of PTSD:
- Trauma severity
- Lack of social support
- Additional life stress
Reasonable effect:
- Psych history
- Reported childhood abuse
- Fam history
Variable effect:
- Education
- Prior trauma
- General childhood adversity
Possible:
- Female sex
- Race
- Age at trauma
What conditions are commonly seen in PTSD patients?
- Very strong co-morbidity with depression (88%M, 79%F)
- Strong co-morbidity with alcohol abuse (52%M, 30%F) (this could be a self-medication thing)
- Ohayon et al (2000) found 60% of PTSD sufferers also experience insomnia symptoms, vs 6-15% of general population
PTSD also appears to have an effect on general health, with increased risk of:
- CVD
- Diabetes
- Alzheimer’s
- Early death
What factors can predict developing chronic PTSD?
Recovery environment:
- Social support
- Absence of negative responses from others
- Further stressful or traumatic events including aftermath of trauma
Psych maintenance factors:
- Dysfunctional appraisals
- Trauma memory characteristics
- Dysfunctional behaviours or cognitive strategies
Sleep problems, both before and after the event
Why is PTSD so commonly poorly treated?
- Often unrecognised, especially in children
- On average takes 10 years before patients receive adequate treatment
- Secondary problems have developed by that point, making it harder to treat
Outline the evidence supporting the role of Cortisol in PTSD?
Evidence for:
- Olff et al (2005): PTSD patients show low basal cortisol levels, probably due to increased receptor number leading to more sensitive cortisol negative feedback inhibition of the HPA axis
- Wessa et al (2006): Expanded on this by associating cortisol directly with PTSD symptom severity
Evidence against:
- Meewisse et al (2007): Meta-analysis + SR of evidence, found no significant different in cortisol levels
- Methodological limitations rampant in evidence for
- Cortisol alone unlikely to explain core PTSD symptomatology
Problem of cause vs effect
Outline the neuroanatomical/ fMRI evidence surrounding the cause of PTSD?
Liberian et al, 2006:
- Impaired functioning in sub regions of mPFC and anterior cingulate regions
- Increased responsivity of the extended amygdala and insula regions
- Amygdala role in exaggerated emotional responses in PTSD
Bremner et al, 2003:
- Women with PTSD who were exposed to childhood sexual abuse show smaller hippocampal region as well as less HC activation
Again issue of cause vs effect
Which region of the brain is most strongly associated with dysfunction in PTSD?
The Amygdala (+ Hippocampus)
Hull et al, 2002:
- Most replicated structural difference = hippocampal volume reduction
- This may limit the proper evaluation and categorisation of experience
- Patients display increased activity in the amygdala after symptom provocation
Woon et al, 2008:
- Differences in the hippocampus and amygdala in adults who experienced child maltreatment vs those who didn’t
Teicher explains these differences in terms of preparing the brain for a threatening and uncertain environment.
Outline the evidence regarding the role of genetics in PTSD?
Pitman et al, 2006:
- US twin study
- Twins who’d been exposed to combat showed a greater heart rate response
- However both exposed and non-exposed twins showed increased neurological soft signs as well as decreased hippocampal volume
- Suggesting that both had a vulnerability, which when exposed to a trigger lead to symptoms of PTSD
Stein et al, 2002:
- 30% of variance in PTSD symptoms could be attributed to genetics