Session 4: Country Differences in Political Economy Flashcards
Opening Case: Hong Kong Protests
Why is the Hong Kong case ideal to appreciate differences between countries’ political systems and economies?
- 1841
- 1984: declaration returning the territory in 1997
- 1997
- one country, 2 systems promise
- In 2019, Hong Kong’s Security Bureau, proposed amendments that allowed to extradite criminal suspects to mainland China
- Hong Kong civil society reacted with mass protests demanding the repeal of the law and the resignation of the executive chief
- The beginning of 2020 marked another wave or protests, focused on wider democratic reforms, culminating with the dismissal of Wang Zhimin, Beijing’s liaison officer for the territory, and the appointment of a provincial Communist Party secretary
Political Systems (6)
- Collectivism
- Socialism
- Individualism
- Democracy
- Totalitarianism
- Semi-totaltarianism / Fragile democracies
Collectivism
- Political system that stresses the primacy of collective goals over individual goals.
- Plato (427-347 BC) - Individual rights should be sacrificed for the good of society
Socialism
Roots: Karl Marx (1818 – 83)
* Communism – revolution and totalitarian dictatorships
* Social Democrats – socialism by democratic means
Individualism
- Political system that focuses on the interests of the individual over the interests of the state.
- Aristotle (384 – 322 BC) – Private property is more highly productive than communal property and will thus stimulate progress
Individualism has two central tenets:
1. Individual Freedom and self-expression – John Stuart Mill
2. Let people pursue their own economic self interest – Adam Smith
Democracy (6 demands)
- Political system in which the people elect representatives to form the government.
Democracy demands:
1. Freedom of expression
2. Free media
3. Regular elections
4. Limited terms for representatives
5. Fair court system
6. Non political – police and army
“Democracy is the worst form of government – except for all the others that have been tried” W. Churchill
Totalitarianism (4 forms)
- All the constitutional guarantees on which representative democracies are built are denied to the citizens.
- In most totalitarian states, political repression is widespread and those who question the right of the rulers to rule find themselves imprisoned or worse.
There are four major forms of totalitarianism:
✓ Communist totalitarianism
✓ Theocratic totalitarianism
✓ Tribal totalitarianism
✓ Right-wing (Fascist) totalitarianism
Semi-Totalitarism / Fragile Democracies
- Countries are not always clear-cut democracies or totalitarism
- Hybrid forms exist
- Political systems are not static entities: Countries are often in transition toward more totalitarian or more democratic regimes. E.g.:
✓ Post-communist countries in Eastern Europe
✓ Many Latin-American countries’ drift toward Fascist/Communist regimes in the aftermath of economic crises, loss of a leader (e.g.: Venezuela, Chile, Argentina)
Economic Systems (3)
- Market economy
- Command economy
- Mixed economy
Market economy
- All productive activities are privately owned;
- Supply and demand determines price and production
Command Economy
The government determines the allocation of resources including the determination of production and prices
Mixed economy
- Some sectors are left to private ownership and free market mechanism;
- Others have significant government ownership and government planning.
What’s a legal system?
Legal system refers to a system of rules that regulates behavior and the processes by which the laws of a country are enforced and through which redress of grievances is obtained.
Different Legal Systems (3)
- Common law
- Civil law
- Theocratic law
Common Law
System of law based on tradition, precedent, and custom. When law courts interpret common law, they do so with regard to these characteristics.
Civil Law
Law based on a very detailed set of written laws and codes.
Theocratic Law
System of law based on religious teachings.
Definition of Contract
- Contract is a document that specifies the conditions under which an exchange is to occur and details the rights and obligations of the parties involved.
Contract Law
- Contract law is the body of law that governs contract creation and enforcement
- Parties to an agreement invoke contract law when there is belief there was violation of the agreement
International Trade and Contract Disputes
- United Nations Convention of Contacts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG);
- By adopting the CISG, a nation accepts to treat the convention rules as part of its law.
- CISG applies automatically to all contracts for the sale of goods between different firms based in countries that have ratified the convention, unless the parties to the contract explicitly opt out
Property
- Refers to a resource over which an individual or business holds a legal title, meaning it owns the resource.
- Resources include:
✓ Land & real estate; Equipment; Capital
✓ Mineral rights; Businesses; Intellectual property (patents, copyrights and trademarks)