Sentencing Flashcards
What are the longest sentences available to the Magistrates Court?
6 months for one offence; 12 months for two either way offences
What is the largest fine available to the Magistrates Court?
£5,000
When will a youth be sent for trial in the Crown Court?
- If he is sent with an adult
- If the offence is punishable with 14 years imprisonment or more
- If the offence is specified in s91 PCCSA
When must Magistrates obtain pre sentence reports for adults?
If they are considering a custodial sentence
When do Magistrates not need to obtain pre sentence reports for adults?
If it would be unnecessary
When do Courts need to obtain pre sentence reports for young offenders?
If they are considering a custodial sentence
When do Courts not need to obtain pre sentence reports for young offenders?
If they already have a pre sentence report
Explain the 5 step procedure for sentencing hearings (6 points)
- The prosecution will OPEN
- The prosecution will provide the court with a copy of D’s ANTECEDENTS
- The Prosecution will apply for the COSTS
- The Defendant will be able to MITIGATE
- The Magistrates/Judge will pass SENTENCE after RETIRING
How will a Defendant plead guilty if they disagree with the Prosecution case?
By entering a written basis of plea
If the Defendant pleads guilty via a written basis of plea midway through the trial what are the Judge’s 4 options?
- Have the jury continue and decide the facts of the case.
- Accept the Defendant’s version
- Hold a Newton hearing with the judge as the tribunal of fact
- Accept the Prosecution’s case if the written basis of plea is “manifestly absurd or incredible”
There is no need to hold a Newton hearing when the dispute is immaterial to sentence or is insignificant. True or false?
True
Write 6 facts about indications of sentence:
- At any time the accused can request an indication of sentence (a Goodyear indication)
- The Judge is never obliged to give an indication of sentence
- An lenient sentence may be appealed to the Court of Appeal by the A-G
- If the Judge gives an indication, she will be bound by it
- It is inappropriate to ask for a Goodyear indication if there is a material difference between the Prosecution and the Defence as to the facts on which a guilty plea might be entered
- A Goodyear indication ceases to have an effect after a reasonable period
What are the 6 roles of Prosecuting counsel at sentence
- Open the facts
- Outline aggravating or mitigating factors
- State any statutory provisions relevant to the offender
- Draw the Courts attention to the relevant sentencing guidelines or case law
- Put forward views of victim, where relevant
- Make appropriate applications for costs
What are the 5 objects of sentencing (142 CJA 2003)
- Punishing offenders
- Reduce crime by deterrence
- Reform and rehabilitate offenders
- Protect the pubic
- Provide reparation
What is seriousness?
Harm + culpability
What are six considerations when determining sentence?
- Consider sentencing guidelines for starting point
- Move up or down starting point with regards to aggravating or mitigating factors
- Reduction for an early guilty plea
4 Consider dangerousness - Consider totality
- Consider ancillary orders
What is the rule on the Defence recovering their costs in the Crown Court?
An acquitted (or otherwise successful) Crown Court defendant who has paid for legal services may recover their legal costs, limited to the amount that would be payable under specified legal aid rate.
What is the rule on the Defence recovering their costs in the Magistrates Court?
Non-legally aided privately paying clients in the magistrates’ court will be entitled to recover their legal costs under a Defendant’s Costs Order if they are acquitted, but the amount will be limited to the amount that would be payable under specified legal aid rates.
What is the rule on costs where a Defendant is convicted?
A defendant may be ordered to pay some or all of the prosecution’s costs.
What will the Court take into account before making a defendant’s costs order?
The means of the Defendant and whether it is reasonable to order her to pay
An offender aged over 21 who is convicted of murder must be sentenced to what?
Imprisonment for life
What are the four conditions for a person to be sentenced to imprisonment for life under s225 (dangerous offences)?
- Convicted of a serious offence
- The offence is punishable with imprisonment for life
- The Court believes that the offender is “dangerous” and there is a risk that he will commit further specified offences
- The Court considers that the seriousness of the offence is such as to justify a sentence of life imprisonment
What is the definition of dangerous?
The Court is of the opinion that there is a significant risk to members of the public of serious harm occasioned by the commission by him of further specified offences
What are the 4 conditions for a mandatory life sentence for a “second listed offence” under s224A?
- A person aged over 18 is convicted of a specified serious offence (in Schedule 15)
- The Court would otherwise have imposed a sentence of imprisonment for 10 years for that offence
- At the time the present offence was committed the offender had been convicted of an offence under Schedule 15
- The previous offence carried a sentence of 10 years or life
When will the Court disapply the mandatory life sentence under s224A?
Where it is of the opinion that there are particular circumstances which relate to the offence, or the previous offence, or the offender, which would make the sentence unjust in all the circumstances
When will an offender be liable for an extended sentence under s226A CJA 2003?
- Where they are over 18 and commit a specified offence
- Where the Court considers they are dangerous
Either
3A. At the time the offence was committed the offender had previously been committed of a serious specified offence
OR
3B. If the Court were to impose an extended sentence the custodial time would be at least 4 years
Which is correct?
[A] The Court may sentence the offender to an extended sentence under s226A if the conditions are met
[B] The Court must sentence the offender to an extended sentence under s226A if the conditions are met
[A]
If a person is given a sentence of 12 months or more, how long must they serve in prison?
Half
If a person is a dangerous offender, how much of their sentence will they serve?
Two thirds
Where an offender is sentenced to an extended sentence of over 10 years, how much of their sentence must they serve?
The automatic release section does not apply. The Parole Board will make a recommendation.