Sentencing Flashcards
What is the first thing a court considers when determining a sentence?
“The seriousness of the offence
What two things does the court look at to determine the seriousness of an offence?
“Culpability of the offender and the harm caused
What are the two statutory thresholds a court must consider before imposing certain sentences?
“The threshold for a custodial sentence (Section 230 SA 2020) and the threshold for a community order (Section 204 SA 2020).”
When can a court impose a custodial sentence?
“Only if the offence (or combination of offences) is so serious that neither a fine alone nor a community sentence can be justified (Section 230 SA 2020).”
When can a court make a community order?
“Only if the offence (or combination of offences) is serious enough to warrant such an order (Section 204 SA 2020).”
What is ‘culpability’ in sentencing?
“Essentially the blameworthiness of the offender
What is ‘harm’ in sentencing?
“An assessment of the damage caused to the victim
Are courts required to follow sentencing guidelines?
“Yes
Where can you find sentencing guidelines?
“Magistrates’ court guidelines
What happens at a sentencing hearing?
“Prosecution presents facts and submissions
What are some of the prosecutor’s duties at a sentencing hearing?
“Reminding the court of previous convictions
What is the defence’s role at a sentencing hearing?
“Ensuring a lawful sentence is passed and presenting mitigating factors.”
What is a pre-sentence report (PSR)?
“A report obtained by the court (usually from probation) to assist in determining the most suitable way to deal with an offender.”
When is a court required to obtain a pre-sentence report?
“Before passing a custodial or community sentence
What is the general approach a court takes to sentencing?
“1. Determine offence seriousness. 2. Consider aggravating factors. 3. Consider mitigating factors. 4. Consider assistance to prosecution. 5. Consider guilty plea reduction. 6. Consider totality. 7. Consider ancillary orders.”
What are aggravating factors?
“Factors that increase the seriousness of the offence (e.g.
What are mitigating factors?
“Factors that reduce the seriousness of the offence or relate to the offender’s circumstances (e.g.
What is ‘totality’ in sentencing?
“Ensuring that the final
How do sentencing guidelines categorize offences?
“Usually into three categories (1 being the most serious
What is a ‘starting point’ in sentencing guidelines?
“A reference point within a category that the judge will adjust based on aggravating and mitigating factors.”
What is a ‘sentence range’ in sentencing guidelines?
“The potential span of sentences a judge can impose within a specific category.”
What is ‘credit for a guilty plea’?
“A reduction in sentence given to defendants who plead guilty.”
What is the maximum reduction for a guilty plea at the first stage of proceedings?
“Maximum 1/3.”
What is the maximum reduction for a guilty plea after the first stage of proceedings?
“Maximum 1/4.”