Sentencing Flashcards
When does sentencing occur?
Guilty plea or found not guilty
Which courts are courts of first instance with sentencing powers?
- magistrates
- youth
- crown
Can a summary only offence be sentenced in the crown court?
No
Can an indictable offence be sentenced in the magistrates court?
No
Can a guilty plea for an either way offence be tried in the magistrates court?
Yes but can commit to crown court for sentencing
Can a not guilty plea for an either way offence be tried in the magistrates court?
Yes but can commit to crown court for sentencing
Can a not guilty plea for an either way offence which is sent to the crown court for trial be sentenced in the magistrates court?
No
What is the process for a newton hearing where the prosecution doesnt accept the defendant’s basis?
- D drafts written basis of plea
- Prosecution decides not acceptable
- Does judge think basis absurd?
* If yes = sentence on P basis
* If no… - Will it make a material difference to sentencing?
* If no = sentence on D basis
* If yes…
Newton hearing
What is the process for a newton hearing where the prosecution accepts the defendant’s basis?
- D drafts written basis of plea
- Prosecution decides acceptable
- Does judge accept the basis?
* If yes = sentence on D basis
* If no…
Newton hearing
Will there be a jury at a newton hearing?
No
What does the court decide in a newton hearing?
Whether prosecution has proved version of facts beyond reasonable doubt
What is the consequence where the court decides to sentence a defendant on the prosecution basis in a newton hearing?
Defendant loses some credit for guilty plea
What sentences are likely to be given where there is more than one offence arising out of the same facts?
Concurrent
What sentences are likely to be given where there is more than one offence arising out of different facts?
Consecutive
How long can a court defer a sentence?
up to 6 months
When can a defendant ask for an indication of sentence at the magistrates court?
Either way offence and magistrates court accepted jurisdiction
What can the defendant ask regarding indication of sentence at the magistrates court?
indication of sentence if remaining in magistrates and pleading guilty
Does the magistrates court have to give an indication of sentence?
No
What will the indication of sentence be if the magistrates decide to give one?
Custodial or non custodial
Will a magistrates indication of sentence be binding?
Yes if D pleads guilty
When can a defendant ask for an indication of sentence at the crown court?
Before Pre trial preparation hearing or
any stage before jury returns verdict
What must the defendant do in order to ask for an indication of sentence at the crown court?
- Either accept P facts or written basis of plea agreed by parties and court
- Give clear instructions to counsel that D wishes to ask for an advance indication
What are the factors in the courts deciding the seriousness of an offence for sentencing purposes?
- cuplability
- harm
What is the threshold for passing a custodial sentence?
only if so serious that fine/community sentence cant be justified
What is the threshold for passing a community sentence?
Only if serious enough to warrant making order