Secured transactions Flashcards
Security Interest
Gives creditor (secured party) rights (e.g., to sell) in debtor’s personal property or fixtures to satisfy a debt.
Collateral
Property in which the security interest is created, extends to identifiable proceeds of the collateral
UCC Art. 9 Goods (Tangible Collateral)
All things that are moveable at the time the security interest attaches.
- Consumer goods
- Equipment
- Farm products
- Inventory
UCC. Art. 9 Consumer Goods
Goods that are used primarily for personal, family, or household purposes
UCC. Art. 9 Inventory
Goods that are kept for sale or lease.
Attachment
- Security agreement
- record showing intent
- signed by debtor
- reasonably identifying collateral
- Debtor’s obtains rights in collateral beyond mere possession (ownership rights)
- Creditor extends value to the debtor
Renders creditor’s interest in the collateral enforceable effective against the debtor. Requires security agreement, debtor’s rights in collateral, and extension of value by the creditor. All three must happen the order in which they do doesn’t matter.
NB. Oral security agreement is possible but rare. For non-consumer deposit accounts, electronic chattel paper, and investment property, control will evince the security agreement.
Perfection (Five different methods)
- Automatic Perfection (consumer goods; purchase money security interests; assignment of accounts that don’t transfer a sig. part of the assignor’s outstanding accounts)
- Phys. possession/Pledge (works only for money)
- Control - investment property, electronic chattel, non-consumer deposit accounts (ONLY way to perfect for these accounts)
- Notation of the lien on a certificate of title - usually for vehicles that are NOT inventory. ONLY way to perfect security interest in a car or truck (i.e., car may look like a PMSI but it’s not)
- Filing a financing statement
Enhances the creditor’s interest in the rights of the collateral after attachment. Attachment and perfection can occur simultaneously. Renders creditor’s interest in the collateral enforceable effective against the world.
Priority Rules
- Perfected wins v. unperfected
- Two perfected secured parties - first to file or perfect
- Two unperfected parties - first to attach
- Seller financed PMSI beats financer-financed
- If same type of financed PMSI, first to file or perfect
PMSI
Purchase-money secured interest.
- Seller-financed PMSI
a) Secured party sells collateral on credit AND
b) retains a security interest in the item sold - Financer-financed PMSI
a) Secured party gives debtor a loan to buy specific collateral
b) Debtor uses loan to acquire that collateral
c) Creditor takes security interest in that collateral
PMSI Rules
- PMSI in consumer goods is automatically perfected
- PMSI in equipment can be perfected by filing w/in 20 days of buyer obtaining possession
- PMSI in inventory MUST be perfected by the time the buyer gains possession and those with a previous filed security interest in the inventory must be given notice
- No 20 day grace period
- Perfection usually by filing
After-acquired Property Clause
Grant of security interest in the property obtained in the future (in addition to the interest in the present property).
Generally, has to be expressly included within the agreement UNLESS the property is of a type that rapidly depletes and replenishes (e.g., inventory, accounts).
Future Advance Clause
Grant of security agreement securing future loans with the same collateral
Financing Statement
Document conveying notice of security interest in order to perfect it. Generally, no signature req. since the security agreement will be signed. Can be filed before security agreement! Contains:
- Debtor’s name (trade name NOT ok)
- For individuals, match driver’s license
- Seriously misleading errors NOT ok
- Must be retrievable by searching Debtor’s correct name using standard search logic
- Reasonably identifiable description of the collateral
- Generality has implications for perfection of proceeds
- If debtor changes their use of the collateral, financing statement remains effective (no duty to monitor or amend)
- Secured Party’s name
Equipment
Good used or bought for use in a business. Default/catch-all category.
Farm Products
Crops (or their products), livestock, or supplies used or produced in farming operations IN POSSESSION of a debtor engaged in farming operations.
NB. There always has to be a farmer involved for this to apply!
Inventory
Good held by debtor for sale, lease, or to be furnished under service contracts. materials used or consumed in a business in a short period of time.
Semi-Intangible and Intangible Property
- Instruments (checks promissory notes)
- Documents (bills of lading, warehouse receipts)
- Chattel paper (records of a monetary obligation, e.g. a promissory note AND a security interest in a lease of specific goods (the security agreement)
- Investment Property (stocks, bonds)
- Accounts (right to payment FOR SERVICES rendered or PROPERTY sold)
- Non-consumer deposit accounts (general business bank accounts)
- Commercial tort claim (NB. This is really bad collateral)
- General intangibles (intellectual property; good will)
- This is the default.
- Payment intangible - general intangible under which the account debtor’s principal is a monetary obligation (e.g., a settlement)
Consignment
A security interest involving a non-owner/consignee’s attempt to sell the goods of the owner (assignor).
Secured Sale Disguised as a Lease
NOT a true security interest because the leased property still has MEANINGFUL economic value (e.g. rental car)
Ask: At the time the parties entered into the transaction, was it reasonably likely that the lessor would get the item back with MEANINGFUL economic value?
Yes → True lease; not governed by Art. 9
No → Secured sale disguised as a lease; governed by Art. 9
NB. In a true sale, items are typically used until they are drained of their value.
Attachment Req. “Value Given”
Anything that would satisfy contractual consideration works, as would past consideration. Debtor and creditor must BOTH give consideration. Easy to meet, esp. from Debtor’s perspective b/c they give a promise to pay at a min.
Lowest Intermediate Balance Test
Used to determine the identifiable cash proceeds to which a creditor is entitled when they have been intermingled with non-collateral funds: The lowest account balance between the time proceeds are deposited and the time at which the creditor is collecting (can’t exceed value of the original deposit).
Proceeds
Anything received from the sale, exchange, collection, or other disposition of collateral or proceeds. Security interest automatically gives the secured party a right to identifiable proceeds.
If the proceeds are not identifiable cash proceeds or do not meet the same office rule, creditor must amend the financing statement to cover them unless it’s already broad enough.
NB. Perfected interest in collateral = automatic perfected interest in proceeds for 20 days. Continues w/o further action for identifiable cash proceeds and items that collateral that satisfy the same office rule.
Where to file Financing Statement (Generally)
- Generally, Secretary of State’s office of the secretary of state where debtor
- Individual resides
- Registered org. (e.g., corporation, LLC, LLP) is organized
- Unregistered org. (e.g., general p’ship) has place of business
- Exceptionsroperty record of the county where the real estate is located (includes fixtures and timber to be cut).
- Debtor moves out of state: 4 months to file
- Collateral moves out of sate: 1 yr to file
Where to file Financing Statement (Exceptions)
- Fixtures and timber to cut): record of the county where the real estate is located (includes fixtures and timber to be cut).
- Goods covered by certificate of title: state issuing most recent certificate
- Deposit accounts: state in which bank has CEO
- Investment property:
- Certificated security - where the certificates security is located
- Uncertificated security - where the issuer was organized
- securities account - where the securities intermediary’s CEO is located
- EXCEPT: Perfected automatically or by filing → where debtor is located
- Agricultural liens: where farm product is located