Second Round Flashcards
Trial Court Jurisdiction
District Court
- felony charges;
- misdemeanors as lesser included offenses;
- misdemeanor involving official misconduct
Only a district court has jurisdiction to conduct trial for aggravated assault because that is a felony
Trial Court Jurisdiction - Justice Courts
Offenses only punishable by fine
I.e. traffic court
Trial Court Jurisdiction - Municipal Court
Exclusive jurisdiction:
- offenses created by city ordinance; punishable only by fine
Concurrent jurisdiction:
- offenses created by state statute; punishable only by fine
Trial Court Jurisdiction - County Courts
Misdemeanors over which exclusive jurisdiction is not given to justice courts
Habeas Corpus
Court order commanding someone with a person in custody to produce that person before the court and show why the person is being held
A writ is directed to someone restraining another
Instructs the restrainer to produce the person
When must df be taken before a magistrate?
Officers must present df to magistrate without unnecessary delay; but in any case within 48 hours of arrest
What are a magistrates duties at a preliminary appearance?
The magistrate must:
1. Tell df the charges
2. Tell df of his rights to counsel; right to an examining trial*
3. Warn df that in regards to police question
- right to remain silent
- any statement can/will be used against him
- right to have attorney present during questions
- can request appointment of attorney
- can terminate interview with police at any time
4. Set bail
May also determine if probable cause exists
What actions if magistrate determines no probable cause?
Release on bail
- felonies - after 48 hours of arrest without warrant
- misdemeanors - after 24 hours of arrest without warrant
Magistrate can delay release for not more than 72 hours total
Can bail be denied to df?
Yes, if the state can show one prior felony conviction and the use of a deadly weapon in the present offense
Can bail be denied in noncapital cases?
Yes, only if at a hearing the prosecution shows
1. Df is charged with noncapital felony
2. Subst evidence of df’s guild of crime; and
3. One of the following:
- two prior felony convictions
- present offense committed out on bail on felony; or
- both:
(A) one prior felony conviction; and
(B) present offense involved use of a deadly weapon; or
- present offense was a violent sexual offense committed while on felony probation or parol
What can df do if bail is denied in noncapital case
If detention for noncapital case lasts 60 days or greater, order denying bail expires and df can demand bail be set.
Rule - denial of bail in a noncapital prosecution lasts only 60 days, as long as defense does not move for a continuance of the trial proceedings
What procedural steps can df take to reduce bail? E.g. bail set at $500k on charge of aggravated assault
- File application for writ of habeas corpus in dist ct
- Introduce evidence at hearing showing:
- bail set was excessive;
- df cannot meet the bail set; and
- amount of bail df can meet - The dist judge may order bail reduced
- If not, df can, before trial, appeal to Court of Appeals (not Criminal Court of Appeals, just the intermediate)
Factors a court should considering what fixing bail
LASSO Likelihood of df appearing for trial Ability of df to make bail Seriousness of the crime charged Future SAFETY of the victims/community Required bail is not to be an instrument of OPPRESSION
Personal Bond vs Bail Bond
Bail bond requires a surety or cash deposit (down payment)
Personal bond requires neither kind of security
- is the accused’s promise to pay the amount if bond is forfeited
Examining Trial
Pretrial hearing before a magistrate. It’s purpose is to require the State to produce evidence showing probably cause to believe the df is guilty of the crime.
Examining Trial Procedure
At an examining trial, df has the rights to
- Be present
- Be represented by counsel
- Have rules of evidence applied
- Cross-examine state witnesses; and
- Subpoena and present dfnse witnesses
Who can demand an examining trial?
A df is entitled to an examining trial if
- She is charged with a felony; and
- An indictment has not yet been returned
What requirements needed for person to waive indictment?
- Df must be represented by counsel
- Waiver must be by written instrument or in open court; and
- Waiver must be voluntary
- Waiver is not permitted for capital murder indictment
What grounds permit challenging grand juror
- Juror is insane
- Juror has medical condition rendering them unfit to serve
- Juror is witness or target of a grand jury investigation
- Juror served on petit jury of former trial for same conduct
- Juror is biased/prejudiced
- Juror is biased about guilt/innocence of person accused/suspected
- Juror is related within 3 degrees of cosanguinity with suspect
- Juror is biased/prejudiced against law applicable in the case
- Juror is the prosecutor of an accusation against the person making the challenge
Voluntary Appearance Before grand jury
What must occur before and as a suspect is questioned in grand jury proceedings
Df is deemed a suspect witness. Must be warned of the following before questioning
- The offense of which he is suspected;
- The county in which it was committed; and
- The time of its occurrence
Questions asked and answered must be recorded
This is notice pleading - letting df know what he’s charged with.
Subpoenaed appearance before a grand jury to testify
What must occur before suspect appears and is questioned?
Subpoenaed as a suspect witness, must be warned of the following:
- Testimony given under oath
- False answer to material question subjects df to prosecution for perjury
- May refuse to answer incriminating questions
- Has right to have counsel appointed
- Has right for counsel to be present outside the room; and
- His testimony can be used against him
Challenges to grand jury indictment
While the grand jury is conducting proceedings, prior to deliberation and voting, the prosecutor, stenographer, bailiff, and an interpreter may be present.
An indictment may be set aside if an unauthorized person was present while the grand jury was hearing evidence.
An indictment must be dismissed if an unauthorized person was present while grand jury was deliberating and voting.
General Periods of Limitation
Misdemeanors - 2 years
Felonies - 3 years
Theft, burglary, robbery, kidnapping - 5 years
No period of limitations for:
- Murder/manslaughter
- Offense involving leaving the scene of an accident
- Sexual assault, where DNA testing indicates the perp is not a person whose identity is readily ascertained (if the v didn’t know the df)
What is a charging instrument, generally?
Provides information and alleges only fact. It does not identify the charged crime by name, nor does it specify the statute creating the crime.
It charges the offense and provides the accused with trial preparation notice. To charge an offense:
- Facts constituting all elements must be alleged
- Statutory langue is usually sufficient
- Any victim must be named
More detail and specificity may be required to provide notice
What are the formal requisites of an indictment or information?
The following are required per the Coder of Crim Proc.
- Commence: “In the name and by the authority of the State of Texas”
- Name the accused (or describe him)
- Set forth (charge) all elements of the offense
- Specify enough details to give accused notice
- Allege the crime was committed on a date that is both:
- within period of limitations; and
- before presentment of indictment*
- Allege crime occurred in county under court’s Juris
- Conclude: “Against the peace and dignity of the State”
- Be signed by foreperson (indictment) or prosecutor (information
- Bar tricked test-takers one year - the alleged commission occurred on later date, after the charging instrument was issued (minority report bull shit).
Jury instruction on an uncharged offense
A jury should be instructed on an uncharged offense if:
- The other offense is a lesser included offense of the crime charged; and
- The evid before the jury supports finding both that:
- d is not guilty of the charged offense; and
- d is guilty of the lesser included offense
What procedure available to challenge indictment?
Motion to quash:
- An exception to the form of the indictment; or
- An exception to the substance of the indictment.
Motion must be filed before the day trial begins
What personal decisions is df entitled to make during prosecution
- What plea to enter
- Jury or bench trial
- Take the stand
What effect does pleading nolo contendere have compared to guilty
In the criminal prosecution, no difference.
If civil litigation arises out of the same incident (i.e. wrongful death following murder case):
- guilty plea can be used as evidence
- nolo contendere cannot be used
What admonition must a judge give before accepting a felony plea of guilty/nc
- Inform df range of punishment
- Inform df that recommendations by state are not binding
- Inform df of limited right to appeal following guilty plea
- Inform df plea may result in deportation, exclusion from US, denial of naturalization; and
- Inquire into whether there is a plea bargain
Plea bargain calls for probation; judge ordered 20 years’ imprisonment
Df has right to withdraw his plea
Pre-trial hearing and conference
Up to the judge’s discretion If set, parties must within 7 days before the conference 1. Enter any special plea; 2. Challenge indictment 3. Ask for continuances; 4. Change of venue motion; 5. Motion to suppress evidence; 6. Request for discovery; 7. raise claims of entrapment
Motion in limine
A Pre-trial motion asking for either (or both):
- Pre-trial ruling on the merits of some question of evidence or procedure that will arise during trial; or
- Pre-trial ruling that opposing counsel must alert the judge before raising some matter of evidence or procedure before the jury
Essentially a motion in limine is asking the judge to tell someone they can’t do something.
A JUDGE’S RULING ON A MOTION IN LIMINE PRESERVES NOTHING FOR APPELLATE REVIEW. MUST OBJECT TO PRESERVE ERROR IN THE RECORD.
What ways are available for df counsel to raise admissibility of evidence
Make a pre-trial motion to suppress; or
Wait and object to the admission when State offers at trial
What effect is court denies motion to suppress?
A pre-trial motion to suppress evidence preserves the issue for appeal
- counsel doesn’t have to object during the case in chief (but would be wise to do so anyway)
Denied motions in limine do not preserve the issue for appeal
What is the scope of questioning allowed on cross-examination of df at a hearing to suppress evidence (pre-trial)?
The state may only inquire into matters related to the hearing issue - the validity and facts behind the motion to suppress. Cross-examination cannot extend to guilt of the charged crime.
Nor does df waive his right to remain silent at the rest of the trial.