Search and Seizure Flashcards
General warrants or Rits of Assistance
- Issued on mere suspicion
- No PC
- No Judicial authorization
- No inventory/ or items to be seized
- Good till the person who wrote it dies plus 6 months
What part of the CT constitution mimics 4th Amendment?
Article 1 section 7
Judicial branch does what?
- Interprets laws
- Involves judges
Executive branch does what?
-Enforce laws-
Involves prosecutors, police, and corrections
Legislative branch does what?
Writes laws
Drafters of constitution philosophy?
- Individual rights
- The government exists from the GOVERNED consent
Bill of rights
First 10 amendments of constitution
14th amendment does what?
- Due process clause
- State and local government have to follow federal law
Judicial Review?
- Unique
- America invented it
- US supreme court has final say on what the constitution means
- They INTERPRET the constitution
4th amendment does what?
- Protects PEOPLE not PLACES
- Restricts federal government
The federal constitution acts as a what?
Basement
Our state constitution acts as what?
- A ceiling
- Gives additional rights to citizens
- CT supreme court acts as final say for OUR constitution
54-1f
- Arrest w/out warrant
- To have a constitutionally valid arrest all you need is PC
How to apply 4th amendment (3 parts)
- Government action
- Search or a Seizure
- Constitutionally protected area
What is a constitutionally protected area?
Area without a reasonable expectation of privacy
What is a Search?
An intrusion into an area where a person has an reasonable expectation of privacy, with the intention to discover evidence of a crime.
What is Seizure?
Would a reasonable person feel free to leave?
Does the constitution define reasonable?
NO
Who tells us what reasonable is?
The US supreme court
US v Katz concluded what?
Where there is a reasonable expectation of pivacy
- Was there an subjective expectation of privacy?
- Was there an objective exception of privacy?
What is objective?
Reality (what society excepts as reasonable)
What is subjective?
The persons perception of reality
What is standing?
For a person to have legal standing to challenge the constitutionality of a searcher seizure they MUST have an reasonable exception of privacy to that area or item.
Places where people expect privacy
- House (temp or permanent)
- Overnight guest
- Apartment
- Hotel room while rented
- Dorm room
- Where a person has total legal right to control access and exclude others
- Cartilage
- On your person
- Motor vehicle
- Persons belongings
- Thermal imaging or technology not available to public
- GPS tracking of MV
- Cell phone or computer
- Motor home
- Homeless persons belongings
4 part Cartledge test
- Proximity to home
- Whether an area is in an enclosure around a home
- Nature of the use of the area
- Steps taken to protect the area
Places where the is NO expectation of privacy
- Abandoned property
- Abandoned MV
- Property discarded while being pursued by PD
- Property left in a public place not out of necessity
- Garbage at the curbside
- Business guest at a home
- 3rd party records
- Physical attributes on public display
- Arial surveillance of a persons property in navigable airspace using the NAKED eye
- Woods or open fields
- Motor vehicle in which you are a passenger
- Use of a flashlight to look in a car
- Prison cell
- VIN # of a MV
- License plate
- Common hallway
- Conversations overheard in adjacent apartments
- Any place open to the public
Probable cause
The facts and circumstances that would lead a reasonable to believe that a crime has been or is about to commited
With probable cause can a innocent person be arrested?
YES
Objective standard
Reasonable people can reasonably disagree
Needs for PC
- Must be based on the “totality of the circumstances”
- Based on “all the officers training and experience”
3rd party searches
- Evidence is admissible even if obtained illegally only if the person is not acting as an agent for the government
- Who determined the action?
- Who determined to give the evidence to the police?
- Was the citizen prompted to give the evidence to the police?
- Prior knowledge by government
- Request or authorization by police for the person to do it
A warrant is what?
Per say REASONABLE
No warrant is what?
Per say UNREASONABLE
Is the constitution silent to what happens when the 4th amendment is violated?
YES
What is the main purpose of the exclusionary rule?
To deter unlawful police conduct
Conclusion of Weeks v US
Exclusionary rule: allowed evidence to be thrown out if obtained while violating 4th amendment
Silver platter doctrine
Federal courts could use evidence obtained illegally if obtained via state officers
What was the conclusion to Mapp v Ohio?
Exclusionary rule applied to EVERYONE
Fruits of poisonous tree
Any evidence derived from an unconstitutional search or seizure gets thrown out
US v Leon and the good faith exception
Concluded the that when an officer i good faith applies for a warrant and then is signed by the prosecutor and judge the EXCLUSIONARY RULE does not apply
State v Marsala
No good faith exception in CT
Inevitable discovery doctrine
State must prove by preponderance that the evidence seized in violation of the 4th/5th amendment would have been inevitably discovered by other means
Important requirements for Inventory search
- Have a department policy
- Person must be taken into custody
- Department policy must be complied with ROUTINELY
Reasons for Inventory search
- Protection of property owners
- Protection of Police from claims of stolen property
- Protect police from danger within vehicle