Sales & Leases Flashcards
A transferor who transfers whatever rights he has in property without making a warranty regarding those rights has
assigned his rights, but has not sold a corporeal immovable.
Assignments are effective against debtors and third persons from what time?
the time they have actual knowledge or are given notice of the assignment.
If the seller over delivers by more than 10%
the buyer is permitted to keep the overage as a penalty.
If a sale is rescinded for lesion, the seller takes the thing back in what condition?
in the condition it is in at the time of the action of recision.
As a general rule, the risk of loss of a thing being sold due to fortuitous events transfers from the seller to the buyer upon
delivery to the buyer.
Can a lease term can expire on the occurrence of an event?
yes.
A lease term is prohibited by law from exceeding
99 years. If a lease term exceeds 99 years, the term will be reduced by operation of law, but the lease will not be deemed invalid.
What is the last day on which a lessee can validly terminate a three-week lease?
Five days before the end of the lease period.
An option is a contract whereby the parties agree that
the offeror is bound by his offer for a specified period of time and that the offeree may accept within that time. Such an agreement is separate from a lease of property.
The lessor warrants to the lessee that the thing is suitable for the purpose for which it was leased and is free of vices or defects that prevent its use for that purpose. Under the Code, a warranty may be disclaimed only if
waived by clear and unambiguous language brought to lessee’s attention. Further, any attempt to disclaim warranties affecting health or safety is ineffective in residential leases.
A sale is a contract where
person transfers ownership of a THING to another for a price in MONEY.
Requirements for the perfection of a sale
(1) Thing
(2) Price
(3) Consent of the parties
Is the transaction a sale?
(generally do not bifurcate) ask, what is the primary obligation? What is the predominant element of the sale, the thing or the services? Is the cost of the service component or is it “trifling”?
Litigious rights
Officers of the court (judges, attorneys, clerks, officers) cannot purchase litigious rights under contestation in the jurisdiction of the court, and any such purchase by such an officer is null. You cannot buy rights to things currently subject to litigation in the jurisdiction in which s/he serves
Future things, or things not yet in existence, can be sold. The existence of the thing is a condition that
suspends the effects of the sale.
A hope, or a thing that may materialize, can be sold
Buyer assumes the risk that the thing may not materialize.
EXAMPLE: A fisherman may sell a haul of his net before he throws it. Buyer is entitled to whatever is caught in the net, and even if nothing is caught the sale is valid.
Parties must fix a price that is certain or determinable through an agreed upon method
Parties can select a third person to determine the price. If the third person is unable or unwilling to make a determination, a court may set the price.
If the thing is (1) movable, (2) of a kind that seller habitually sells, and (3) parties cannot agree on price, the price is:
a reasonable price at the time and place of delivery
Lesionary price
is an unjust price; the sale cannot be affected by a vice of consent called lesion. Limited to corporal immovables. When the price paid is less than 1/2 the fair market value of the thing. Only the seller can bring action; the buyer can either rescind the sale, or pay a supplement.
Auxiliary terms, immovables
the offer and acceptance must be mirror images of one another, including the auxiliary terms
auxiliary terms, movables
no need to have mirror images, so long as the price and the object to be sold are mirror images. No more “last shot” rule.
auxiliary terms for the sale of a movable are considered
proposals, unless the form says the acceptance of the additional terms is a condition of sale
auxiliary terms for the sale of a movable for non-merchants, if they’ve acted as though there was a sale
just fill in where the aux terms were with the standard provisions in the Civil Code
auxiliary terms for the sale of a movable for merchants
additional terms become elements of the contract, unless the new terms materially alter the sale
auxiliary terms for the sale of a movable for merchants, the offer expressly limits acceptance to the terms of the offer
then the additional terms provided by the other party are not added to the contract
auxiliary terms for the sale of a movable for merchants, if the offeror objects within a reasonable period of time
then the additional, objectionable terms provided by the other party are not added to the contract
Form of sale, moveables
There is no form requirement for the sale of movables, but delivery is required to affect third parties.
Form of sale, immoveables
(1) Sale of immovable property must be in writing.
(a) Exceptions:
1) An oral transfer of immovable property will be recognized as a valid sale if possession of the immovable is actually delivered to the purchaser and the seller acknowledges or confesses that sale under oath.
2) Sometimes, acts under private signature can be enforceable even though they are only signed by one party, provided the other party avails himself of the benefit and has done something to indicate that he wants to take advantage of that or participate in it.
(2) The thing that is the object of the sale needs to be described with some minimally sufficient level of specificity.
(a) If you’re able to eke out with parole evidence what you purchased, the transaction may be enforceable between the parties.
(3) Sale is effective upon perfection, but it is only effective against third persons once it is recorded.
(a) The public records doctrine is a negative doctrine. Failing to record something deprives it of effect.
transfers between parties once there is
agreement on the thing and price, regardless of whether price has been paid or delivery has occurred.
Transfer of ownership, Individualization
When an item must be individualized from a mass of things of the same kind, ownership transfers when that individualization occurs
When an item is sold by weight, count or measure, ownership transfers when
the seller weighs, counts, or measures the item
Lump Sales: When things, such as good or produce, are sold in a lump, there is no requirement of weight, count or measurement. Ownership transfers upon consent of the parties.
If buyer reserves the right to view or try the thing, ownership is not transferred until
the trial period ends (sale subject to a suspensive condition)
NOT the same as a right of inspection, which would be an issue of breach of contract – failure to deliver the thing contracted for
transfer of ownership of things in transit
using a common carrier, the bill of laiding controls
The risk of loss due to fortuitous events transfers from seller to buyer
at the time of delivery
When a contract requires seller to ship through a carrier, but does not require him to deliver the things at any particular destination, the risk of loss is transferred to buyer
on delivery of the things to the carrier.
When a contract requires seller to ship through a carrier, and specifies delivery at a particular destination, the risk of loss is transferred to buyer when
the things are tendered to buyer at the destination.
When the parties incorporate well-established commercial symbols into their contract, the risk of loss is transferred
according to the customary understanding of these symbols.
EXAMPLE: FOB; FAS
Obligations of Seller: Overview
a. Deliver the thing
b. Warrant the thing against:
(1) Eviction, and
(2) Redhibitory defects
c. Warrant the thing is fit for its intended use
Seller must clearly express the extent of his contractual obligations; any obscurity or ambiguity is interpreted against seller
seller fails to deliver the thing sold, buyer may:
(1) Demand specific performance
(2) Seek dissolution of the sale
(3) Seek damages
(immovables) Delivery takes place upon
execution of writing that transfers ownership
If there is a discrepancy between what was supposed to be sold and what is sold, however, seller’s duty will depend on the circumstances
(immovables) Sale by measure
occurs when the price is fixed at so much per measure (unit pricing).
(immovables) Sale by measure, under delivery. If seller delivers less than the full amount specified in the contract, the price is
proportionately reduced
(immovables) Sale by measure, over delivery.
If seller delivers more than the amount specified, buyer must pay seller a proportionate supplement of the price.
However, buyer may recede from the sale when the actual extent of the sale exceeds 5% of what was meant to have been delivered
Sale by lump price
occurs when the parties have specified the extent of the premises and agreed on a lump price.
Sale by lump price, Slight Discrepancies
There is no price change, and buyer cannot recede from the contract.
Sale by lump price, Over Delivery
If seller over delivers by more than 5%, buyer can recede from the contract or pay the increase.
sale by lump price, under delivery
If seller fails to deliver by more than 5%, price is reduced accordingly; buyer cannot recede from the contract
Sale per aversion
the sale of a certain and limited body or a distinct object.
There is no augmentation or reduction in purchase price if the thing delivered is actually more or less than what was represented in the act of sale.
(movables) Delivery takes place when seller
(1) delivers item to buyer, or (2) by another means agreed upon by the parties.
Delivery of incorporeal movable things incorporated into an instrument, such as stocks and bonds, takes place by
negotiating the instrument to buyer.
(Movable) cost of making a delivery is borne by
seller; the cost of receiving a delivery is borne by buyer, absent another agreement.
(movables) Delivery must be made at
the location of the item at the time of sale, absent another agreement
Seller must deliver the thing sold
in the same condition as parties expected, or should have expected, it to be in at time of delivery.
Buyer may reject non-conforming goods within
a reasonable time, upon giving notice to seller
If buyer does not reject the goods within a reasonable time
the goods are deemed accepted
A buyer who accepts non-conforming goods can’t later reject them for nonconformity, unless
the acceptance was made with a reasonable belief that the nonconformity would be cured.
After buyer’s rejection of goods, seller can cure non-conformity when
(1) time for performance has not expired, or (2) seller had a reasonable belief that the nonconforming things would be acceptable to buyer
(1) Seller must give reasonable notice of his intention to cure to buyer.
Buyer’s Remedies when rejecting goods
When seller fails to perform a contract of sale of movable things, buyer may purchase suitable things within a reasonable time and in good faith.
(2) Buyer can recover the difference between the contract price they agreed to and what they had to pay to buy the conforming goods.
Seller’s remedies for breach
(1) When buyer fails to perform a contract of sale of movable things, seller may resell those things still in his possession.
(2) Seller can also recover the difference between the contract price and the resale price, along with other damages.
Obligation of Seller: Warranty Against Eviction
Eviction is buyer’s loss of, or danger or losing, the whole or part of the thing sold because of a third person’s right that existed at the time of sale.
Seller warrants buyer against
(1) Eviction
(2) Encumbrances not declared at time of sale, except:
free from apparent servitudes
free from natural (non-apparent), legal servatudes
Rights and Duties of Buyer
a. Call in Warranty
(1) Buyer threatened with eviction must give timely notice of the threat to seller; bringing suit against buyer amounts to notice.
(2) If buyer fails to give such notice, or fails to give it in time for seller to defend himself, buyer forfeits the warranty to the extent seller can show he could have defended suit.