Rulings Flashcards
What happened in Marbury v Madison and when was it?
SCOTUS gave themselves the power of judicial review, they can strike down federal laws if deemed unconstitutional
1803
What happened in Fletcher v Peck?
1810
The Supreme Court extended the scope of judicial review and assumed right to take on the constitutionality of state laws too.
What happened in McCulloch v Maryland?
1819
Stated that the government had implied powers
The govt could set up a national bank
What happened in Gitlow v New York?
1925
States as well as Federal govt must respect the first amendment.
The adoption of the incorporation doctrine
What happened in Youngstown steel and Tube company v Sawyer?
1952
The President (Truman)s powers as commander in chief did not extend to large scale confiscation of property of steel for Korea war effort.
What happened in Brown v Board of Education, Topeka?
1954 Warren Court
Black people can go to white schools and Vice Versa. Ended de jure segregation
Segregation is unconstitutional! Change of zeitgeist, overturns Plessey v Ferguson
Segregation actually didn’t end until the 1964 Civil rights act. Not enforced
What happened in Miranda v Arizona?
1966
Criminal suspects must be advised of their rights. Evidence without Miranda rights is inadmissible
Warren court
What happened in Furman v Georgia?
1972 Burger
By a 5-4 majority the court stuck down all existing death penalty laws.
What happened in Roe v. Wade?
1973 Burger
Abortion is a constitutional right
What happened in Engel v Vitale?
1962 Warren Court
Outlawed prayer in public school
What happened in Gideon v Wainwright?
1963 Warren Court
Have the right to a free lawyer
What happened in Swann v Charlotte Mecklenburg Board of Education?
1971 Burger
Addressed de facto segregation and made the bussing of students across cities happen to address this issue
What happened in Greg v Georgia?
1976 Burger
Overruled Furman v Georgia (1972) and reinstated the death penalty
What happened in University of California Regents v Bakke?
1978 Burger
Only allowed affirmative action in very limited circumstances, reigned in AA. Court not fully upholding protection of minority groups
What happened in Argostini v Felton?
1997 Rehnquist
Allowed federally funded schoolteachers to provide remedial assistance to those in church run private schools.
What happened in Bush v Gore?
2000 Rehnquist
After the bitter dispute of Florida votes the Supreme Court essentially gave the election to Bush
What happened in Clinton v Jones?
1997 Rehnquist
The President can not be protected from civil actions bought by other citizens.
Paula Jones could then seek damages from Clinton who she alleged had sexually harassed her.
What happened in Clinton v New York?
1998
Struck down the line item veto
President had been able to delete individual items of expenditure from bills
What happened in Kansas v Hendricks?
1997 Rehnquist
Permitted states to pass laws requiring the confinement of sex offenders in mental hospitals after they had served imprisonment
What happened in Lee v Weisman?
1992 Rehnquist
Prayers at high school graduation ceremony is unconstitutional
What happened in Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v Casey?
1992 Rehnquist
Allowed 24 hour wait on abortions and parental permission laws for those underage
What happened in Texas v Johnson?
1989 Rehnquist
Freedom to burn the flag under fist amendment and a constitutional right
What happened in Washington v Gluksburg?
1997 Rehnquist
Allowed states to decide their assisted suicide laws
Oregon has assisted suicide laws now
What happened in Webster v Reproductive Health Services?
1989 Rehnquist
Can not use public facilities or employees in abortion.
What happened in Snyder v Phelps?
The Westborough baptist church is allowed to picket military funerals due to first amendment rights
2011 Roberts
What happened in Walmart v Dukes?
Roberts court refused to hear this big case of sex discrimination
What happened in Shelby County v Holder?
Struck down section 5 of the 1965 voting rights act
Stopped pre clearance, something that printed racial equality in voting
2013 Roberts
What happened in United States v Windsor?
2013 Roberts
Struck down DOMA (defence of marriage act)
Gay couples therefore allowed tax breaks the same as straight couples are
What happened in Hollingsworth v Perry?
It wasn’t heard
It was a case to limit same sex marriage
A step forward for gay rights
What happened in Obergefell v Hodges?
2015 Roberts
Allows same sex marriage, struck down DOMA
What happened in King v Burwell?
2015 Roberts
Upheld obamacare insurance subsidy
What happened in Fisher v. University of Texas?
2016 Roberts
Upheld universities affirmative action programme
What happened in US v. Texas?
Struck down Obama’s immigration reform
A limitation on the presidents power
What happened in whole woman’s health v Hellerstedt?
2016 Roberts
The court make Texas make it easier to access abortion.
What happened in Trump v International Refuge Assistance Project?
2017 Roberts
First time struck down and later upheld when make to include North Korea
What happened in Fry v Napoleon Community School?
2017 Roberts
Confirmed right for girl to have assistance dog with her through the whole school day
What happened in DC v Heller?
2008 Roberts
Upheld the right of the people to own guns personally. Arguably a loose constructionist reading ‘militia’
NRA influence
questioned by the idea of a right to safety
What happened in Pollock v Farmers loan and trust company?
1895
Said the government couldn’t impose a federal income tax
16th amendment changes this
What happened in Hamdan v Rumsfeld?
2006 Roberts
Guantanamo bay is unconstitutional as rights in the constitution apply to all citizens on overseas US territories and therefore military tribunals are wrong.
Limiting power of GWB
What happened in Bowers v Hardwick?
1986
Upheld a law that made consensual gay sex illegal
What happened in Lawrence v Texas?
2003 Rehnquist
Overturned Bowers v Hardwick
Gay consensual sex not illegal
What happened in Plessey v Ferguson?
1896
Upheld racial segregation, on a separate but equal basis
Overturn by Brown v the Board 1954
What happened in Korematsu v US?
1944
Upheld executive order that put Japanese citizens into internment camps, the court did not strike this down despite being a clear breech of rights
What happened in Dred Scott v Sandford?
1857
Black people could not be citizens, slaves were not protected under the constitution
What happened in NFIB v Sebelius?
2012 Roberts
Upheld obamacare
states can not be compelled to accept federally funded medicare expension in Obamacare
this was 5-4 but Roberts tipped the balance, we cannot clearly label justices conservative or liberal
What happened in Burwell v Hobby Lobby?
2014 Roberts
Corporations don’t have to cover contraception for employees for religious reasons. This mandate was part of the ACA
What happened in Citizens v FEC? (Federal election commission)
2010 Roberts
Said that you couldn’t limit spending of business in elections as this is a first amendment right. Extended this right to corporations.
What happened in Gonzales v Oregon?
2006 Roberts
Upheld the states right to decide to assisted suicide
Oregon could keep their assisted suicide laws
What happened in Brown v Entertainment Merchants Association?
2011 Roberts
Struck down a law banning sale of certain video games to under 18s
What happened in Maryland v King?
2013 Roberts
Can use DNA in criminal investigations, not an unreasonable search or seizure
interesting that the normal liberal Breyer voted with the majority and the ‘conservative Scalia was in minority
What happened in Buckley v Valeo?
1976 Burger
Linked money to free speech
What happened in Lopez v US?
1995
Struck down gun free zones around schools
What happened in Nixon v US?
1974
Ruled Nixon had to hand White House tapes over
What happened in Baze v. Rees?
2008 Roberts
Lethal injection does not violate 8th amendment
What happened in league of American citizens v.Perry?
Gerrymandering deemed legal
2006 Roberts
What happened in Gonzales v Raich 2005?
Even if state laws allow use of medical marijuana, the UC congress can still deem it illegal and criminalise its growth and use
What happened in ACLU v Clapper? 2015
Dismissed
Patriot Act collection of communications metadata does not violate the fourth amendment right against u reasonable searches and seizures.
What happened in US v Morrison? 2000
The court struck down a violence against women act as this legislation should have been left to the states under amendment 10
what happened in Washington v Glucksburg? 1997
assisted suicide Is not a constitutional right, left to states to decide
What happened in Us v Texas 2016?
blocked DAPA, immigration for parents
What happened in Reno v ACLU?
struck down communications decency act under the first amendment 1997, upheld freedom of the press
What happened in Dimaya v Sessions?
Gorsuch voted with the liberals against Trump’s position
Justices are interpreters of the constitution, not politicians lapdogs
Why is the Patriot Act unconstitutional?
wire tapping and electronic surveilance, a clear breech of ‘unreasonable searches and seizures’ and the ‘right to privacy’
What was Gonzales v Carhart? 2007
Upheld partial birth abortion ban