Rules on Past Exams Flashcards
To exercise personal jurisdiction over a nonresident defendant, a Virginia court needs to satisfy…
both the Virginia Long Arm statute and show that the exercise of does not violate principles of Due process.
The Virginia long-arm statute includes someone who:
- Causes tortious injury instate by act or omission instate
- Causes tortious injury instate by act or omission out of state
- Contracts to supply services or things in Virginia
- Has an interest in, uses or possesses realty in Virginia
- Transacts any business in Virginia
- Causing injury in Virginia by breach of warranty where sale was out of state.
- Domestic relations
Virginia is a single transaction state, meaning…
one business transaction leading to the cause of action will suffice.
After the long arm statute is satisfied…
you must evaluate whether the minimum contacts of a nonresident that lead to the claim in the case are sufficient in quality and nature to make it reasonable to exercise personal jurisdiction.
The minimum contacts test is satisfied if…
the defendant had contacts with Virginia displaying purposeful availment of Virginia’s laws and, thus, putting the defendant on reasonable notice of suit in VA.
So long as the contact has a substantial connection to the forum, even a ______ ___ cansatisfy due process.
Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12, a defendant is not required to either make a _______ __________ before or simultaneously with a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction.
special appearance
So long as the defendant _________________________ for lack of personal jurisdiction in the first-filed challenge to the plaintiff’s Complaint, such as in the first motion filed, then the personal jurisdiction defense is preserved.
files a timely motion to dismiss
To satisfy diversity jurisdiction, two requirements must be met:
- There must be complete diversity of citizenship, meaning that every plaintiff is a citizen of a State different from every defendant.
- The amount in controversy must exceed $75,000 exclusive of interests and costs.
The test for citizenship of individuals is…
the person’s domicile.
What is a person’s domicile?
(a) where the individual has a physical residence, and (b) the intent to make the residence his or her permanent physical residence.
Where does a corporation hold its citizenship?
in its State of incorporation and in the state where the corporation has its principal place of business.
The general rule precludes a plaintiff from aggregation the amount of damages when she…
joins more than one defendant so as to exceed $75,000 exclusive of interests and costs.
What is the exception to the rule against aggregating claim amounts?
Aggrefation of damages of claims is allowed against two or more defendants whose negligence jointly contributed to a single injury, such that they are jointly liable.
The amount required to comply with an injunction is…
deemed to be the amount in controversy.
Under the Supplemental Jurisdiction statute, claims without SMJ are allowed in federal court when they…
arise from the same common nucleus of operative facts.
Venue is proper where:
- All of the defendants reside, or
- where a a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred.
What is the exception to the venue rule?
If the defendants are all from one state, venue is proper in any district in that one state.
Transfer is only available if the transferee district…
is one where the original case might have been brought.
You can only appeal when…
there is a final order in the case. There are narrow exceptions for an appealable interlocutory order.
In cases removed to Federal Court based on diversity, the case can be removed after a later change in the case creates diversity, so long as…
the change and removal occur within one year from commencement of the action.
What is the deadline to file a notice of removal in a case after a change in its status creating diversity?
30 days from receipt of the order showing the change in the status of the case.
The amount in controvery is still satisfied even if…
the plaintiff settles with one party for an amount that, if deducted from the total amount, would be less than $75,000. The plaintiff is entitled to seek from a single tortfeasor the entire amount of injury from an incident.
Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12, a defendant can preserve any of the highly waivable Rule 12 defenses by…
raising any such defenses in its first defensive filing within 21 days of service on the defendant.
What are the highly waivable defenses?
12(b)(2)-(5).
- PJ
- Venue
- Process
- Service of Process
The defendant can choose to file a motion as his first defensive filing, or he can choose instead to file an answer. The key is that…
whichever of the two is the first defensive filing, he includes the highly waivable defense in that filing.
As long as a waivable defense is reserved, a later-filed motion can proceed to…
bring on for resolution the question of personal jurisdiction.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12, therefore, rejects the classic general appearance doctrine. Under that doctrine…
personal jurisdiction had to be raised by the defendant’s appearing by special appearance solely to challenge jurisdiction and by filing a motion to dismiss based on personal jurisdiction, not an answer.
General jurisdiction has been reserved to instances in which a company is…
“at home” in a state.
The Supreme Court has indicated that the primary ways that a company would be at home in a state is by…
incorporating there or having its principal place of business in the State.
Lacking incorporation or having one’s principal place of business in a state, even substantial conduct and sales in a state—unrelated to the claim in question—have been insufficient to establish general jurisdiction.