RPIRM - EDGE Flashcards
Duties of the Trustee (9)
- Duty of loyalty
- Duty of care
- Duty to diversify plan assets
- Duty of impartiality
- Duty to delegate
- Duty to follow statutory constraints
- Duty to make the property productive
- Duty regarding co-trustees
- Duty to act in accordance with the trust agreement
US Safe Harbor for Shifting Responsibility for Investment Decisions to Plan Members (3)
- Have at least 3 diversified investment options covering a broad range of investment options
- Can transfer fund at least quarterly
- Sufficient information upon which to make an informed decision (investment managers, description of funds, etc.)
Disclosures that must be made upon the participants request (5)
- Description of plan expenses
- Prospectuses, financial statements and reports
- List of asset and their value within the investment
- Value of shares or units available to participants and past investment performance
- Information concerning the value of shares or units in investment alternatives held by the beneficiary
Points regarding 404(c) Protection (Responsibilities of the Fiduciary) (5)
- Fiduciary remains liable for the prudent selection and management funds to be offered
- Fiduciary remains liable for prudent investment and diversification of plan assets if plan does not offer member choices
- Multi-fund plan fiduciary not complying with 404(c) responsible for the prudent investment of plan funds
- Fiduciary responsible for prudent asset mix if changes allowed less often than quarterly
- It is transactional
Requirements for 404(c) Protection for Default Fund used with Automatic Enrollment (7)
- Must be QDIA (Plan sponsor fiduciary responsible for selecting and monitoring QDIA)
- Participant had opportunity to direct investments but did not do so
- Must notify participants at least 30 days before initial investment and each subsequent plan year
- Provide ERISA 404(c) fee and expense disclosures
- Can transfer assets at least quarterly
- QDIA fees same for everyone
- Must offer at least 3 broad range investments
QDIA Requirements (4)
- Can’t be employer stock unless part of a mutual fund
- Can transfer out within 90 days
- Must be professionally managed by regulated firm or named fiduciary
- Must be one of the following
- TDF or Target life expectancy fund
- Balanced fund
- Actively managed account similar to 2 above
- Preserve capital (120 days only)
Role of the plan administrator includes: (3)
- Managing the plan assets (following prudent principles)
- Drafting an investment policy
- Ensuring assets are managed according to the investment policy and legislation
Fiduciaries must: (3)
- Act in prudent manner
- Manage/make decisions in the best interest of plan members
- Exercise due diligence
Due diligence means making decisions based on: (2)
- Adequate information
2. Documenting decisions, motives and circumstances
Steps that demonstrate a prudent investment strategy (4)
- Developed
- Adopted
- Implemented
- Monitored
Prudent investment practices take into account (4)
- Nature of plan liabilities
- Timing of payments
- Expected future experience
- Demographics of plan members
Prudent investment principles (5)
- Prudent person rule
- Prudent delegation
- Define investment objectives
- Develop an investment policy
- Proper monitoring
When delegating functions, plan administrator… (2)
- Must do so prudently
2. Remains responsible for delegated activities (should review and monitor the delegates)
Clearly defined investment objectives allows the risks associated with the objectives (2)
- To be understood
2. To be actively managed
Investment objectives should be consistent with the plan’s (4)
- Retirement income objectives
- Liabilities
- Demographics
- Ability to accommodate investment volatility
Investment objectives should reflect (2)
- Relevant legal provisions
2. Relevant investment principles regarding asset allocation, diversification and liquidity
Investment policy/ SIP&P should (6)
- Reflect plan’s investment objectives
- Specify investment principles, strategic asset allocation, performance objectives, etc.
- Life investment restrictions
- Identify the asset allocation
- Identify the plan’s expected returns
- Address the nature and extent of anticipated risk
When monitoring, administrator should (5)
- Review investment objectives and risk tolerances
- Ensure adequate investment procedures are in place
- Review key investment decisions
- Ensure service providers are monitored and measured
- Review plan’s investment performance
Purpose of pension governance (3)
- Structure / process for effective administration
- Ensure fiduciary compliance
- Ensure participants receive benefits according to plan terms and understand their rights/responsibilities
An effective pension governance system incorporates (3)
- Framework for defining duties
- All pension aspects (management, communication, funding)
- Oversight to protect plan members
Advantages of good governance (6)
- Meet fiduciary requirements
- Minimize risks and inefficiencies
- Promote accurate and timely delivery of benefits
- Consistent benefits administration
- Provides control mechanisms to facilitate decision making, efficient practices, accountability and review
- Facilitates positive plan performance
Fiduciary must (5)
- Treat members impartially
- Act with care, skill and diligence of a prudent person
- Interpret plan terms fairly
- Prevent personal conflict of interest
- Ensure members receive benefits
Risk management governance framework should (6)
- Identify risks
- Assess / prioritize risks
- Responsibilities for managing risk
- Define acceptable risks
- Design response to mitigate
- Monitor
Participant Communications Should (3)
- Outline process for asking and raising questions
- Communicate how important decisions are made
- Information about plan’s risks, benefits, options and participants responsibilities
Investment Behavior DC Sponsors are Likely to See Among the Norm (4)
- Correlated equity allocation decisions
- High utilization in hybrid allocations
- Static asset allocations
- Tax inefficiencies
Investment Behavior DC Sponsors are Likely to See among the Minority (4)
- Trade too much
- Invest too much in company stock
- Insufficiently diversified
- Invest too much or not enough in equities
Likely to see among the Norm Higher Equity Allocations Correlated with (12)
- Positive stock market performance
- Younger age
- Higher education
- Higher income
- Longer investment horizons
- Higher risk tolerance
- Higher number of investment choices
- Not participating in a DC plan
- Good health
- Married
- Non-union
- Male
Theory to understand causes of irrational investment behavior is called
Prospect Theory (argues investors follow an investment process)
Prospect Theory Investment Process
Phase 1 (Framing and Editing): Decision affected by the way the problem is presented and the investors habits and expectations
Phase 2 (Evaluation): Decision affected by investor’s risk aversion
Party Responsible for Oversight of DC Plan Investments
- For DC, if ee has no control over how assets are invested, er has full responsibility
- For DC, if ee has choices, er bears responsibility of selecting investment funds and making sure find line-up is diverse and competitive (can reduce fiduciary liability through 404(c))
Items DC Sponsors should Provide Participants (3)
- An investment framework
- Guidance
- A range of investment options
To Increase Tax Inefficiency, DC Sponsors should Recommend Participants to… (2)
- Invest bonds in pre-tax fund
2. Invest equities in after-tax fund
Reasons why DC Governance is more complicated than DB Governance (3)
- DC plans are participant-directed
- Participants have unique financial circumstances
- Participants have different investment abilities
DC Sponsors should Facilitate Best-Practice (3)
- Skills
- Resources
- Processes
Items DC Sponsors should Review (5)
- Investment performance
- Program’s effectiveness reaching HR goals
- Program’s likelihood of reaching targeted replacement ratios
- Asset allocations selected by participants
- Program’s legal compliance
DC Governance should Address 3 common DC Structural flaws
- Participant lack of investment skills
- Providing a sub-optimal investment line-up
- Not offering annuities
Due to 3 common flaws, DC Fiduciaries should consider the following principles (4)
- Participants’ needs and circumstances
- Correct framing on retirement adequacy
- Protect participants from themselves
- Provide simple but not simplistic solutions
Items designed to address structural flaws 1 and 2 (5)
- Fewer and lower cost investment options
- Automatic enrollment
- Auto-escalation contribution rates
- Professionally managed target-date funds
- Advice and financial education
Key Attributes to a Successful DC Plan (9)
- Empowerment within the scope of ability
- Design-making support
- Comprehensive risk profiling
- Efficient investment building blocks
- Offer options with protection
- Right amount of fund choice
- Cost controlled
- Easy-to-understand reporting against objectives
- Well-defined governance aligned with participant needs
Building blocks DC Plan investment structure (3)
Tier 1 funds (Asset allocation funds): Professionally managed TDF and lifestyle funds
Tier 2 funds (Core funds): Participant managed funds
Tier 3 funds (Specialty funds): Participant managed
Advantage of offering Tier 1 funds
Asset allocation decision is outsourced
Disadvantage of offering Tier 1 funds
May not reflect participant’s unique risk profile
Advantages of offering Tier 2 funds (2)
- Exposed to major asset classes
2. Can develop desired risk / return profile
Should only offer actively managed Tier 2 funds if (2)
- Believe markets are inefficient
2. Sponsor can select managers with skill
Advantage of offering Tier 3 funds
Attractive to highly compensated and sophisticated participants
Items fiduciaries should consider when offering / evaluating TDF (5)
- Potential impact on decisions / strategy
- Capacity constraints
- Manager invested in fund?
- Fund’s principle strategies / objectives and risks
- Fees
Target-Date Glide Path Characteristics affecting Risk / Reward (4)
- Initial and ultimate asset allocations
- Slope (market-timing risk)
- To vs. Through
- Sub-asset classes (type, weight, active/passive)
Glide Path Balances the Following Risks (2)
- Longevity (higher equity allocation)
2. Market (higher fixed income allocation)
Comparing TDF performance (2)
- Differentiate based on risk exposures
2. Apply goals-based framework
ERISA DC Fiduciaries responsible for (related to services)
Ensuring services DC plan receives are charged reasonable fees and that services are necessary
Best-practice Considerations for ERISA DC Fiduciaries (4)
- Develop inventory of fees paid by the plan
- Benchmark fees
- Review service agreements and contracts for appropriate scope and transparency
- Assess record keeper services compared to other vendors
Plan Fiduciary Responsibilities (2)
- Act in best interest of participants (Prudence + Care)
2. Monitor Delegates
Services used to help with plan investments (2)
- Investment management
2. Investment consulting
Role of an independent investment consultant (5)
- Establish overall investment policies
- Write investment policy statements
- Benchmark investment results
- Ensure all appropriate asset classes are represented
- Ensure plan fiduciaries are discharging duties appropriately
The investment management process (3 steps)
- Develop SIPP
- Implement
- Monitor
DB SIPP should address (6)
- Investment objectives
- Investment specifics
- Manager selection/termination
- Performance measurement (expected return, monitoring)
- Risks (tolerance, management, measurement)
- Governance
Required Considerations when Setting the DB Investment Policy (3)
- Liabilities
- Funded Status
- Factors affecting funding and solvency
Member-Directed DC Plan’s SIPP should Include / Address (7)
- Investment Philosophy
- Permitted asset classes
- Default Investment options
- Monitoring process
- Manager selection / termination
- Fees / expenses
- Investment communications to participants
Types of Risks Addressed in SIPP (3)
- Asset based
- Liability based
- Asset-Liability-based
Example of Liability-Based Risk
Longevity
Example of Asset-Liability Risk
Solvency
Example of Assets Risks (17)
- Active management
- Alternative asset
- Asset concentration
- Compliance
- Counterparty
- Country
- Currency
- Derivative
- Index-tracking
- Inflation
- Interest rate
- Investment style
- Leverage
- Liquidity
- Market
- Operational
- Securities lending
Examples of outcomes investment categories (4)
- Absolute return
- Yield-generating assets
- Low volatility
- Low correlation with rest of fund
Examples of traditional investment categories (2)
- Style
2. Geography
Sponsor’s Fiduciary Responsibility: Ensure Investment Decisions Process (3)
- Sound
- Systematic
- Informed
Recommended first step in managers selection process is to consider (5)
- Number of managers
- Type (Specialty / Balanced)
- Style
- Primary approach (Fundamental / Quantitative)
- Active / Passive management
Factors affecting the manager selection (7)
- Cost
- Oversight resources
- Diversification
- Benchmark volatility
- Varying expertise between managers
- Ability to add value by switching asset classes
- Market efficiency of different asset classes
Desired attributes of the manager (8)
- Expertise in a specific asset class
- An established investment team
- Minimum level of assets under management
- No significant issues involving the overall organization
- Low portfolio turnover
- Above median performance over the past 5 years
- Below median performance volatility over the past 5 years
- Reasonable fees
Plan size affects the following items (4)
- Risk distribution
- Manager selection
- How funds will be invested (asset classes, type of account)
- Economies of scale
Plan size and its impact on risk (2 small, 2 large)
Small plans:
- Less asset class diversification
- Use of separate accounts leads toward active management concentration risk
Large plans:
- Lack of high-quality managers for needed asset classes
- Balancing active management risk and avoiding low-quality managers
Plan size and use of separate and commingled fund
Large plans: Separate accounts
Small plans: Commingled accounts
Disadvantages of active management concentration (2)
- Potentially lower returns
2. Diverge from peer groups
Advantages of separate accounts (5)
- Access and fee scale to sophisticated managers
- Can customize plan
- Can customize tracking error targets
- Specify risk parameters
- Can develop performance statistics
Disadvantages of customized accounts (2)
- Require significant oversight
2. Implementation risks
Advantages of commingled accounts (5)
- Many exist
- Provide investment solutions
- Can develop performance statistics
- Facilitates cost-effective allocations
- Access to high-quality managers
Disadvantages of commingled accounts (2)
- Active management risk if only one manager
2. Must monitor the manager’s performance, risk and style consistency
Typical investment cost (4)
- Investment management
- Custodial
- Transaction costs
- Administration
Small Plans and Costs
Need economies of scale through commingling
Performance measurement should be carried out in the context of (3)
- Plan’s current value
- Current and expected contribution levels
- Anticipated liabilities or expenditure requirements
Advantages of performance evaluation (3)
- Enhances the effectiveness of a fund’s investment policy
- Identifies the program’s strengths and weaknesses
- Provides trustees evidence program is being conducted appropriately
Types of Performance Evaluations (2)
- Comparative performance
2. Benchmark-based
Properties of a valid benchmark (7)
- Unambiguous
- Investable
- Measurable
- Appropriate
- Reflective of current investment options
- Specified in advance
- Owned
Types of benchmark (7)
- Absolute
- Manager universe (median manager or fund)
- Broad market indexes (TSX, S&P500)
- Style indexes (small cap, large cap)
- Factor-model-based benchmark
- Returns-based benchmarks
- Custom security-based benchmark
Median of Manager Universe as Benchmark not Valid Because (4)
- Can’t be specified in advance
- Not investable
- Typically Ambiguous
- Subject to survivor bias
Steps to building custom security-based benchmarks (5)
- Identify aspects of the manager’s investment process
- Select securities consistent with that process
- Devise a weighting scheme for the benchmark securities, including cash position
- Review preliminary benchmark and make modifications
- Rebalance benchmark on a predetermined schedule
Criteria used to test whether a benchmark is good or bad (6)
- Should be minimal systematic biases relative to the account over time
- Tracking error should be minimal
- Account’s exposure to systematic sources of risk should be similar to benchmark over time
- Manager’s account should have high coverage relative to benchmark
- The benchmark’s turnover should not be excessive
- The manager should not be expected to hold largely positive active positions for actively managed long-only accounts
Methods of measuring investment returns (3)
- Money-weighted rate of return (IRR)
- Time-weighted rate of return
- Linked internal rate of return
Advantage of IRR
Account only valued at the beginning and end of the evaluation period
Disadvantages of IRR (2)
- R can’t be solved directly
2. Sensitive to the size and timing of external cash flows while TWR is not
Advantages of TWR (2)
- Not sensitive to the size and timing of external cash flows
- Accurately reflects how an investor would have fared over the period
Disadvantage of TWR
Account valued every time an external cash flow occurs (more expensive and more error prone)
TWR vs. MWR
MWR more appropriate if manager maintains control over the timing and amount of cash flows
Stock’s risk (definition)
Return variance and covariance with other stock returns in the portfolio
Tracking error (definition)
Standard deviation of the difference between the portfolio’s return and the benchmark
Information ratio (definition)
Portfolio’s average active return divided by its tracking error
Sharpe ratio
Excess return of the portfolio divided by its volatility
Efficient portfolio (definition)
Portfolio with the highest expected return for a target level of risk. Highest information ratio possible given the risk budget. All risks are compensated
Active management in an EPM context
Overweighting attractive stocks and underweighting unattractive stocks relative to benchmark weights
Four major steps in the EPM investment process
- Forecasting returns, risks and transaction costs
- Constructing efficient portfolios
- Trading stocks efficiently
- Evaluating results and updating the process
Characteristics of a well-structured investment process (6)
- Sound economic logic
- Diverse information sources
- Careful empirical analysis
- Reliable forecasts
- Effective implantation
- Easy to explain
EPM Approaches (2)
- Traditional
2. Quantitative
Traditional Approach
Construct an in-depth stock-specific analysis (talk to senior management, study financial statements, conduct competitive analysis)
Advantages of the traditional approach
More in depth knowledge than quantitative approach:
- Cope with data errors
- Cope with company’s structural changes
- Understand data sources
- Incorporate qualitative factors
Disadvantages of the traditional approach (5)
- Relies heavily on analyst judgement
- Costly
- Difficult to evaluate
- Typically relies on only the most distinctive factors
- Fewer and larger bets taken
Quantitative approach
Use statistical models to forecast each stock’s return, risk and cost of trading
Advantages of the quantitative approach (8)
- Transparent
- Minimizes subjective bias
- Cost effective
- Model can be tested historically
- Can uncover opportunities more quickly and efficiently than traditional approach
- Spreads risk over many companies
- Every specified factor considered before reaching a conclusion
- Model is stochastic
Disadvantages of the quantitative approach (3)
- Subject to specification errors
- Overfitting
- Model can be misleading
Process for forecasting returns (quantitative approach) (4 steps)
- Identify signals
- Test the effectiveness of each signal
- Determine signal weights
- Blend output with market equilibrium
Forecasting risk
- Consider the frequency of data to use
- The more observations the better
- Consider giving more weight to recent observations
Methods of forecasting transaction costs (2)
- Examine the complete record
2. Use own trades to develop a model
Transaction costs have two components (2)
- Implicit costs
2. Explicit costs
Approach to constructing an efficient portfolio (2)
- Rule-based system
2. Portfolio optimization
Rule-based system
- Rank stocks based on a few key risk factors
- Invests heavily in the highest-ranked stocks while keeping the portfolio’s total weight close to the benchmark
Advantage of rule-based system
Portfolio is neutral with respect to identified risk factors while overweighting attractive stocks and underweighting unattractive stocks
Disadvantages of rule-based system (2)
- Not very efficient
2. Can’t explicitly consider trading costs
Advantages of the portfolio optimization approach (3)
- Expected returns and risk/cost/constraints better balanced
- Facilitates portfolio customization
- Only requires use of forecasts
Portfolio optimization caveat
Need to make sure model’s inputs are reliable
Evaluating results and updating the process
- Compare actual results against expected
- Determine sources of under and over performance
Advantages of Alternative Investments (Private Equity or Hedge Fund) (3)
- Lower volatility
- Higher absolute and risk-adjusted returns
- Varied correlations
Risks Particularly Unique to Alternative Investments (9)
- Market
- Illiquidity
- Valuation
- Operational
- Regulatory Obligations (Lack of)
- Strategy Risk
- Counterparty Risk
- Sub-Advisor Risk
- Unstable / Unreliable Vendor
Common Characteristics of Illiquid Investments (Private Equity) (5)
- Return Premium (3%+)
- High dispersion of returns
- Long time horizon before profits (10+ years)
- Upfront commitment
- Potential good fit for pensions
Hedge Funds designed to look for (2)
- Arbitrage opportunities
2. Pricing Inefficiencies
Characteristics of hedge funds (8)
- Purest form of active management
- Loosely Regulated
- Lack of Transparency
- Performance fees paid
- Short lived
- Illiquid
- May experience capacity constraints
- Unconstrained with regard to short selling, leverage, instruments, strategies
Typical fund fee structure of hedge funds
Fixed management fee + Performance fee subject to high water mark
Main advantage of hedge funds
Provide opportunity to both enhance expected returns and reduce risk
Short selling (definition)
- Borrow then sell asset and repurchase it later
- Sell high and buy low (hedge against another asset, exploit relative price movements)
Hedge fund strategies (4)
- Relative value
- Event driven
- Equity long/short
- Tactical trading
Private Equity Investment (definition)
Any ownership interest not publicly traded, except for real estate
Advantages of private equity (5)
- Efficient market hypothesis does not apply (high returns)
- Illiquid market may reduce purchase price
- Long-term focus
- Have more company control
- Can decide when to exit investment
Disadvantages of private equity (2)
- Lack of transparency makes analysis difficult
2. Market illiquid/difficult to sell
Private equity investment strategies include (4)
- Buying start-ups
- Restructuring large company
- Repositioning large company
- Innovation
Investment Characteristics of Infrastructure (4)
- Defensive - less risk (higher barrier to entry, monopoly-like, less sensitive to business cycle, inflation protection)
- Long operational life
- High operating margins
- Reliable long term cash flow
Potential advantages of Infrastructure as a pension investment (3)
- Enhanced diversification
- Match liability profile with cash flows
- Higher risk/return optimization
Infrastructure’s similarities/differences with other asset classes
Fixed income (Long-term predictable cashflow/Inflation hedge, low interest rate risk
Real estate (Physical Asset/Barrier to entry, predictable cash flow)
Private Equity (Management control/Longer time horizon)
Equities (Equity ownership/Fewer securitization)
Infrastructure risks (6)
- Patronage / Demand
- Regulatory
- Contractual / Credit
- Operational / Constrution
- Financing / Inflation
- Liquidity
Essential Traits Needed for an Infrastructure Investment Team (6)
- In-depth sector knowledge
- Transaction capabilities
- Operational experience
- Access to Quality deal flow
- Ability to select best opportunities
- Apply strict governance
Risks with emerging market investments (8)
- Lack of reliable information
- Currency risk
- Poor legal infrastructure (may permit insider trading)
- Political instability
- Different accounting systems
- Transaction costs
- Shareholder rights
- Ability to recover investment
Major sources of fixed income risk (10)
- Interest rate risk
- Yield curve risk
- Sector risk
- Credit risk
- Volatility risk
- Prepayment risk
- Currency risk
- Security-Specific risk
- Reinvestment risk
- Liquidity risk
Measurement typically used to measure interest rate risk exposure
Duration
Ways to construct portfolios with the same duration but different exposures to yield curve risk (3)
- Bulleted
- Barbelled
- Laddered
Measurement typically used to measure yield curve risk exposure
Key-Rate Duration (Portfolio’s duration that comes from cash flows in each part of the yield curve)
Measurement typically used to measure sector risk exposure
Contribution to duration (MV weighted average duration of sector holdings x MV weight holdings in sector)
Credit risk usually defined by…
Nationally recognized rating organization
Volatility risk
Risk bond value impacted by how much interest rates move in either direction
Arises when instrument has asymmetric payoffs
Types of risk exposures that arise when investing in embedded options
- Gamma exposure
2. Vega risk
Gamma exposure
- Market value impact from experiencing a change in interest rates
- If you are long volatility then you gain from market movement
- Convexity used to quantify gamma exposure
Vega risk
- Risk due to a change in the market’s expectation of future volatility of interest rates
- Volatility duration is used to quantify vega risk
Volatility duration
Percentage change in bond price due to a 1% change in expected future (or implied) volatility
Prepayment risk
- Defined as the return volatility arising from the over or underestimation of actual prepayment rates
- Prepayment duration used to quantify prepayment risk
Prepayment duration
-Percentage change in price due to a 10% increase in projected prepayment rates
Currency risk
Can mitigate/eliminate risk using currency hedging techniques such as currency forward contracts
Active management strategies…
Change the risk exposure of the portfolio to maximize return given a level of risk or minimize risk given a level of return
Most widely used active management fixed income strategies (6)
- Duration timing
- Yield Curve positioning
- Sector allocation
- Security selection
- Country allocation
- Currency allocation
Combining active strategies using risk budgeting…
Need to allocate risk efficiently across investment idea and strategies
Risk budgeting process/steps used to maximize return per budgeted level of risk (7)
- Determine benchmark
- Determine investment constraints
- Determine permissible active strategies
- Determine maximum tracking error allowed
- Estimate information ratio
- Determine the target excess return or tracking error
- Determine the optimal amount of risk to each strategy
Ready to determine appropriate allocation once you determine… (5)
- What strategies can be used
- How much could be allocated to each strategy
- How good you are at generating returns in each strategy
- How you expect them to move together
- How much risk or return looking to achieve
Successful investing (5)
- Reposition risk to create return
- Maximize return per unit of risk
- Diversify
- Avoid concentrated risks
- Understand sources of risk
Central them of MPT
Look at the expected return of each investment in relation to the impact that it has on the risk of the overall portfolio
Risk and return estimates (characteristics)
- Estimating expected returns problematic
2. Estimating volatility is more complex but more easily quantified
Implied views (other name)
Hurdle Rates
Repositioning risk allocations…
- Improves the portfolio’s expected return
2. Assets that reduce risk are less expensive on budget
Traditional portfolio immunization strategy
Requires prior specification of expected excess return for all of the assets
Alternative technique based on MPT to optimize a portfolio’s return to risk ratio
- Analyse the risk margins to decide whether to sell/purchase asset
- Portfolio optimal when expected excess return per marginal contribution is the same for all assets in the portfolio
Advantages of the alternative technique (2)
- Can calculate excess return on one asset and back out the implied views on all of the others
- Analysis based on more risk statistics than expected return statistics
Active vs management decision
Directed by belief about the EMH
EMH
- Active manager can’t outperform index
- No arbitrage opportunities
- Market reflects all information
- Stock price movement is random
- Stock prices unpredictable apart from a long-term trend
EMH supported historically by (2)
- Net of expenses, most active funds do not outperform index
- Data does not support strong performance persistence
Advantages of passive investing (4)
- Low management fees
- No active management risk
- Low transaction costs
- Returns close to benchmark
Disadvantages of passive investing (3)
- Most require high dollar minimums
- No opportunity to reduce risk relative to benchmark
- Return typically less than benchmark by the amount of management fees
ERM steps of evaluating a pension plan’s risk (5)
- Identify the stakeholders
- Identify risk
- Quantify risk
- Separate risk
- Manage risk
Things to consider when managing pension assets relative to the firm’s economic strength (4)
- Corporate risk in addition to pension risk must be considered
- Must coordinate pension assets with corporate strength to minimize business interference
- Must reflect liabilities to address surplus volatility
- Must coordinate pension assets, liabilities and corporate strength to maximize firms expected life
Risks to participant and shareholder by funding strategies (3 strategies)
- Pay as you go:
- P: Will company be around to pay benefit
- S: Future shareholder must pay benefits - Balanced asset allocation:
- P: Will the company be able to make up any future shortfall
- S: Shortfall/Surplus addressed bu future shareholder - ALM asset allocation:
- P: Risk is very small
- S: Large up-front contribution and minimal possibility of surplus
General framework to follow when determining an asset allocation (4 steps)
- Identify stakeholders and their needs
- Identify risks
- Quantify risk
- Separate and manage risk
Three dimensions to risk management
- Panning
- Budgeting
- Monitoring
Risk management wants to (3)
- Identify risk exposure
- Measure risk exposures
- Report risk exposures to senior management
Measures of risk (2)
- VaR
2. Tracking error
Risk plan should include/address the following items (6)
- Set expected return and volatility goals
- Define points of success and failure
- Determine how risk capital will be used to meet objectives
- Determine events that are disappointing vs life threatening
- Identify critical dependencies
- Involve senior leadership in the planning process
Advantages of involving senior leadership in the risk plan (3)
- Risk and return issues are addressed, understood and communicated
- Can better describe context for risk and financial capital allocations
- Better understand risks needed to generate profits