Risk Management in Banks Flashcards
How to conduct risk management?
3
1) IDENTIFY the risks
2) MEASURE the risks
3) MANAGE the risks
What is Interest rate risk?
The most pertinent risk in the bank given the bank’s business model.
What is liquidity risk?
Systematic risk where liquidity might dry up.
Liquidity dry up: Lack of liquidity, lesser buyers, lesser market participants, more volatile
What do financial intermediaries do?
2
They intermediate between suppliers and demanders of funds.
E.g.
1) If lenders and buyers have some differences, such that they do not want to talk to each other, financial intermediaries would step in to bridge the gap.
2) Helps to reduce the costs between lenders and borrowers
What type of intermediation are available?
3
1) Maturity Intermediation
2) Denomination Intermediation
3) Risk Intermediation
What is Maturity Intermediation?
*Note that maturity for deposits is 0.
- Borrow short-term loans from depositers and pay them interest
- Loan out long-term loans to lenders who pay higher interest
> Profits are made from the differences in interest rate
> Banks (Financial Intermediaries) step in facilitate such services so that funds continue to flow
What is an example of Maturity Intermediation?
A financial institution can BORROW money from certificates of deposits or demand deposits, then LOAN out the money as a 30-mortgage.
What is Denomination Intermediation?
A process whereby small investors are able to purchase pieces of assets that are sold only in large denominations.
What is an example of Denomination Intermediation?
Mutual funds pool small amounts to purchase a well-diversified portfolio of assets.
What is risk intermediation?
Banks incur and manage these risks.
Non-risky: Deposits
Risky: Loans
Why do interest rate risks occur?
2
1) Maturity mismatch between deposits and loans.
2) Affects interest income to fluctuate.
HOW?
Loans increase interest income, deposits decrease interest income.
When does a matched gap occur?
- Maturities of the fixed-rate loan and fixed deposits are the same.
- No interest rate risk if interest rates rise or fall
When does a mismatch gap occur?
- When there is a difference in maturities.
- When interest rates increase or decrease, the net interest income will change respectively
*refer to notes for examples
What is a gap report?
3
1) It helps banks measure the interest rate risks
2) It includes assets and liabilities that are due for re-pricing/interest rate sensitive –> Those that are reaching their MATURITY DATE and rates will have to be repriced/changed
3) Does not factor in discount rates
What is a gap position?
Total Assets repricing - Total liabilities repricing
Assets: Interest Income (Inflow) - from loans given like fixed rate loans (Corporate, housing, vehicle) and floating rate loans (Corporate, housing)
Liabilities: Interest Expense (Outflow) - from interbank borrowings; savings account; fixed deposits (pay consumers their interests)
Which is better: Positive or negative gap position?
DEPENDS.
When interest rates increase:
Positive Gap position benefits, Negative Gap position suffers.
WHY?
1) In a positive gap (A>L), when i/r increases, inflow increases more than outflows –> BENEFITS
2) Assets are repriced more than Liabilities
When interest rates decrease: Negative Gap position benefits, positive gap position benefits.
WHY?
1) In a negative gap (L>A), when i/r increases, outflow increases more than inflow –> SUFFERS
2) Liabilities are repriced more than Assets
QN TO THINK: So does this mean matched gap position means no interest rate risk?
Does matched gap position mean no interest rate risk?
Ans: Depends. Matched gap position –> Static
- When i/r goes down, depositors will withdraw their funds.
- When i/r goes up, depositors likely to change to another company that accepts higher deposits (assuming they are able to break their fixed-deposit); most people will lose extra interest that they earn over the period if they do not change
- Need to account for basis risk (Definition is below)
- > Intensity & magnitude on the change of value when interest rates change
- Fixed deposits are not really that fixed
- > Pre-withdrawal & redeposit
- Loans are not that fixed
- > Pre-payment & refinance
What are the 2 shortcomings of a gap report?
1) Time value of money is not taken into account (Gap report is a static statement; no discounting –> Does not tell us how much risk we are currently bearing)
2) Does not tell us how much the bank’s interest margin or value will be affected by external forces
How to overcome the 2 shortcomings of a gap report?
Ans: Duration
What is “Duration”?
It is a time-weighted average of the time value of all cash flows (of the banks’ portfolio), or a cash-flow-weighted average of the time-to-maturity. (PROVIDES MORE INFORMATION ABOUT MATURITY)
Weighted by:
1) Timing
2) Magnitude
of the cash flow
- An estimation to tell the effective time taken to break even
How does the Duration equation look like?
- Refer to notes
- It reflects the (% change in price)/(% change in i/r)
- To compute the duration of both assets and liabilities, you cannot combine the cash flow and find the duration
- You have to compute separately the duration of assets and duration of liabilities respectively and subtract from each other
What does the length of the Duration tell you?
*All else constant* Longer: - More vulnerable the portfolio is to changes in i/r (MORE RISKY) - Penalizes later cash-flows more - Has more cash-flows later
Shorter:
- Has more cash-flows earlier
When portfolios with all cash flow at termination –> Duration = maturity
(only get back money at maturity/termination)
(similar to a 0-coupon bond where the face value is repaid at the time of maturity)
- Give us more information on the interim cash flows
What is Modified Duration?
1) It identifies how much the duration changes for each % change in the yield, while measuring how much a change in i/r impacts the price of a bond.
2) It can provide a risk measure to bond investors since it can measure/approximate how i/r affects the price of a bond
**IMPT: See how much price of bond change
What is the equation for modified duration?
Duration/(1 + i/r)
It assumes linear r/s of a bond –> Gives us the effective time taken for the bondholder to breakeven
Therefore, change in price = - ModD x change in i/r x Original price of bond/asset
What is a DURATION GAP?
It measures the sensitivity of a bank’s current year net worth when there is a change in i/r.
- Tell us how much the value of the bank will be affected is i/r change.
What is the equation for Duration Gap?
*Refer to notes
Net duration = duration of ASSETS - duration of LIABILITIES
How does an INCREASE in interest rates affect a positive and negative duration gap respectively?
1) Positive duration gap: Suffers
2) Negative duration gap: Benefits
How does a DECREASE in interest rates affect a positive and negative duration gap respectively?
1) Positive duration gap: Benefits
2) Negative duration gap: Suffers
Is positive or negative duration gap better?
Ans: Positive net duration
WHY?
- It resembles a bond
- When interest rates increase, price and valuations come down (i.e the positive duration gap suffers)
Does a zero gap/zero duration gap means no interest rate risk?
No.
Theory:
Banks with zero duration gap should not suffer or benefit(profit) when interest rates change.
Reality:
Nothing remains constant.
- Human beings may misbehave –> May choose to withdraw the deposit before time/pay up loan before the 20-yr maturity.
- Assets and liabilities misbehave as well –> While interest rates have been going up and down, assets and liabilities may not be affected due to… BASIS RISK