Revisions Flashcards
Crime - What?
No ontological reality
Look at the perpetrator
Look at the law
Look at the societal context
Crime Prism
The Crime Prism
- Harmfulness
- Extent of victimization
- Visibility
- Social response
- Social consensus
Moral Panic
- Initial Spark
- Suitable enemy
- Suitable victim
- Societal consensus
Additional characteristics:
- Concern
- Hostility
- Consensus
- Disproportion
- Volatility
Good? Brings a new light. Moral entrepreneurship is not restricted to an elite
Denial
- No story-telling
- No easy apprehension
- Lack of empirical data
- Need of something tangible (or imaginable)
Literal Denial - Does not believe the facts
Interpretative denial - Believes the facts but gives it a different interpretation
Implicatory denial - Believes the facts but gives it different consequences
Scapegoating
- Stereotypical group, defenceless
- Crisis period for society
- Against acts that offend social standards
- Stigmata - Devil v. Angel
- Target is subject to violence (social, physical, psychological, financial, legal…)
Criminal policy - Two kinds
Legal policies - As a reaction
Criminological policies - As prevention
Criminal policy - Other kinds of policies
Sociological - To help the criminal (or potential criminal) deal with his mental issues
Biological - To help the criminal via medication
Architectural/environmental - Limit the opportunities for crime by adapting the environment
Principle of Individual Autonomy
Each individual should be treated as responsible for his behavior
Factual - We are reasonable beings with free will
Normative - We have to be respected and treated as autonomous agents
Principle of Individual Autonomy - Duty to protect
The state has a duty to protect the freedoms or its citizens.
One’s freedoms should not be undermined unless it goes against someone else’s freedoms.
Harm Principle
Mill - The state may only criminalize behavior that causes harm to others or create an unreasonable risk.
What is harm? Individual harm and public wrongs
Public Wrongs
- Not individual - Do not focus on the victim but on population in general
- Sense of belonging, community
- To protect democracy over attacks against it
- Freedom is the result of self-control
Principle of Ultima Ration
Subsidiarity:
- Check both utilitarianism and retributivism
Principles of Criminalisation and Hate Speech - US
- Needs a public element
- Intent
- Imminence
- Likelihood
- ‘True Threat’ doctrine - Virginia case (burning cross)
- Intimidating speech must show clear intent
Principles of Criminalisation and Hate Speech - NL
- Is the utterance defamatory? Must address a group because of its characteristics, not just the group in itself
- Does the context nullify the defamatory character? Can also show it - Against ECHR
- Is the utterance nonetheless ‘unnecessarily offensive’?
Risk Society - What?
Our modern society can no longer control the risks it created.
No more distribution of goods but a focus on how to deal with the wrongs created by the system
Risk Society - Why?
The end of tradition - Individualisation and emancipation
The end of nature - Risks created by modernization
New risks - Invisible, irreversible, no social or geographical barrier
Culture of Control - What?
Social reform will reduce the frequency of crime
The state is responsible for the care of offenders and their punishment - So the state is also responsible for control
Penal Welfarism - What?
To take care of and protect citizens
To provide basic needs
To help people achieve their goals and their best
Penal welfarism - Shift
To preventive justice
From a social to an economical style of reasoning
3rd sector
Criminologies of control
Criminology of the other
Criminology of every day life
Against criminology of welfare
Culture of Control - Criticism
- Assumption that increasing risk is a valid excuse to restrict freedom
- Trades the freedoms of a minority against the security of a minority
- More power to the state = more risks of abuse
- Unclear definition of ‘security’
Terrorism - Definition
The deliberate creation and exploitation of fear through violence or the threat of violence in the pursuit of political change