Revision Flashcards
What are the “inward-looking” responsibilities of the board?
- Policy making
- Monitoring and supervising (e.g. budgets)
What are the “outward-looking” responsibilities of the board?
- Accountability to shareholders (through the use of financial and non-financial reporting)
- Strategic formulation
What is the shareholder theory?
The main purpose of a firm is to increase profitability, thus increasing shareholder value
Assumption that management are hired by shareholders to run the company of their benefit, and therefore are legally and morally obligated to serve their interests
What is the stakeholder theory?
That a company owes a responsibility to a wider group of people than just shareholders. The people affected by the actions of a business are its stakeholders.
Stakeholders include:
- Employees, customers, competitors, community etc.
Starbucks and Google UK Tax affairs
CSR
Although the measures adopted by the companies are legal, they are widely unethical because they utilise loopholes in the British tax system to pay less corporation tax in the UK
What is a dual (two-tier) board?
Two boards
- Executive board of management
- Supervisory board (employees are represented on this board)
In Germany, listed companies follow the two-tier board system
What are the benefits of a two-tier board system?
Allows employees to be more involved in decision making
The supervisory board is independent as one a maximum of two members of the executive board are allowed
What are the disadvantages of a two-tier board system?
Employee representation on the board can lead to employees holding back decisions that benefit the business as a whole, e.g. closing operations that are not profitable but means employees will lose their jobs
Also, the supervisory board may lack information to carry out its functions, they aren’t as knowledgeable about the firm as the executive board
What are the disadvantages of the stakeholder theory?
- Only really focuses on short-term strategy
- Encourages greater risk taking
- The collapse of corporate firms such as Enron, Worldcom came from continuous pressure on management to increase returns to shareholders leading them to manipulate the company accounts
- Seen as a historic way of doing business due to the disadvantages
What is a hybrid system of governance?
We use it in the UK
A combination of law (e.g. the Companies Act 2006) and regulation (e.g. The UK Corporate Governance Code 2014)
What are the advantages of a rule-based approach?
- All companies are required to meet the same minimum standard of corporate governance
- Companies do not have the choice of ignoring the rules
- Improved investors confidence in the stock market, since all companies are required to comply with recognised rules of governance
What are the disadvantages of a rule-based approach?
- Rules cannot keep up with developments and emerging initiatives
- Can result in a ‘box-ticking’ exercise, focusing on the letter and not the spirit of the rules
- The rule book can not cover everything, leaving gaps that could potentially be exploited
- Since each state has their own company law, federal laws may be harder to pass since they require certainty amongst all of the states
What are the advantages of a principle-based system?
- More flexible, allows for different circumstances
- The Code can be updated to respond to changing conditions and expectations of shareholders
- Allows companies to go beyond the minimum requirement
- Directors report on the actual circumstances of their own business, rather than one based on specific requirements, should be more meaningful and useful
What are the disadvantages of the principle-based system?
- The principles are so broad that they are of very little use as a guide
- May be difficult for the directors to see whether they have met the specific requirements of the code
- Not as easy to comply with as the rules-based, as they are ambiguous (can’t be evidenced)
- Tends to result in general, meaningless statements
Who provides a federal oversight of corporate firms in the USA?
The Securities Exchange Commission (SEC)
As each state has their own company law