Research methods Flashcards
What is a hypothesis?
A statement of what the researcher believes to be true
What does operationalisation mean?
Defined and measurable (categories of behaviour)
Whats the difference between directional and non-directional hypotheses?
(i) Directional = changes are greater/lesser, positive/negative.
(ii) Non-directional = doesn’t state a direction, just that there is a difference etc.
What are extraneous variables?
‘Nuisance’ variables that do not vary systematically with the IV
What are confounding variables?
Variables that change systematically vary with the IV; so we cannot be sure if any observed change in he DV is due to the CV or IV
What is a demand characteristic?
- Any cue from the researcher/research that may reveal the aim of the study.
What are investigator effects?
Any effect of the investigator’s behaviour on the outcome of the DV.
(i) What is randomisation?
(ii) What is standardisation?
(i) Use of chance when designing investigations to control for the effects of bias.
(ii) Using exactly the same formalised procedures for all participants in a research study.
What do researchers use to see if the IV does have an effect on the DV?
Control groups for comparison.
What are independent groups ?
One group does condition A, and a second group does condition B.
Give 2 advantages of independent group designs
1) No order effects
- only tested once
= can’t practice or become tired/bored.
2) Will not guess aim
- unlikely to guess research aims
= more natural behaviour?
Give 2 disadvantages of independent group designs
1) Participant variables
- participants in both groups are different (EV/CV?)
= less validity?
2) More participants
- need 2x as many as repeated measures
= expensive/time costs?
What is repeated measures design
Same participants take part in all conditions of an experiment.
Give 2 advantages of repeated measures design
1) Participant variables
- the person in both conditions has the same characteristics/
= controls CV
2) Fewer participants
- half of IG
= save time/money
Give 2 disadvantages of repeated measures design
1) Order effects
- participants may do better/worse when doing a similar task twice
= validity
2) Guessing of aims
- may change behaviour
= validity
What is matched pairs group design
Two groups of participants are used bu they are related to each other by being paired on participant variables that matter for the experiment
Give 2 advantages of matched pairs design
1) Participant variables
- matched on variables relevant to the experiment
= validity
2) No order effects
- only tested once so no practice/fatigue
= validity
Give 2 disadvantages of matched pairs design
1) Matching is not perfect
- time-consuming and can’t control all relevant variables
2) More participants
- 2x as may as RM
= time/cost expenses?
How do you define a lab experiment?
- An environment whereby EVs and CVs can be regulated.
- IV is manipulated and the effect on the DV is recorded.
Give 2 advantages of the lab experiment
1) EVs and CVs can be controlled
- effect of these on the DV can be minimised
= cause and effect between IV and DV demonstrated
= high internal validity
2) Replicable
- standardised procedure
= if results are same, increased validity.
Give 2 disadvantages of the lab experiment
1) May lack generalisability
- environment may be artificial
- participants aware they’re being studied
= low external validity
2) Demand characteristics
- cues in the environmental situation
= results explained by cues rather than effect of IV?
What is a field experiment?
A natural setting, IV is manipulated and the effect on the DV is recorded.
Give 2 advantages of the field experiment
1) More natural environment
- more comfortable in own environment
= generalisable?
2) Participants unaware they’re being studied
- behave normally
= greater external validity
Give 2 disadvantages of the field experiment
1) More difficult to control CVs
- observed changes in the DV down to CVs not IV?
= difficult to establish cause and effect
2) Ethical issues
- may not have given informed consent
= invasion of participant’s privacy
What is a natural experiment?
- Experimenter does not manipulate IV
- IV would have varied even without manipulation
- DV may be naturally occurring or measured by experimenter
Give 2 advantages of the natural experiment
1) Only ethical option?
- may be unethical to manipulate the IV e.g. studying the effects of institutionalisation on children
= only suited method?
2) Greater external validity
- involves real-life issues
= relevant to real experience
Give 2 disadvantages of the natural experiment
1) Natural event may only occur rarely
- natural events are ‘one-offs’ (reduced opportunity)
= limits ability to generalise findings
2) Participants not randomly allocated
- experimenter no control over which participants are placed in which conditions as IV is pre-existing
What is a quasi-experiment?
- IV based on a pre-existing difference between people, e.g. age/gender.
- DV may be naturally occurring or measured by experimenter.
Give 2 advantages of the quasi-experiment
1) Often high control
- controlled conditions
= increased confidence about drawing causal conclusions.
2) Comparisons can be made between people
- the IV is a difference between people e.g. people with and without autism
= comparisons can be made
Give 2 disadvantages of the quasi-experiment
1) Participants not randomly allocated
- no control over which participants are placed in which condition as IV pre-exisitng
= PVs causing the change in the DV?
2) Causal relationships not demonstrated
- does not manipulate/control the IV
= cannot say for certain any change in the DV was due to the IV
What is an opportunity sample?
People who are simply most available, e.g. asking the students in your class to take part.
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of an opportunity sample
(i) Quick method
- convenient as you make use of the people who are closest.
(ii) Inevitably biased
- unrepresentative of the target population as it is drawn from a very specific area
= generalised findings?
What is a random sample?
Everyone has an equal chance of being selected, e.g. pulling names out of a hat
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a random sample
(i) Unbiased
- no influence over who is selected
= no researcher bias
(ii) Representation not guaranteed
- still may produce people who are keen/curious etc
= generalising?
What is a volunteer sample?
Participants selecting themselves, e.g. placing an ad in a newspaper
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a volunteer sample
(i) Participants are willing
- selected themselves
= likely to engage more.
(ii) Likely to be a bised sample
- may share certain traits e.g. keen and curious
= generalising?
What is a systematic sample?
Participants selected using a set ‘pattern’ e.g. every Nth person is selected
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a systematic sample
(i) Unbiased
- first item usually selected at random
= objective
(ii) Time and effort
- complete list of population is required
= use random sampling?
What is a stratified sample?
- Participants selected according to their frequency in the target population, e.g. gender/age.
- Relative % of the subgroups are reflected in the sample.
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a stratified sample
(i) Representative method:
- characteristics of target population are represented
= generalisability?
(ii) Stratification is not perfect
- strata cannot reflect all the ways in which people are different
= representation not possible?
What is informed consent?
- Get permission to make a judgement about whether to take part (or not).
What is deception?
Misleading or withholding info so consent is not fully informed
How would a researcher overcome deception?
- Giving a debrief at the end of the study
What should a debrief include?
- True aims of the study
- Details not given during the study
- Use of data acquired (about participant)
- Right to withhold data.
How would protection from harm be overcome?
- Right to withdraw at any stage
- Reassured that their behaviour was typical/normal during debriefing
- Provide counselling if necessary
How would a researcher ensure privacy/confidentiality?
- If personal details are kept, they must be protected.
- Refer to participants using numbers, initials or false names.
- Personal data cannot be shared with other researchers.
What is a natural observation?
Taking place where the target behaviour would normally occur
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a natural observation
(i) High external validity
- spontaenous behaviour
= generalisable?
(ii) Low control
- uncontrolled EVs
= difficult to detect patterns
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a controlled observation
(i) Can be replicated
- standardised procedures
= findings can be checked.
(ii) May have low external validity
- behaviour a result of the manipulated situation?
What is a controlled observation?
Some control/manipulation of variables, including control of EVs
What is a covert observation?
Participants are unaware they are being studied
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a covert observation
(i) Demand characteristics reduced
- behaviour more natural
= increased validity
(ii) Ethically questionable
- may not want behaviour recorded
= affect privacy
What is an overt observation?
Participants are aware of being studied
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of an overt observation
(i) More ethically acceptable
- given consent
= right to withdraw if they wish
(ii) Demand characteristics
- knowledge of being studied influences behaviour
= reduced validity
What is a participant observation?
When the researcher becomes part of the group they are studying
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a participant observation
(i) Greater insight
- researcher experiences situation as the participants do
= enhanced validity
(ii) Possible loss of objectivity
- researcher may identify too strongly with those they are studying
What is a non-participant observation?
When the researcher remains separate from the group they are studying
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a non-participant observation
(i) More objective
- maintains objective distance so less chance of bias
= increases validity
(ii) Loss of insight
- too far removed from those they are studying.
In terms of observation, what are behavioural categories?
Target behaviours to be observed should be broken up in to a set of observable categories = operationalised
Give 2 (possible) disadvantages of behavioural categories
1) Difficult to make clear and unambiguous
- should be self-evident and not overlap, e.g. grinning and smiling.
2) Dustbin categories
- all forms of behaviour should be in the list
In terms of observation, what is time sampling?
Observations made at regular intervals, e.g. once every 15 seconds.
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a time sampling in observation
(i) Reduce number of observations
- recorded at certain intervals than everything that is seen
= more systematic, structured
(ii) May be unrepresentative
- may miss out on important details outside of interval
In terms of observation, what is event sampling?
A target behaviour/event is recorded every time it occurs
Give;
(i) 1 advantage
(ii) 1 disadvantage
…. of a event sampling in observation
(i) May record infrequent behaviour
- pick up behaviours that do not occur at regular intervals
(ii) Complex behaviour oversimplifeid
- important details may go unrecorded
= affect validity
Give 2 advantages of questionnaires?
1) Can be widely distributed
- large amounts of data quickly, researcher doesn’t need to be present
= cost-effective
2) Respondents maybe be willing to open up
- less self-conscious
= less chance of social desirability bias than an interview