Republican Dominance and Opponents 1981-92 Flashcards
Reagan’s economic policy - family income
1981 persuaded Congress to pass most budget requests
Reduced the budget of 212 fed programmes - food stamps, student loans and child nutrition programmes
Reduced the level and range of benefits for ‘safety net’ programmes- Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC). 13 million children living below the poverty line in 1984 with many being offspring to single mothers who depend heavily on AFDC and majority being black
Tax rises by Reagan called ‘revenue enhancement’ hit the less wealthy hardest - The average income of the poorest decreased by $1,300 per annum. The number of homeless people increased from 200,000 to 400,000
Recovery by 1987 but only to 1973 levels
Only ½ of families maintained their standards of living in the 1980s usually due to both parents working
Reagan’s economic policy - employment rights
Opposed minimum wage- obstructed congressional attempts to increase it
Hostile to unions- 1981, 12,000 air-traffic controllers went on strike for higher wages ignoring the no striking action for fed employees in their contract, fired them all calling in the military to do their job. Liberals and Labour leaders horrified
Whereas Conservatives were impressed especially when striking action plummeted as major companies followed suit
Appointed over 400 conservatives to the judiciary- late 80s rulings made it difficult for women, minorities, elderly and disabled when suing over discrimination
Reagan’s economic policy - deregulation
Cut the staff of regulatory agencies by 25% on average - failed to differentiate between stifling economic regulations and ones that protected the environment/health and safety
50% fall in prosecution for illegal disposal of hazardous waste- adverse impact on the environment
Ensured bodies like Occupational Safety and Health Administration made decisions in favour of business and against labour- decreased protection against accidents and unhealthy working conditions
Number of personnel in the Consumer Product Safety Commission was cut by 38%- less active in ensuring the product customers purchased were safe
Reagan’s economic policy - congressional and public resistance
Later budgets were substantially rewritten and Congress was not cooperative with his many attempts to reduce the size of fed gov
Vetoed the renewal of the $18 billion Clean Water Act- overrode his veto of the virtually identical in 1987 Water Quality Control Act
Social security, Medicare and veterans benefits were the most valued policies so left them basically intact along with school lunches and Head Start (free breakfast for poor kids)
The Department of Agriculture’s - save money by having ketchup and pickle relish substitute part of the vegetable portion in fed-subbed school lunches was publicly ridiculed then dropped
Reagan’s economic policy - economic successes
The tax reform bill of 1986 simplified the tax code:
Increased taxes on corporations and capital gains
Lowered the top rate of taxation from 50% to 28%
Raised the bottom rate of taxation form 11% to 15%
US experienced its longest- ever period of economic growth in peacetime:
1980-1988 inflation fell from 13.5-4.7%
Unemployment fell from 7-5.2%
16 million new jobs were created
External factors e.g. fall in oil prices due to finding new oil sources
Defence expenditure and tax cuts led to a budget deficit which would cause problems for future Americans and their families
Reagan’s economic policy - growth of trade deficit
Mid-1980’s American went from the world’s largest creator to the world’s largest debtor nation
Owned to changing consumer spending- rocketed because of the rise of new discount stores e.g. Walmart as they boasted they were the friend of the consumer (low-cost, good quality goods and widely available)
Cheap goods were mainly made in low-wage foreign factories contributing to the loss of manufacturing jobs in the US and the trade deficit
Deficit rose from $38 billion 1982 to over $150 billion per annum by the second half of the decade
On average every week of Reagan-Bush years (1981-92) American consumers spent $2 billion more on imported goods than foreigners on American goods
Reagan’s economic policy - government action
Reagan administration persuaded Japanese manufacturers to voluntarily limit their exports to the US in 1981
Japan responded by opening manufacturing plants in the US giving employment to thousands of Americans
The gov imposed at 25% tariff on imported trucks and 3% tariff on imported cars
The trade deficit still continued to grow
The annual trade deficit with Japan passed over the $50 billion mark in 1985
Late 80s and early 90s many Americans were accusing Japan of launching an economic offensive against the USA
The significance of Bush raising taxes
Elected because of his ‘no more new taxes’ promise but pledged a decrease in the $2.7 trillion deficit upon which $200 billion interest was being paid annually
Agreed with Congress in Nov 1990 that taxes must rise
Signalled his belief that the fed gov had spent beyond its means- did nothing to help workers worried about family income
Demonstrated the difficulties facing a democratic nation living beyond its means- politicians in a search of votes made promises they couldn’t keep
Infuriated conservative Republicans who dominated the 1992 Republican Convention and weakened Bush’s bid for re-election
Tax rise caused many voters to reject Bush - poor campaigner who appeared helpless and uninterested in the face of recssion, lost to the charismatic Bill Clinton in the 1992 election, workers felt Clinton could ‘feel their pain’, nation seemed to be swinging back to the left electing a Democratic president and Congress
Religious Rights promotion of traditional values
Through organisation, the media and politicians emerging as a political force in the 1970s and 1980s
Preached against change instead they should follow the Bible
Baptist minister Jerry Falwell established the “Moral Majority” in 1978 as ‘pro-life, pro-family, pro-morality and pro-American
in 1980 he helped raised millions for Reagan’s campaign and estimated his ‘Moral Majority’ registered about a million voters – disbanded in 1989
Christian Coalition (1989) – 1992 had 150,000 people – claimed to control the Republican Party in southern states
Reagan failed the Religious Right
During his campaign in 1980, he emphasised his disgust at 60s excesses and permissiveness opposing feminism and the Equal Rights Amendment.
Wanted constitutional amendments to ban abortion and restore prayer in public schools (banned by SCOTUS in 1962), but could not get the necessary 2/3 majority in Congress. The Religious Right felt he didn’t try very hard on these issues and grew disappointed with him during his presidency.
He failed to endorse the Family Protection Act 1981-1982 which would prohibit abortion, restore school prayer, tax breaks for wives and mothers who stayed home, denial of teenage contraception unless parents were notified. Congress did not pass it
Reagan helped the Religious Right
Had a highly successful judicial strategy which helped him pursue victory for social conservatism.
Successful nomination of nearly 400 conservative judges ‘Reaganised’ the judiciary, and helped compensate for his failure to win congressional approval for his conservative social agenda.
By the end of his presidency, he had appointed over 50% of the federal judiciary. The election of George H.W. Bush as his successor ensured that 3/4 of federal judges were conservative through Reagan or Bush appointees by 1992.
Religious Rights campaign against abortion
Methods
It used emotive mailings and slogans and used ‘reformed’ sinners to advertise its causes - former feminists were encouraged show how they had renounced feminism.
Support of Republican politicians who sought their votes. Even moderate Republicans felt they had to oppose abortion. George H.W. Bush was pro-choice like his wife, but changed to please the RR and said in a 1988 campaign that ‘abortion is murder’.
Appropriated civil rights movement tactics, including ‘rights’ language that emphasised the rights of the unborn child (vs the rights of the mother), and Operation Rescue’s sit-ins
Federal government disappointed the RR
Following Justice Brennan’s retirement from the Supreme Court in 1990, RR hoped Bush would nominate a known pro- lifer, but he nominated David Souter, whose views on abortion were unknown.
1981 – Reagan appointed Sandra Day O’Connor to the Supreme Court, upsetting the RR because of her sympathy for women needing abortions.
On the other hand, the Religious Right was sometimes encouraged by federal government actions. For example:
Federal gov pleased the RR
Reagan persuaded Congress to fund ‘chastity clinics’ where women were encouraged to avoid sex.
Reagan’s judicial appointments meant several Supreme Court rulings that hindered abortions – Webster v. Reproductive Services of Missouri (1989) - ruled Missouri could deny women access to public abortion facilities - hoped others would follow but only 3 states did
Religious Rights campaign against homosexuality
Leading campaigners against homosexuality were:
Televangelist Pat Robertson – 1966 – The 700 Club, a Christian news and television programme that is still running – promoted traditional values, like writing to donors that the ‘socialist’ feminist agenda encouraged ‘women to leave their husbands, kill [abort] their children, destroy capitalism and become lesbians’.
1988 – he declared himself a Republican presidential candidate but lost to George H.W. Bush – did not help his cause by publicly praying for God to divert a hurricane from Virginia to New York (New York had more voters than Virginia).
1989 – established the Christian Coalition, which lobbied against gay rights and abortion, and was pro-school prayer
Concerned Women for America
Pat Buchanan – 1992 – George H.W. Bush won the Republican presidential nomination but allowed defeated Republican rival Pat Buchanan to deliver the opening speech at the National Convention. Buchanan said that the Democrat presidential candidate Bill Clinton and his vice-presidential candidate Al Gore constituted the ‘most pro-gay and pro-lesbian ticket in history’
Jerry Falwell and his Moral Majority and televangelist Jim Bakker and his PTL (‘Praise the Lord’) Club (in 1988, Bakker was indicted and convicted for large-scale fraud and conspiracy).
The Impact of the AIDS Crisis
Impacted the lives of homosexuals, drug users and haemophiliacs which impacted their public perception
HIV was discovered in 1984 but there was no treatment making it a death sentence and you were ostracised
Most young gay men with 5,500 died by 1985 and 46,000 in 1989
1989 there were over 80,000 confirmed but a possible 10x more
It was associated with immorality fuelling anti-gay sentiment - led many to stay in the closet meaning many said they did not know a gay man
1987 - created ACTUP (Aids coalition to unleash power) followed by the 1st Pride Parade in New York which demanded more research and equal rights
Reagan and Aids
After his friend died from AIDS in 1985 Reagan asked Surgeon General Koop for a report on the problem which suggest 3 remedies and called for sex ed even in elementary.
However, Reagan refused to advocate for the use of condoms or speak to Congress to get help to fund an investigation into curing the disease.
His inaction had the support of conservatives who opposed the promotion of condoms and sex ed.
Social conservatism meant HIV infection in the US was far higher than Western Europe which had advocating about needle exchanges and sex ed
Ryan White Care Act
1990
Improved federal government assitance to those suffering of Aids
Ryan had contracted it through a blood transfusion as he is a haemophiliac
He was highly articulate and was able to change some of the public perception of Aids
After his death, Congress passed the act which granted $220,00 million to help the victims of the ‘gay plague’
The growing problems with drugs
In 1985, under 1% of Americans surveyed counted illicit drugs as a major national problem. The main concerns were economic and foreign policy issues. However, by 1989, over 50% of those surveyed said that drug use was the gravest threat to national security.
Reasons for this change:
1 - the inexpensive cocaine derivative ‘crack’ became widely available. Even poor ghetto inhabitants could afford crack which was a temporary escape or social mobility for black and Hispanic Americans who could make fortunes selling it.
2 - media coverage of drug use increased. Stories of addicts staging robberies to finance their addiction and newborn babies in agony from withdrawal - frightening yet compelling reading.
3 - the Cold War was winding down in the mid-to late-80s and some contemporaries felt that the drug war was replacing the Cold War as the major national security issue in the minds of Americans.
4 - the President and First Lady placed a great deal of emphasis on the drug problem
Nancy Regan’s ‘Just Say No campaign’
Anti-drug campaign obtained a great deal of media coverage from visiting nurseries that treated ‘crack babies’ telling the media what they saw as heartbreaking condmeing it as immoral and criminal
The best cure was the promoting religion, strict enforcement of anti-drug laws and harsh school discipline
1986 Reagan order federal workplaces to be ‘drug free’ and called for routine urine tests on workers in ‘sensitive’ jobs e.g. public health and national security
1988 the Drug-Free Workplace Act was passed - unis and contractors receiving fed gov money had to maintain this
Rather than money going towards those stuck in poverty (often the underlying reason for drug use), $10 billion per annum was spent on law enforcement and imprisonment
750,000 were charged yearly mainly for using marijuana
Meant people risked losing their jobs if they were an addict and had a positive urine test for
Ultimately both Reagan and Bush were unsuccessful as there was no change on the availability or price of drugs - futile
Robert Bork
Reagan’s nomination for SCOTUS saw most Republicans approve but Democrats loathed him
Bork attacked some liberal SCOTUS decisions, defended a Connecticut law that would have denied contraceptives to married couples, opposed abortion, claimed women’s rights were not included in the 14th Amendment, criticised racial equality
Black organisations (NAACP) and women’s organisations (NOW) worked hard to stir up vociferous popular opposition and engaged in exceptionally aggressive lobbying of Senators, which contributed greatly to the rejection
Growth of inter-party division in the Republican Party
Despite Bush winning the election the conservative Republican attacks contributed to his defeat in 1992 like Pat Buchanan as he vewed Bush as an insincere conservative
1992 campaign rival Buchanan attacked him saying he’d start a ‘culture war’ against liberal influence in gov, education, churches and Holywood
Buchanan had considerable support after members were disillusioned with Bush’s tax hike and lack of enthusiasm for the Religious Right social agenda-
Bush wouldn’t mind a gay cabinet member
Growth of inter-party division in the Democrat Party
Less bitter than the Republican party
Old-style still desired the Great Society policy but recognised that more centrists were more electable
New Democrats e.g. Bill Clinton advocated a balanced fed gov budget and decreased fed gov intervention
Clinton said the era of big gov was over and wanted to end welfare as we know it- ‘cease to be a way of life’