Representation Flashcards
What are the differences between Delegate and Trustee Models of Representation?
Delegate: Members of Congress should accurately represent the views of their constituents
Trustee: Members of Congress should use their own judgement (rather than the voter’s judgement) about what it is in the best interests of the entire nation. “Trust me in this decision”
What is Mr. Page’s and Virginia Assembly defense of delegate “instructions”?
Because the U.S. Government is democratic, the people’s will should be appropriately reflected in its representatives. The people have a right to seek solutions that benefit the common good as a whole, but that can’t be accomplished if they don’t have the power to instruct their representatives.
What is Burke’s argument for the Trustee model?
Burke believes the representative must have a will subservient to that of the people. If he is submitting in character, then it is difficult to object to the system in that regard.
What is Kennedy’s arguments for Trustee model?
Senators, as trustees, are meant to use their best judgment and act in the long-term interests of the nation, even if it means going against the immediate desires of their constituents.
What are Koopman’s arguments?
Koopman argues we are too focused on the person and the issues, rather than the character. America has been focusing too much on the similarities that make an individual a good spokesperson for the country. We no longer observe the virtuous and locally grounded citizens to serve us, when virtue is key to a position of servitude.
What does Brutus say concerning the delegate model?
Brutus strongly supports the delegate model of representation, where representatives act directly on behalf of the will of the people, to avoid abuse of power.
