Remedies Flashcards
What is anticipatory repudiation?
A party to the K clearly and unequivocally states that they will not perform on the K before performance is due.
What can the non breaching party do when the breaching party repudiates?
- treat the repudiation as a breach and sue immediately for damages. BUT, if the non breaching party already fully performed and simply waiting on payment, they cannot sue early.
- ignore the repudiation, demand performance, and see what happens
Can a party retract its repudiation?
Yes, provided the other party has not commenced a lawsuit or acted in reliance on the repudiation (by materially changing its position).
UCC Anticipatory Repudiation
When there are reasonable grounds for insecurity about the other side’s performance, you can demand adequate assurance. If the other party fails to respond within a reasonably time, treat this as a repudiation.
Money Damages
What is the goal of expectation damages and how are they measured?
the goal is to put a party in the same economic position it would be in if the contract has been performed as promised
they are measured by comparing the value of the performance w/o the breach to the value w/ the breach
Expectations damages
Mickey contracts with Pabst to buy a keg of beer for $100. Mickey repudiates the contract, and Pabst sells the keg to a liquor store for $80. What are Pabst’s expectation damages?
$20
Expectations damages
Same facts but no one else wants to buy this beer and Pabst cannot resell the keg at any price. What are Pabst’s expectation damages?
$100
Mickey contracts with Pabst to buy a keg of beer for $100. Mickey gets the keg but breaches the contract by refusing to pay. The current price for a keg of Pabst has risen to $110. What are Pabst’s expectation damages?
$100
Mickey contracts with Pabst to buy a keg of beer for $100. Pabst fails to deliver the keg, and Mickey has to buy her keg from Blatz for $120. What are Mickey’s expectation damages?
When Pabst refuses to deliver, can Mickey buy a keg of Utopia Beer for $25,000 and sue Pabst for $24,900?
- $20
- No, cover must be similar
Mickey contracts with Pabst to buy a keg of beer for $100 (paid up front). When Pabst delivers the keg, it is only half-full but Mickey is desperate to have her beer and keeps the half keg. It can be shown that a half keg of Pabst costs $60 at the corner liquor store. What are Mickey’s expectation damages?
Can Mickey send the keg back instead?
- $60
- Yes
Limitations on Expectation Damages
Must be proven with…
reasonable certaintly
Common fact patterns involve brand new or unproven business ventures which have difficulty proving what their lost profits would be.
Limitations on Expectation Damages
Are unforceable consequential damages recoverable?
Not recoverable unless the breaching party had some reason to know about these damages.
Limitations on Expectation Damages
Differentiate the two categories of damages
General damages – damages are the types of losses almost anyone
would suffer if there was a breach. Includes incidental damages , such as the cost of storing rejected goods, finding a new buyer, or finding a replacement vendor.
Consequential Damages – losses that are unique or special to this plaintiff.
Limitations on Expectation Damages
Consequential damages can be limited or excluded entirely unless this would be…
unconscionable
Limitations on Expectation Damages
What limitation on consequential damages is prima facie unconscionable? What isn’t?
Limitation of consequential damages for injury to the person in the case of consumer goods is prima facie unconscionable but limitation of damages where the loss is commercial is not.