Remedies Flashcards
What types of monetary damages are available at common law
At common law, aggrieved party can choose among the types of damages:
1. expectation damages
2. reliance damages
3. restitution damages
4. liquidated damages (if available)
What are expectation damages?
Aggrieved party is entitled to the amount that will restore them to the position they would have been in had the contract been fully performed
How are expectation damages calculated
(loss of value of breaching party’s performance) + (incidental and consequential costs generated by breach) - (payments already received) - (any costs saved as result of breach) = [expectation damages]
When may aggrieved party not be able to recover the full expectation of the contract?
- cost of performance greatly exceeds market value of performance
- damages cannot be calculated with reasonable certainty
- damages are unforseeable
- damages could have been mitigated
What are reliance damages
Damages that restore aggrieved party to the position they were in before the contract
How are reliance damages calculated?
(money spent in preparation for performance or in actual performance) - (loss breaching party can prove aggrieved party would have suffered if contract was fully performed) = [reliance damages]
When are reliance damages available?
When expectation damages are too uncertain
What are restitution damages?
Value of benefits conferred upon the other party in a transaction. May be available even when the other party has not breached
How are restitution damages calculated?
Calculation of damages based on court’s discretion and as justice requires by either:
1. reasonable vlue or cost of the benefits conferred
2. extent to which the other party’s property has increased in value because of the performance rendered
When are restitution damages available?
Available if aggrieved party has partially but not fully performed
What are liquidated damages
Liquidated damages are provisions in contract that provide damages of the parties’ own choosing in the event of a breach
When are liquidated damages provisions enforcable?
Enforceable if the provisions are designed to compensate for a breach
When are liquidated damages provisions unenforcable?
Unenforcable if provisions are mainly a penalty designed to punish breach
What is test for determining enforceability of liquidated damages provisions?
- Did parties intend for clause to be a liquidated damages provision or a penalty?
- Was the clause reasonable at the time of contracting in relation to the anticipated harm?
- Is the clause reasonable in relation to the harm/loss that actually occurred
What is remedy if court finds liquidated damages provision to be a penalty?
Court will strike the provision from the contract and issue damages in accordance with default rules
What is seller’s remedy under UCC if goods were delivered to and accepted by the buyer?
Contract price
What is seller’s remedy under UCC if goods were not delivered or accepted because the buyer wrongfully rejected or repudiated goods?
- If seller has re-sold goods: damages are differences between contract price and resale price
- If seller hasn’t resold: damages are difference between contract price and market price
What are lost volume sellers
Sellers under UCC for whom supply of goods exceeds the demand
How are damages calculated for lost volume sellers?
Lost volume sellers may recover the profit they would have otherwise made on the lost sale
What must lost volume sellers demonstrate in order to recover lost profit?
- that the seller could have sold to both the breaching buyer and resale buyer
- that it would have been profitable to make both sales
- that seller probably would have made the additional sale regardless of buyer’s breach