Religious Language Flashcards
Cited in Richardson and Bowmen, how does Burrell define analogies
“Proportional similarities which also acknowledge dissimilar features”
What does Aquinas say about univocal language
“No name belong to God in the same sense that it belongs to creatures”
What does Aquinas say about equivocal language
“Neither, on the other hand, are names applied to God and creatures in a purely equivocal sense…if that were so it follows that from creatures nothing could be known or demonstrated about God”
Aquinas book
Summa theologica
Univocal language
Means same
Equivocal language
Different
What does Hume say about univocal language
“We justly ascribe to him because those words are honourable among men and we have no other language by which we can express our adoration of him”
What phrase does Aquinas use to sow that what we say and know about God is limited
Via eminentia
Analogy of attribution is
The idea that the qualities we ascribe to one another reflect the qualities of God. It draws a causal relation between the two things being described
Brian Davies example of analogy of attribution
Bakery. To say the bread is good is to say the baker is good as the bread is the product of the baker
What does Aquinas think “God is living” means
God is the cause of life
Analogy of proportion is
The idea that the attributes of a being are unique and dependant on the type of being that possesses said attributes
What is the example used by John Hick that was originally used Baron Von Hugel
Faithfulness.
Dogs faithfulness is limited to humans
Humans faithfulness is limited to Gods
Ian Ramsey’s book
Religious language
Ian Ramsey’s model and qualifiers idea
Take a human attribute (model) and qualify it (with adjectives like perfectly) to make it clear that it is infinitely enhanced when applied to God
Weaknesses of analogy
William Blackstone: Thomson doctrine is unhelpful because we have to translate the analogies into univocal language before we can know anything - need to know how Gods love relates to humans love before we gain knowledge
St Paul: need to ‘see’ God before we can accurately express God
Still assumes similarities between humans and God but God transcends us
Duns Scotus: too vague and leaves us unable to understand God and his actions
By using analogy we lose the meaning and purpose behind what we are trying to communicate
Strengths of analogy
Evans: says nothing wrong with accepting the fact god is mysterious and that our knowledge of him is limited as long as we know enough to worship
Stops anthropomorphism
Hick: analogy enables us to make some statements about God yet we still preserve the mystery present in Judeao-Christian theology
How does Burrows describe myth
“A symbolic approximate expression of the truth”
What is the purpose of myths
To convey concepts that go beyond the basic true-false descriptors to express that which is other worldly. They allow humans to gain and insight into cosmological and existential questions that are difficult to express in cognitive terms
Myth is bible
Creation
What does mythological language describe
Apocalyptic events and eschatological expectations in the Bible
Quote for the second coming of Jesus
“With the sound of the trumpet of God…men, both alive and dead, will rise to meet the Lord in air”
Paul
Thessalonians 4:16
What does Braithwaite believe about religious stories
Are inspirational and give us the motivation to lead a moral life
What did Bultmann believe
Demythologising the bible made it meaningful. He believed we needed to access the kerygma which is done by demythologising the New Testament to reveal its truths
Bultmann quote about demythologising
“It is impossible…to avail ourselves of modern…surgical discoveries and, at the same time, to believe in the New Testament world of demons and spirits”
Once demythologised what does the story of Jesus walking on water tell mean
Helping them through difficult times
Is symbolic language non cognitive
Yes
How does Erika Dinker Von Schubert define symbol
“A pattern or object that points to an invisible metaphysical reality and participates in it”
How does Tillich define symbols
Something that “Participates in that to which it points”
Example of symbol used by Tillich
National flag
Conveys nationalism and patriotism
Shows symbols express what the believer feels about the symbol
What does Tillich believe signs do
Provide information
What does Rowan Williams say about religious language
“Like all other serious human discourse, religious language requires a symbolic foundation”