Religion Flashcards
Durkheim
Religions divided world into sacred and profane
Religion makes use totems, Australian aborigines, all beliefs form a collective conscience
Malinowski
Trobiand Islands, religion reinforced norms and values
He found: religious aspects appear in fishing, when they are fishing in local rivers that are safe and reliable there is no need for religious rituals —> if they are fishing at sea which is less reliable and dangerous they use rituals to protect them and provide them with comfort/ensure a good catch
Parsons
Religion provides moral guidelines, helps maintain social stability, provides comfort in times of stress, prevents social anomie, acts as a conservative force
Bellah
Civil religion, used to create solidarity, generates large scale loyalty, may/may not involve religious beliefs, e.g. Americanism
Marx
“Religion is the opium of the people” - dulls the pain of oppression
Religion benefits the bourgeoisie in 5 ways:
1) promises compensation for our suffering in the form of an afterlife
2) justifies a hierarchy (divine right)
3) acts as a conservative force
4) produces a false class conscience which prevents true class conscience
5) keeps workers sober and willing to work (BUDD - Clarks Shoe Factory)
Critiques of Marxist
Ignores secularisation, divine right is no longer used as justification for positions of power, religion can cause social change
Neo Marxist Approach (Liberation Theology)
—>
Maduro
Religion can create social change and freedom for the oppressed
Father Torres: South America - 1960s - Christian Revolution
Martin Luther King: USA - 1960s - civil rights movement
Desmond Tutu - South Africa - 1960s - helped abolish apartheid
Gramsci
Proletariat need to scrap existing region and replace it with another faith that encourages equality and changes the hegemony
Weberian Approach (Social Action Theory)
Protestant work ethic, religion provides a ‘universe of meaning’, helps to understand the motive of behaviour to gain verstehen, Protestantism encouraged social change towards capitalism, many countries could’ve became capitalist but lacked the right religion, Calvinist’s believed that some souplike were the ‘elect’ who were destined for Heaven (doctrine of predestination), behaviour didn’t affect whether you were the ‘elect’ but a clue of this was wealth, people began living frugal/ascetic lifestyles due to salvation anxiety, reinvested profit from their businesses back into business as pleasurable things were seen as evil, amassed great wealth to convince themselves they were the ‘elect’
Critiques of Weber
—>
Sombart
Calvinism is anti-profit, so shouldn’t have created capitalism BUT Weber says profit was only made by accident
Tawney
Ignores other faiths that contributes to Capitalism such as Judaism
Marshall
Ignores countries that were heavily Calvinist but capitalism didn’t exist like SCOTLAND
Kautsky
FLIP: Calvinism is an ISA to Capitalism
Christian New Right Approach
-rise in evangelical Protestantism in USA
-attempt to reunite Christianity with politics
-attempt to increase public support via ‘televangelsim’
Popular in Bible Belt
-Favour traditional values
Bruce
CNR defends interests of the bourgeoisie; George Bush supported right wing Christian views such as cutting funds for stem cell research
Roof and McKinney
Conservative forms of Protestantism on the rise, combines commitment to religion and refusal to compromise belief
CNR
CNR own/control many TV channels, schools and bookshops
Promise keepers: traditional values, only straight men can join
Religion used to prevent anomie and uphold morality
Critiques of the CNR
CNR have had limited impact
Haven’t won many elections or passed any laws
Public opinion polls show a decline in support
Feminism and Religion
—>
7 ways Judaism is Patriarchal
1) women are seen as adams helpmate
2) women confined to balcony in holy buildings
3) no female rabbis
4) Can’t read the Torah
5) men pray and thank god for not being female
6) no rituals for women
7) women can’t wear skull caps
How are feminists resisting patriarchal Judaism?
They are creating their own Jewish rituals that celebrate female bodily functions (menstruation) thus changing the hegemony
The rituals are informal (dancing and music)
Feminists
Religion is a form of patriarchy
Throughout history, women have been excluded from religious hierarchy —>
Female Vicars only accepted in CofE since 1992
Holm
Women are exploited by religion, Buddhism:
Monks are more superior to nuns
Orthodox Judaism: women are excluded from services
Islam: women cannot enter places of worship
Hinduism: only men can become Brahmin priests
Women are oppressed due to sexuality/biology, menstruation is seen as a polluting element
—>
Simone De Beauvoir
religion acts as compensation for suffering faced in current life, helps maintain inequality, women vital for religion to continue ‘social control’, women socialise children and organise rituals
Saadawi
Egyptian feminist, imprisoned for beliefs, forced to undergo female circumcision, Arab women often sexually abused by male family members
Argues religion only became patriarchal when men misinterpreted religion, in Old Testament Eve has the gift of knowledge.
Holm
Women are resisting patriarchal religious traditions, Islamic women can keep their family name in marriage, reformed Judaism allows female rabbis, Quakerism doesn’t oppress women
Watson
Veiling is usually seen as social control, Muslim women see it as a way of avoiding male oppression, when looking at religion we shouldn’t be ethnocentric
Reasons why women are more religious:
—>
Miller and Hoffman
Women are socialised to be more passive, obedient and caring, qualities that are valued by religion. Women more likely to work part-time or be full-time carers, meaning they have more time to participate in religion
Greeley
Taking care of family members increases religiosity
Davie
women are closer to birth and death, so question the meaning of life more
Glock and Stark and Stark and Bainbridge
Organismic deprivation—women more likely to be of ill health and seek healing through religion. Ethical deprivation—women are more morally conservative so regard the world as being in moral decline, sharing the views of religion.
Social deprivation—women more likely to be poor, religion attracts poor groups.
New Religious Movements (NRMs)
Big rise in NRMs over past 30 years
Suggests that religion isn’t declining, simply changing
Challenges the secularisation thesis