Relationship between the branches Flashcards
what act led to the creation of the Supreme Court in the uk
the constitutional reform act 2005
how many justices sit on the Supreme Court
12
identify three functions of the Supreme Court
- review government legislation
- to check whether the legislation complies with the HRA
- to determine if public officials have acted ultra vires
what is meant by the term judicial neutrality
that judges don’t allow their decisions to be biased by personal opinion
identify three ways in which judicial neutrality is maintained
- legal training
- peer review and appeal
- writing a reason for verdict
what is meant by the term judicial independence
free from the political influence and pressures and the courts being separated from the executive and parliament
identify three ways in which judicial independence is maintained
- independent appointments commission
- independent pay review
- security of tenure ( constitutional guarantee that a political office holder can’t be removed from office, except in exceptional circumstances )
what is meant by the term judicial review
judges reviewing the law
what is meant by the term ‘ultra vires’
acting beyond the law
identify an example of the supreme court ruling that each of these bodies has acted ultra vires
- parliament
- executive
- a devolved institution
- a case on the power to cut legal aid budget in 2016
- the executive didn’t have the power to trigger article 50 (treaty on EU) in 2017
- scottish and welsh executives didn’t have the right to be consulted over Brexit
explain one way in which judicial review is an effective check on the government
can be effective when it is used to rule a member of the executive as acting ultra vires
explain one way in which judicial review is not an effective check on the government
the human rights act can be ineffective because it has no power to force parliament to repeal/ amend legislation due to parliamentary sovereignty
explain how the HRA 1998 helps the Supreme Court hold parliament to account
as it has brought the European convention on human rights into uk law this can make rulings on clearly defined laws
explain one limitation of the HRA 1998 in helping the Supreme Court hold parliament to account
this is only statue law and therefore parliament can amend and repeal it as it is not entrenched within the uk constitution
explain one way in which judicial independence has been threatened in recent years
it was threatened when the media accused high court judges of being traitors over brexit
explain one way in which judicial neutrality has been undermined in the twenty first century
as the continuous appointments of ‘pale, male and stale’ oxbridge graduates provides a narrow social outlook which can impact neutrality
identify three ways in which parliament can act as a check on the executive
- select committees
- ministerial questions - PMQs
- voting against and repealing legislation
give three examples of parliament acting as a check on the executive
- home affairs committee over windrush scandal - amber Rudd
- MP’s challenging Hancock over covid19 measures
- mays brexit proposal defeat in the House of Lords
identify three ways in which the executive can control parliament
- majority and party whips can force legislation through parliament
- they can refuse to act in select committees
- they can ensure that the composition of legislative committees is favourable
give three examples of the executive controlling parliament
- 2018 the government ignored 22/25 select committees regarding to expansion of Heathrow airport
- Johnson forced through a tax increase for social care in 2021 “Heath and Social Care Levy Act 2021”
- Johnson proroguing parliament before Brexit to make a ‘no deal’
give three factors that effect the balance of power between the executive and parliament
- the size of the majority of government
- the unity of the governing party
- the amount of public support for the government
explain how voting on legislation enables parliament to check the executive
by voting for or against legislation, parliament can force the executive to act in a particular way or force a change in policy by refusing to support proposed legislation
explain how select committees enable parliament to check the executive
as they examine evidence, which can hold the executive accountable for their actions and take responsibility for issues that may emerge
explain how ministerial questions enable parliament to check the executive
they require a response, forcing ministers to answer and give accurate reports to the house of commons which shines public light on their actions