Relationship between crime and mental illness Flashcards
Rate of violence among people with mental illness than the general population
4-6x higher among people with mental illness
Factors which are higher risk factors for violence than mental illness
Personality disorder
Drug misuse
Alcohol misuse
Male sex
Age between 15-30
Socioeconomic deprivation
Past history of violence
Percentage of patients with schizophrenia violent in the 20 weeks following discharge from a psychiatric setting
9%
Percentage of patients with depression violent in the 20 weeks following discharge from a psychiatric setting
19%
Percentage of patients with bipolar disorder violent in the 20 weeks following discharge from a psychiatric setting
15%
Percentage of patients with substance misuse disorders violent in the 20 weeks following discharge from a psychiatric setting
29%
Percentage of patients with personality disorder violent in the 20 weeks following discharge from a psychiatric setting
25%
Percentage of patients with another psychotic disorder (not schizophrenia or bipolar) violent in the 20 weeks following discharge from a psychiatric setting
17.2%
Percentage of patients in the community with schizophrenia who have committed a violent act in the preceding 12 months
10%
Percentage of general population living in the community who have committed a violent act in the preceding 12 months
2%
Annual risk of a male patient with schizophrenia committing homicide
1:3000
Annual risk of a female patient with schizophrenia committing homicide
1:33000
Percentage of prison population with psychosis
3.7%
Percentage of prison population with major depression
10%
Percentage of prison population with personality disorder
65%
Percentage of prison population with organic mental disorder
1%
Percentage of homicides related to a mental disorder
34%
Description of Penrose’s law
There is an inverse relationship between rates of prison occupancy and rates of mental institution occupancy
Number of homicides annually committed by a mentally disordered offender
50
Percentage of offenders of homicide who have an abnormal mental state at the time of the offence
10%
Annual risk of a patient with schizophrenia committing homicide
1:10000
Annual risk of a person with schizophrenia being convicted of violence
1:150
Definition of filicide
A mother killing their own child
D’Orban’s six types of filicides
Battering mothers
Mentally ill mothers
Neonaticides
Retaliating women
Unwanted children
Mercy killings
Description of ‘battering mothers’ group of filicides
Impulsive killing due to a loss of temper
Description of ‘neonaticides’ group of filicides
Usually defined as killing of a child within 24 hours of life
Description of ‘retaliating women’ group of filicides
Mother’s aggression towards their partner is displaced onto the child
Description of ‘unwanted child’ group of filicides
Can be active killing or passive neglect; associated with unplanned pregnancies and socioeconomic deprivation
Description of ‘mercy killing’ group of filicides
Victim is genuinely suffering; no secondary gain for the mother
Most common mental illnesses associated with ‘mentally ill mothers’ group of filicides
Depression
Psychotic illness
Personality disorder
Definition of infanticide
Intentional killing of an infant (usually under 12 months old) by their mother
Definition of murder-suicide
Murder followed by suicide of the perpetrator within one week of the murder
Mental illness more common among murder-suicide perpetrators than homicide perpetrators
Depression
Two typical clinical presentations of murder-suicide perpetrators
- Middle aged man, recently separated from his partner, suffering from depression, access to firearms
- Older man, caregiver for his partner, recent onset of new illness in the man, depression, access to firearms
Definition of patricide
Killing of someone’s own parents (more often their father)
Definition of matricide
Killing of someone’s own mother
Percentage of homicides made up by patricide/(matricide)
2%
Typical demographic of a patricide perpetrator
Male
Aged 12-50
Motivated by revenge for sexual abuse or financial gain
Number of annual cases of non-fatal assault in England and Wales
1 million
Definition of common assault
Any act where someone intentionally or recklessly causes another person to suffer apprehend immediate unlawful violence
Definition of aggravated assault
An act where someone attempts or does cause serious bodily injury to another person purposefully or recklessly manifesting extreme indifference to human life; or with a deadly weapon
Definition of battery
An act where someone intentionally or recklessly applies unlawful force to the body of another person
Difference between assault and battery
Battery requires actual force; assault can be committed if someone indicated violence e.g. someone throws a punch that misses
Percentage of perpetrators of non fatal violence with schizophrenia
9%
Percentage of middle aged female shoplifters who are depressed
24-30%
Age at which shoplifting usually peaks
Adolescence
Percentage of shoplifters with a history consistent with kleptomania
1-2%
Percentage of people who set fires who do so intentionally
25%
Percentage of psychiatric patients with a history of fire setting behaviour
26%
Percentage of psychiatric patients who have previously set fires
16%
Association between IQ and fire setting
Low IQ gives a higher risk of fire setting
Typical demographics of an intentional fire setter
Young adult male
Relationship difficulties
Unmarried
Poorly educated
Isolated
Unemployed or unskilled labourer
Likelihood of males compared to females fire setting
Males 2.5x more likely
Groups of fire setters described by Faulk
Group 1 - fire setting as a means to an end e.g. fraud, revenge
Group 2 - fire setting for its own sake
Six criteria for pyromania according to DSM IV
Deliberate fire setting on multiple occasions
Emotional arousal and tension before fire setting
Fascination/attraction to fire
Pleasure or relief when setting fires
Exclusion of other causes
Fire setting not better accounted for by conduct disorder or personality disorder
Sex more associated with juvenile fire setting under the age of 10
Females
Reoffence rates of mentally disordered fire setters
11%
Reoffence rates of non mentally disordered fire setters
4%
Percentage of women who have been stalked in their lifetime
15%
Percentage of stalkers who are male
80-90%
Percentage of stalking victims who are women
80-90%
Typical demographics of a stalking victim
Woman
Reproductive age
Previous sexual relationship with the perpetrator
Typical demographics of a stalker
Male
Unemployed or underemployed
Well educated
Previous sexual relationship with their victim
Types of stalkers described by Mullen
Rejected - pursues ex-partners
Intimacy seekers - stalk someone they believe they love and loves them back
Incompetent suitors - inappropriately intrude, looking for a date
Resentful - look to get revenge for a real or imagined injury
Predatory - stalking forms part of other sexual offending
Psychiatric diagnoses most often seen in ex-partner stalkers
Borderline PD
Narcissistic PD
Histrionic PD
Antisocial PD
Psychiatric diagnoses most often seen in stranger stalkers
Delusional disorders, most commonly erotomania
Schizophrenia
Affective disorders
Organic psychosis
Percentage of stalking victims who develop PTSD
37-60%
Percentage of psychiatrists who consider themselves to have been stalked
22%
Percentage of psychiatrists who have experienced stalking behaviour meeting the legal definition of harassment
33%
Typical demographics of a stalker who has targeted a mental health professional
Male
Prior history of stalking
Under the care of the stalked clinician
Motivated by wanting more intimacy
Percentage of sexual offenders committing offences against children who are a relative of the child
13%
Percentage of sexual offenders committing offences against children who are known to the child but not a relative
68%
Percentage of child sexual abuse offenders who are male
90%
Percentage of child sexual abuse offenders who are adolescents
33%
Definition of incest in England/Wales vs. Scotland
Penetration must have occurred in both
In England/Wales step relatives are not included but in Scotland they are
Percentage of reported incest cases which involve children
30%
Percentage of perpetrators of indecent exposure who reoffend
20-30%
Definition of penile plethysmography
Determining sexual arousal by measuring changes in penile tumescence when images or stories of deviant sexual material are presented