Regulation of Financial Services Flashcards
How is the provision of financial services regulated in the UK?
Financial Services and Markets Act 2000
Will many law firms obtain FCA authorisation?
No - stringent level of regulation + small proportion of work for clients requiring authorisation = not cost-efficient
What is the general prohibition under s19(1) of FSMA and what is a breach of it?
- No person may carry on a regulated activity unless he is an authorised person or exempt person
- Breach = criminal offence
So solicitor must assess whether activity is governed by s19
What are the 2 components of a ‘regulated activity’?
A specified investment + specified activity
E.g. advising on the merits (activity) of shares (investment)
What if the activity being proposed to by a client is governed by s19(1) and the solicitor is not an authorised nor exempt person?
They should refer the client to an independent financial advisor authorised by the FCA instead
Why should lawyers make clients aware of the scope of financial services regulations?
- So lawyer does not commit offence
- They can properly advise clients about their own statutory constraints
What are the steps of the Financial Services Decision Tree?
- Is the investment ‘specified’ under FSMA? If yes…
- Is the activity a ‘specified activity’ under FSMA? If yes…
- Is the activity excluded under FSMA? If no…
- Does the activity fulfil the basic conditions in s327 of FSMA and SRA Scope Rule 2? If yes = exemption is possible, if no = authorisation is required
What are the specified investments?
Step 1
- Rights under contract of insurance
- Shares
- Instruments creating/acknowledging indebtedness (inc bonds)
- Government/public securities
- Rights under a pension scheme
- Regulated mortgage contracts (covers typical home buyer’s mortgage but not a loan to buy an office or loan to companies)
If not specified, FSMA does not apply + no authorisation required
What are the 4 ‘specified activities’?
Step 2
Person will not require authorisation unless they are carrying out a specified activity by way of business in relation to the specified investment
- Dealing in investments as principal or as an agent - inc buying, selling, subscribing or underwriting securities (shares, GOV securities, rights under pension scheme) or contractually based investments
- Arranging deals in investments
- Managing investments (exercising discretion re investments that are securities/contractually based investments)
- Advising on (the merits of) investments
Fourth is most likely encountered by a lawyer - corporate solicitors often give advice
What will fall under advising on (the merits of) investments (requires 2 things) and what will not?
- Will: advice requiring an element of opinion and a recommendation as to the course of action
- Will not: generic advice - like to invest in China as opposed to Europe - will not require FCA authorisation (e.g. explaining the legal rights attaching to 2 different classes of shares is fine unless solicitor recommended purchasing shares)
Only advice given to someone who holds or is a prospective investor in a security or relevant instrument relating to merits of buying, selling, subscribing for, exchanging, redeeming, holding or underwriting such investments falls within Art 53(1) [not sure how important this is but leaving this her in case!]
What are the 3 general exclusions under FSMA and what happens if one of them applies?
Step 3
- Regulated activities are necessary part of other services carried on in course of profession or non-investment business
- Regulated activities in connection with the sale of a body corporate
- Authorised persons
If they apply = can stop here!
What do the general exclusions not apply to?
Contracts of insurance
What would be considered a ‘necessary part’ and when will the exclusion not apply?
Step 3 exclusion 1
Generally quite rare in practice
- It must not be possible for other services to be provided unless dealing/arranging/advising is also provided
- Will not apply if the specified activity is remunerated separately or to contracts of insurance at all
E.g. client selling leasehold flat, transaction might also involve transfer of a share in a management company or company that owns freehold for block of flats - although shares are specified investments, arranging their sale would be a necessary part of other property work solicitor carrying out = solicitor could arrange for transfer of share without being authorised by FCA
When will regulated activities in connection with the sale of a body corporate - i.e. purchase/sale of shares in company - come under the exclusion?
Step 3 exclusion 2
If shares (can inc those already held) consist of/include 50% or more of voting rights in company or may reasonably be regarded as acquisition of day-to-day control of the affairs of the body corporate
Does not matter if two entities are different legal status e.g. company can sell shares to individual or partnership etc.
How does the authorised persons exclusion work? (2 conditions)
Step 3 exclusion 3
Solicitor will not be carrying on specified activity if he enters into a transaction as agent for client provided:
1. Transaction was entered into on advice of authorised person; or
2. It is clear the client is not seeking/has not sought advice from solicitor re merits of entering transaction (solicitor has refused if they have)
Same whether it is dealing or arranging