Record Cites

Question 1

Alien Sedition Act

text + rationale

Answer 1

in the record at page 2

Question 2

Mr. El’s immigration history

Answer 2

in the record at page 2

Question 3

Mr. El’s employment info

Answer 3

in the record at page 2

Question 4

Mr. El’s family/relationship info

Answer 4

in the record at page 3

Question 5

Mr. El’s community connections

Answer 5

in the record at page 3

Question 6

Mr. El’s speech

Answer 6

in the record at page 3

Question 7

Mr. El’s arrest, conviction, and imprisonment

Answer 7

in the record at page 3

Question 8

Mr. El’s notice and hearing facts

Answer 8

in the record at page 4

Question 9

Notice of Intent

Exhibit A to Facts in the Record

Answer 9

in the record at page 7

Question 10

Letter attached to Mr. El’s “NOI” response

Exhibit B to Facts in the Record

Answer 10

in the record at page 8

Question 11

Hearing transcript

Exhibit C to Facts in the Record

Answer 11

in the record at page 9

Question 12

Parties stipulation:

Mr. El’s conviction falls within the aggravated felony designation under 8 USC 1101(a)(43)

Answer 12

in the record at page 5

Question 13

Mr. El’s stipulation:

under current law, he has no legal right to remain in the U.S.

Answer 13

in the record at page 5

Question 14

Government’s stipulation:

if the aggravated felony conviction is invalid, Mr. El may may be eligible for certain discretionary relief

Answer 14

in the record at page 5

Question 15

Mr. El’s stipulation:

no procedural challenges to validity of his removal or conviction

Answer 15

in the record at page 6

Question 16

Mr. El’s stipulation:

no ineffective assistance of counsel claim

Answer 16

in the record at page 6

Question 17

Government’s stipulation:

waives all non-exhaust-remedy procedural challenges in the 14th Circuit action

Answer 17

in the record at page 6

Question 18

Procedural context of this case

Answer 18

in the record at page 5