Realism Flashcards
What does classical realism say is the cause of war?
Human Nature
What does neo-realism say is the cause of war?
Anarchy
Who are some of the ancient and pre-modern thinkers that classical realism is based upon?
Thucydides, Machiavelli & Hobbes
The lessons of which conflict led to the emergence of Realism as a critique of the liberal internationalist thinking during the inter-war period?
World War Two
Who said that liberal internationalism is dangerously normative and that scarcity is the cause of conflicts- between the ‘have’ and ‘have-nots’
E. H. Carr
How does Carr view liberalism?
Liberalism is ‘utopian’ and normative- it focuses on what should be, rather than what is.
What does Carr see as shaping international relations?
Power NOT morality shapes international relations- so we should understand the realities of power.
Consensus happens but as an outcome of temporary power configurations, not a ‘harmony of interests’.
What does Carr see as the only way to change the configuration of power?
War
E.H. Carr belongs to which school of IR thought?
Classical Realism
Morgenthau belongs to which school of IR thought?
Classical Realism
What kind of methodology does Morgenthau promote?
Positivist
Which text did Morgenthau release in 1948?
‘Politics Among Nations’
Whose concept of ‘human nature’ does Morgenthau employ in his explanation of the source of conflict?
Hobbes- ‘Nature of Man’, not ‘scarcity’ is the source of conflict
What is Hobbes’ concept of ‘human nature’?
Emotions, thoughts and reasoning are products of self-interest seeking nature of humans
The aggressive, power-seeking characteristic of states reflect the basic nature of human beings
What are Morgenthau’s propositions about states?
Stats are key actors
They have interests, which dominate their behaviour
Are egoists and never sacrifice themselves, they are rational
Seek power to achieve their goals
International relations is about rational states pursuing interests defined in terms of power
What kind of theory does rationalism claim to be?
Rational
What do classical realists say states should avoid if they wish to avoid conflict?
States should avoid ‘crusades’ of moral and ideological natures.
Moral excess has destroyed nations and civilisations. Better to pursue policies that respect other nations’ interests but promote ours at the same time