R06 - Case Study 2 Flashcards
State the additional information that an adviser would require to advise Nick and Shirin on the suitability and tax-efficiency of their current financial arrangements (11)
- CFL
- What are objectives and timescale?
- Is interest being received on deposit accounts
- AA/Diversification within equity funds
- Use of allowances (ISA and Pension)
- Performance of S&S ISAs
- Charges on S&S ISAs
- Are you expecting inheritance
- Willingness to alter portfolio in line with ATR
- Awareness of PSA/Div Allow
- Awareness of CGT allowance unable to use
Comment on Nick & Shirin’s income tax position (7)
- Both higher rate taxpayers
- Both have £500 PSA to use against savings interest
- Both have £2,000 dividend allowance, currently not used
- Income from ISAs is tax free
- Higher rate tax relief on pension contributions
- Could pay more into pension for future fund growth and tax relief
- If they are receiving child benefit Shirin will pay high income child benefit charge
Comment on the suitability of Nick and Shirin’s current savings and investments (11)
- They have sufficient cash for emergency’s
- Is the interest on their savings account competitive
- They have ISAs for tax efficiency
- But neither can use dividend allowance of £2,000
- May not be using PSA in full
- Neither can use CGT
- Shirin’s employer would increase pension contributions to 8% if Shirin matches it
- Shirin’s pension fund doesn’t match ATR
- Overall insufficient diversification
- Both have UK equity funds only in their ISA and Nick’s pension which may match ATR but overweight in equity
- Lack of geographical diversification
Outline the key factors that a financial adviser should consider, when recommending a suitable strategy for Nick and Shirin’s exiting savings and investments (8)
- Objectives
- Use of savings and investments
- Diversification, correlation, AA
- Timescale
- Emergency fund
- CFL/ATR, experience
- Charges and performance
- Planned use of tax wrappers, use of allowances, higher rate tax status
Describe the process that an adviser should follow before giving investment advice to Nick and Shirin (12)
- Establish relationship, disclose status, adviser remuneration
- Establish goals, expectations, objectives, fact finding, affordability
- Timescales
- ATF/CFL
- Amount of emergency fund needed
- Analyse financial and personal situation
- Formulate recommendation
- Tax status
- Likely future tax position
- Fund selection and AA
- Implement recommendation
- Review
Comment on the suitability of Nick and Shirin continuing to hold UK equity funds within S&S ISAs (6)
- Not diversified (geographical or asset class)
- Vulnerable to UK economy
- Shares can be volatile
- Could provide income
- Tax free as in ISA wrapper
- Is there diversification across sectors
Identify and explain to Nick and Shirin the key investment risks of holding equities (5)
- Pricing, depends on supply and demand
- Share dividend volatility, dividends can fluctuate
- Liquidity risk, some shares difficult to sell
- Regulatory risk, misleading info
- Diversification, essential to spread risk associated with equities
Explain how diversification may be used to manage and reduce risk (4)
- Reduces risk by reducing concentration
- Some asset classes are not strongly correlated, loss with one asset class may not be a loss to another
- Geographical diversification spreads risk across number of economies, currencies and national markets
- Sector diversification reduces risk associated with specific areas of the economy or particular firms
Outline the process to review the performance of existing ISAs (12)
- LOA and obtain plan details
- Confirm date of purchase
- Base cost, further investments, withdrawals, fund switches
- Identify reinvestment income
- Calculate performance
- Asses AA
- Identify suitable benchmark
- Compare against the benchmark
- Review charges
- Compare with risk-free return
- Review volatility
- Asses funds against ATR
Identify the reasons why a range of collective investment funds might be suitable for Nick and Shirin (14)
- Improves diversification
- Reduces risk
- Professional management
- No CGT on internal changes (If in unit trust or OEIC)
- Funds can match ATR
- Wide choice of funds
- Can choose monthly/quatrly withdrawals~
- Simply tax reporting
- Less admin, can be held on platform
- Pound cost averaging on monthly contributions
- Reduces market timing risk
- Can use dividend allowance (If unit trust or OEIC)
- Flexible contributions
- Suitable for long term investments
Identify the key reasons why a global equity-based investment strategy might be appropriate for Nick and Shirin (8)
- Potential for growth
- Equities tend to out perform other assets
- Long investment timeframe
- If regular contributions, pound cost averaging
- Reduces risk
- Inflation protection
- Geographical / currency diversification
- Matches ATR
Nick & Shirin are considering making overpayments to their mortgage. State the benefits and drawbacks of them making such overpayments (7/4)
Benefits
- Reduces interest charges
- Reduces debt
- Can make payment up to 10% without penalty
- Peace of mind
- Could reduce mortgage term
- No investment risk
- Could improve credit rating
Drawbacks
- Interest rate is low
- Do they have sufficient surplus income to make overpayment?
- Potential for higher growth if invested elsewhere in line with ATR
- Retaining debt increases flexibility
Identify the additional information that you would need to advise Nick and Shirin on their aim of retiring when Nick reaches age 60 (13)
- Income and capital required for intended travel plans
- Income from savings and investments
- Downsizing, willing to use other assets, expected inheritance
- Lifestyle / smoking status
- Pension contributions history / carry forward available
- State benefit entitlement
- AA on pension, charges, statement, fund choice, projections
- Any other pensions
- Affordability / budget
- Prepared to maximize allowances? Will budget allow?
- Cannot use CGT allowance as only have S&S ISAs
- CFL
- Nomination form done on pension schemes
Identify reasonable assumptions you might make in relation to Nick and Shirin’s retirement planning (5)
- That they continue working full time until Nick reaches age 60
- They they both receive full state pension at SPA
- That they will continue contributing into workplace pension to maximize employer contributions
- Stay in good health
- Willing to use other assets to generate income at retirement
List the factors that a financial adviser would need to consider when advising Nick and Shirin on funding their retirement planning strategy (12)
- Longevity
- Current, planned and future expenditure and capital needs
- Budget / affordability
- State pension age
- AA of funds
- Use of ISA and Pension allowances
-Charges - Priority of objective
- CFL / ATR
- Market conditions
- Expected rate of return on investments
- Impact of death or serious illness of either of them