quiz questions Flashcards
Which of the following best captures the main upshot of Barnes’ article?
Valuing disability can sometimes lead to actions that cause harm to disabled individuals.
Functional accounts of health (like the ones that Anita Silvers critiques) understand health as
the ability to perform all typical physiological functions with at least typical efficiency.
What is the primary focus of Menzel’s article?
The ethical justification for a basic minimum of accessible healthcare
“Bad-difference” views of disability maintain that disability
is something that, in itself, makes you worse off.
Which of the following is essential to maintaining a mere-difference view of disability?
Disability is analogous to features like sexuality, gender, ethnicity, and race.
Disability is a valuable part of human diversity that should be celebrated and preserved.
All of the above.
None of the above.
none of the above
According to Menzel, what constitutes a “basic minimum” of healthcare?
Essential services that address fundamental health needs.
In “A Fatal Attraction to Normalizing,” Anita Silvers argues that matching the species-typical design is more important than freedom and individual well-being. true or false
false
According to Menzel, the fact that hospitals in the U.S. are legally prohibited from turning away the uninsured for emergency care counts in favor of the claim that a right to basic health care is already embedded in U.S. moral culture. true or false
true
Which of the following best captures the main argument of Silvers’ article?
Normalizing behaviors and attitudes is essential for social cohesion.
The desire to normalize can lead to harmful consequences for marginalized groups.
Normalization has no significant impact on societal values.
Normalizing is necessary for effective communication.
desire to normalize can lead to harmful consequences for marginalized groups
According to Silvers, the restoration of normal mode of function should take priority over the restoration of normal level of functioning. true or false
false
The utilitarian purpose behind using quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) is..
to ensure an absolute right to a decent minimum of care.
to care for only those who can pay.
to do the most good with the resources available.
to care for those who are most deserving.
to do most good with resources available
Some cases of causing disability can be impermissible on the “mere-difference” view. true or false
true
Some argue that quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) are unfair to who
older people and those with disabilities
QALYs measure the subjective nature of people’s assessment of the value of their own lives. true or false
false
According to Thomson, if one grants that a fetus is a person from the moment of conception, then it follows that abortion is always wrong. true or false
false
Glannon argues that inequalities resulting from enhancements above the baseline of normal physical and mental functioning could threaten to undermine the conviction in the fundamental importance of…
superior abilities.
personal wellness.
physical identity.
equality.
equality
According to Marquis (“Why Abortion is Immoral”), abortion is morally wrong because
it deprives fetus of valuable future
Thomson’s violinist thought experiment (“A Defense of Abortion”) is meant to show that
abortion is always morally permissible.
not everyone has a right to life.
the right to life does not entail the right not to be killed.
everyone has a right to the bare minimum needed to keep them alive.
the right to life does not entail the right to be killed
Marquis concludes that abortion is seriously wrong in all cases. true or false
false
According to the medical argument against liver transplants for alcoholics, alcoholics should be de-prioritized because
the likelihood of relapse puts the new liver at higher risk of destruction.
their medical condition is the result of immoral behavior.
it would be unfair to prioritize them over non-alcoholics.
All of the above.
likelihood of relapse puts the new liver at higher risk of destruction