Quiz 5 Flashcards
Arguments, Fallacies, and Rules of Inference.
Generalized De Morgan’s Laws
¬(∀xP(x)) ≡ ∃x¬(P(x))
Generalized De Morgan’s Laws
¬(∃xP(x)) ≡ ∀x¬(P(x))
Exactly One…
∃x(1?(x) ∧ 2?(x) ∧ ∀y[(1?(y) ∧ 2?(y)) → (y = x)] x, y ∈ ?
Exactly Two…
∃x∃y(1?(x) ∧ 1?(y) ∧ (x≠y) ∧ ∀z[1?(z) → (x = y ∨ z = y)] x, y, z ∈ ?
Argument
A connected series of statements to establish a definite proposition.
Inductive Argument
An argument that moves from specific observations to general conclusions.
Deductive Argument
An argument that uses accepted general principles to explain specific situations.
Valid Argument
Any deductive argument in the form of (p1, p2, p3…, pn) → is _____ if the conclusion follows from those hypotheses.
Sound Argument
A valid argument that also has a true hypothesis.
Rule of Inference: Addition
p /∴ p ∨ q
Rule of Inference: Simplification
p ∧ q /∴ p
Rule of Inference: Conjunction
p, q /∴ p ∧ q
Rule of Inference: Modus Ponens (“Method of Affirming”)
p, p → q /∴ q
Rule of Inference: Modus Tollens (“Method of Denying”)
¬q, q → p /∴ ¬p
Rule of Inference: Hypothetical Syllogism (“Transitivity of Implication”)
p → q, q → r /∴ p → r
Rule of Inference: Disjunctive Syllogism
p ∨ q, ¬q /∴ p
Rule of Inference: Resolution
p ∨ q, ¬p ∨ r /∴ q ∨ r
Synonym: “Syllogism”
Deduction
Universal Instantiation
∀xP(x), x ∈ D /∴ P(d) if d ∈ D
Universal Generalization
P(d) for any d ∈ D /∴ ∀xP(x), x ∈ D
Existential Instantiation
∃xP(x), x ∈ D /∴ P(d) for some d ∈ D
Existential Generalization
P(d) for some d ∈ D /∴ ∃xP(x), x ∈ D
Fallacy
An argument constructed with an improper inference.
Fallacy: Affirming the Consequent
If Juan is in Dallas, than he is in Texas. He is in Texas. Therefore, he is in Dallas.
Fallacy: Denying the Hypothesis
If Ingrid is in Dallas, she is in Texas. She isn’t in Dallas. Therefore, she is not in Texas.
Fallacy: Begging the Question
I’m not lying so I must be telling the truth.
Fallacy: Interrogation
Have you stopped annoying your spouse?
Fallacy: No True Scotsman
No true American opposes tax cuts.
Specious Reasoning
An unsupported or improperly constructed argument. (That is, an unsound or invalid argument.)
Conjecture
A statement with an unknown truth value.
Theorem
A conjecture that has been shown to be true.
Proof
A sound argument that establishes the truth of a theorem.
Lemma
A simple theorem whose truth is used to construct more complex theorems.
Corollary
A theorem whose truth follows directly from another theorem.