Quiz 3 Flashcards
How should you conduct a chain analysis?
After identifying vulnerabilities prior to the chain analysis, in excruciating detail, understand all links before and after the target behavior.
If this is done properly –> a solution analysis can be done.
What is a solution analysis?
The process of identifying what can be done differently before or after to increase or decrease the emotions, thoughts, behaviors, or external factors being experienced
Ex. identifying exit ramps: “how could you think differently about this?”
Are all exposures behavioral experiments?
YES. all exposures are behavioral experiments but not all behavioral experiments are exposures.
Ex. a behavioral experiment might be information seeking i.e. how many plane crashes happen each year.
What is the definition of a behavioral experiment?
They are planned, experiential activities based on experimentation or observation, which are undertaken by patients in or between CBT sessions.
What is the purpose of a behavioral experiment?
To encourage the client to act in a values-driven way despite their anxiety.
Good for hypothesis testing - negative beliefs and alternative beliefs
Discovery when there is no clear hypothesis - finding out what happens
What to do if the same B.E. is conducted with no change?
Might be conceptualizing the client wrong. A philosophical approach (REBT) might work better (i.e. “who says you have to always be smart/confident?” and coming up with a B.E. where they actually say something incompetent and seeing how they handle it compared to their expectations.
Types of concerns that can be used to design a behavioral experiment.
I cannot tolerate not knowing if I locked the door to my house.
If I have a panic attack while driving, I will lose control and crash.
If I think about something bad happening to another person, it will happen.
What can we get from behavioral experiment “failures”?
Teaches person that they can handle challenges, that people can be trusted.
What can you do when people say they’re not feeling well enough to do a behavioral experiment?
Who says you’re always going to feel 100% comfortable? Have you ever done other things when you’re not feeling totally comfortable? What did you do? How did you handle that?
What should you do BEFORE a behavioral experiment?
Conduct a CB assessment
Case formulation and feedback
Discussion with client of cognitive behavioral approach. –> CB model, collaborative empiricism, value of personal experience in learning
Types of behavioral experiments
Active
Observational - go to the park and watch people
Surveys - ask friends “if this happens, then what?”
Gathering information from other sources - internet search, etc.
The learning circle in a behavioral experiment.
Plan –> experience –> observe –> reflect –> back to plan
Planning phase of behavioral experiment
Clarify purpose, specify prediction, specify alternative (if applicable), rate degree of belief in prediction/alternative, specify how outcome will be addressed, how the experiment will be conducted, identify potential confounding behaviors (preventing yes, buts), ensure no lose outcome (test of probability and cost)
*identify safety behaviors that should not be used in experiment
Experiencing phase of behavioral experiment.
Client understands purpose and how to conduct experiment and is prepared to fully engage, be flexible, confidentiality is addressed when applicable, what to do when it doesn’t turn out well
Observation phase of the behavioral experiment
Focus attention on observing information relevant to the validity of the prediction, watch out for biased interpretation (yes, buts) keep a written record of the outcome if applicable
Reflection phase of behavioral experiments
determine what was learned and implications for prediction tested, assess for conditional learning (yes, buts) that might interfere with generalization, clarify how much belief in initial prediction remains to be targeted.
Cognitive therapy portion - “was anything surprising about what happened?” Discrepancy between predicted and actual outcome; corrective learning - might take time to change core belief.
Planning again phase in behavioral experiment
what does the outcome of the previous experiment mean going forward? what additional learning is needed? what should the next experiment be? what experiments would allow for the maximum possible learning?
Possible outcomes of behavioral experiment.
- It goes better than expected.
- It goes poorly but they can handle it.
What are two habit disorders?
Body-focused repetitive behaviors - 5% of the population, voluntary behaviors (not tics)
Tic disorders
What are three body focused repetitive behaviors?
Trichotilomania
Excoriation
Onychophagia
What is trichotilomania
Causes people to pull out the hair from their scalp, eyelashes, eyebrows, and other parts of the body resulting in noticeable bald patches.
What is excoriation?
Skin picking, causes people to repetitively touch, rub, scratch, pick at, or dig into their skin, resulting in skin discoloration, scarring, and even severe tissue damage and disfigurement.
What is onychophagia
Nail biting disorder, causes people to bite their nails past the nail bed and chew on cuticles until they bleed leading to soreness and infection.
What is a tic?
A sudden, rapid, recurrent, non-rhythmic, stereotyped motor movement or vocalization.
Involuntary movements, sounds, or words that are “sudden, rapid, recurrent, nonrhythmic”
Can be simple or complex -
1. just vocal or just motor
2. motor and vocal (complex)
3. complex motor
Habit reversal training Components
- awareness training - recognizing when they’re ticking
- Development of a competing response - less noticeable, can be carried out for more than a few minutes
- Building motivation - make a list of the problems caused by tics, all the bad things it brings
- Generalization of new skills - practice the skills in new contexts and locations
What to do during exposure / if client attempts to engage in a safety behavior?
Have the client explain the purpose of the experiment and then challenge safety behavior by having them do something different (instead of pulling pillow away from face, move it closer to face)
periodically ask her to notice how she’s feeling
Why choose exposure therapy?
Appears to be the primary, active ingredient in CBT for anxiety disorders. –> just as effective as more complex CBTs; particularly true for PTSD, OCD, Social anxiety, cognitive therapy alone is not as effective as combined CBT treatments
Exposure is effective for ALL anxiety disorders –> cognitive therapy has only been shown to work for some anxiety disorders and not specific phobias or OCD.
Active ingredients in adult CBT according to Adams et al. (2015)
Strong effect sizes for CBT and BT with little difference adding the cognitive component to the behavioral component for specific disorders (i.e. PTSD)
Active ingredients in child CBT according to Ale, et al. (2015)
Examination concluded that adding relaxation and anxiety management strategies prior to exposures did not improve outcomes for exposure-based treatment.
More gold-standard clinician based outcomes measures need to be implemented to assess efficacy of adding anxiety management strategies to exposure therapy in order to increase efficacy of CBT for CADS to that of ERP for OCD.
How effective is exposure therapy?
60-85% of anxiety disorder clients who receive exposure therapy show clinically significant improvement. –> 68% remit from PTSD; 77% of panic disorder no longer experience panic attacks; 83% of OCD show significant improvement