quiz 2 Flashcards
Critical legal studies
heavily influenced by marxist thought; views the law as a tool of opression by the ruling class to maintain power and perpetuate existing social inequality
Ronald Dowrkin
rejects positivism on every concievable level: law creates a norm and gives decision-makers guidance. If a judge violates these laws, they are considered unlawful
Determinism
your inclinations are “predetermined” and shaped by societal norms
Free-will is limited by social infrastructure
Constructive interpretation
aims to create the best possible outcome. Judges should implement their best understanding of justice when making decisions
Conventionalism
(precedes dworkin)
judges should apply the law objectively
Pragmatism
judges should be concerned with the consequences of their decisions
consequentialism
moral virtue of an action is judged by the consequences it produces
idealism
moral actors are guided by principles of right and wrong (deontological)
Gratian 1140 AD
customary law is a practice that wasn’t required but becomes required.
Law is divenly revealed
Divinely ordained law overrides constitutions; humanmade law contrary to God’s law is void
empiricism
the idea that an individual relies on sensory experience to formulate judgements/knowledge
Thomas Hobbes
people are evil, hence the need for a strong civil government
Legal positivism
morality should not limit the scope of law
the United Nations
founded in San Francisco, based in New York; not a sovereign entity (meaning it only has power to the extent it’s members give it power)
the UN Charter
refers to universal human rights in relation to their respective government
the Nuremberg trials
criticized as being “ad hoc” meaning the laws applied in the case existed for the purpose of that trial only
The law has to be preexisting no ex post facto laws
Knife example (The republic)
A man lends his knife to another. Before the lendee can return the knife, the lender goes mad. Raises moral questions about whether or not the knife should be returned. The legally correct choice would be to return it, the morally correct to withhold it (protect the lender from himself and others)
St. Augustine
Render unto caesar’s what is caesar’s and unto god what is god’s- advocated for the separation of the sacred from the secular
Thomas Aquinas
Christianity should influence the secular state (because it provides access to natural law)
Eternal law
Known only to God
Natural Law
discoverable through reason
Divine Law
revealed in scripture