QUIZ 1 MATERIAL Flashcards
Where does family law come from?
State laws, court
Within Legislative regulation, what do State Legislatures do?
traditionally regulate most family law issues, such as marriage and divorce.
Within Legislative regulation, what is Congress?
has increasingly become involved in family law, including legislation regarding child support and child custody.
All legislation is subject to what?
subject to Constitutional limits
What is Marriage defined as within State Regulation?
-considered a “status” based on contract and established by law
-The state has the authority to regulate marriage based on the general welfare of its citizens.
-A movement in a minority of states exists to consider marriage a “contract” as opposed to status.
What is the court’s role in Judicial regulations?
to “interpret” the state legislation & apply it to the current factual situation
Within Judicial regulation how many approaches are there? what are they?
2 Approaches:
-Legal Formalism: follow precedent exercise judicial restraint; logically-based
-Legal Functionalism: primary concern is socially desirable consequences; result-oriented approach
Within Federal courts, what is the - Domestic Regulation Exception Rule
federal courts do NOT have jurisdiction to grant divorces, award spousal support, or determine child custody issues.
What can federal courts do?
- can hear issues based in tort or contract law, even if family law issues are involved.
- can also adjudicate the constitutionality of state statutes regulating the marital relationship
What are some overall things that are within the Traditional Family?
- Traditional religious laws regulating families controlled for centuries
- With the Protestant Reformation, English civil courts took over the regulation of family law matters.
-English law regarding adopted by the American colonies
What was it like within the Early 20th Century Assumptions in the American & European Legal Systems?
- marriage was a primary support institution & a decisive determinant of social status
- marriage lasted until death and was only terminated in serious situations
- community aspect of family emphasized over the individual
- Husband-father had the dominant role
- Procreation was the major purpose of marriage
What were some results of the change in the 20th century’s structure of traditional marriage?
- “Two Paycheck” Families
- Dramatic increase in the divorce rate with the institution of the “no-fault” method of divorce
- Increase in the number of children living in single-parent homes
There has been a movement back towards the idea of a “traditional family”….. what happened?
- Covenant Marriages: parties agree to premarital counseling and terminate their marriage on traditional “fault” grounds
- Some states make it difficult to get a divorce & returning to the “fault” system
- Requiring some pre-marital education
What are covenant marriages?
parties agree to premarital counseling and terminate their marriage on traditional “fault” grounds
What is it like in the Nontraditional Family?
- Some scholars suggest that marriage is no longer a viable model by which to evaluate “families” in this country
- Can traditional family law deal with modern realities? Or do we need new laws to adequately address the changing family picture?
What is Meyer v. Nebraska?
-Meyer v. Nebraska: recognized that the right to marry is a fundamental constitutional right under the Due Process Clause of the 14th amendment
What comes within constitutional parameters?
For a state to regulate marriage, it must have a legitimate state interest that justifies the restriction
-ex: setting a minimum age to marry
What is the right to privacy?
- Not specifically mentioned in the U.S. Constitution
- Douglas: the right is found in the “penumbra” of other fundamental rights
- States cannot forbid married couples from using contraception (Griswold v. Connecticut)
-Right to abortion (Roe v. Wade) before Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022)
What is the Due Process Clause?
legalizes same sex marriage
ex.) the definition of “liberty” here is crucial to the majority opinion within Obergefell v Hodges.
What is Equal Protection Law?
Equal Protection Law: meant to prevent discrimination (based on gender, age, disability)
What is Marriage considered as being? How does the state regulate marriage?
considered a “legal status” based on contract.
- the state can regulate marriage based upon the general welfare of the people of that state:
-Age at which you can marry
-Property law implications
-Social Security benefits
-Health care decisions
Consensual Alternatives of marriage are?
- In the last 30 years, there has been a substantial rise in nonmarital cohabitation
-Both homosexual and heterosexual couples
- How do you resolve disputes between two parties who were not married, but lived together as a family?
- Do you apply contract law?
- Or do you apply the same “status” laws that apply to married couples?
Within Nonmarital Cohabitation, what are some contract implications? What are the 3 main approaches?
-Most courts are going to approach these cases from a contract law position
3 Main Approaches:
-An express or an implied contract is actionable, as long as the contract is NOT based on sexual activities (Martin v. Marvin)
-Only express nonmarital contracts are enforceable, as long as not based on sexual conduct (NY- Morone v. Morone)
-Nonmarital contracts are not enforceable based on public policy (Hewitt v. Hewitt- Illinois)
What are some Property issues in Nonmarital cohabitation?
-What if a couple later marries? What happens to the property they acquired BEFORE they got married?
-Some courts have adopted a “legal merger” theory allowing the judge to consider both premarital and post-marital property together upon divorce
-The majority of states will NOT divide premarital property upon divorce.
-They consider it “separate property.”
What if the couple never marries? What happens to the property they accumulated together?
What is Minority view?
will apply marriage statutes on distribution of property to the case
What is majority view?
most courts have refused to apply divorce statutes to unmarried cohabitants.
In -Nonmarital Cohabitants: Domestic Partnership & Civil Unions, what do they state?
- Some cities & states passed “domestic partner” ordinances or statutes that provided non marital cohabitation with the same legal & status rights as married couples
-Applied to both same-sex & Heterosexual marriage
-Some employers are extending benefits to domestic partners regardless of legislation prior to the legalization of same-sex marriage
What is known from Same-sex marriages?
-Lawrence v. Texas (2003)
-One of the precedents in the movement towards same-sex marriage
-Primarily based on the right to privacy
- Under the federal Defense of Marriage ACT (DOMA), other states did NOT have to recognize a same-sex marriage as valid if it came from a jurisdiction that permits them
- signed by Clinton in 1996
- Many states also passed similar legislation or made amendments to their state constitutions
- DOMA irrelevant after Obergefell in 2015
-U.S. v. Windsor (2013)
- Strikes down Section 3 of DOMA was unconstitutional
-Federal benefits (ex: taxes)
- signed by Clinton in 1996
-Massachusetts was the 1st state to recognize same-sex marriages in 2003
-Now legal in ALL states after the Supreme Court ruling in Obergefell v. Hodges
What comes within Obergefell v. Hodges?
-Due Process Clause (DPC): the definition of “liberty” here is crucial to the majority opinion within Obergefell v Hodges.
-The DOMA (Defense of Marriage Act) is no longer relevant → thrown away in 2016
-Same- sex marriage
-5-4 decision
-Holding (rule of law coming from the case):: 14th Amendment requires a state to:
- License a marriage between 2 people of the same sex
- Recognizes a marriage between 2 people of the same sex when their marriage was lawfully licensed & performed out-of-state
- On June 26th, 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a landmark decision that the 14th amendment requires all states to license marriages between same-sex couples & to recognize all marriages lawfully performed out of state.
- Each petitioner in this sought certiorari, & argued that the actions of the relevant respondent violated the 14th Amendment by either denying them their right to marry or by denying the recognition of their marriage legally performed in another state.
- The liberties protected by the DPC extend to choices that are central to a person’s dignity & autonomy, including intimate choices about personal beliefs and identity
- Banning of same-sex marriage leads to imposing “stigma & injury of the king prohibited basic charter”
- Guaranteed by the Equal Protection Clause
What did civil unions provide?
- Gave many of the legal rights of marriage, without officially sanctioning same-sex marriage
- An option used by some states prior to the legalization of same-sex marriage in the U.S.
What is Formally Statute Marriage?
Obtain a license prior to marriage
Married by an authorized party